Talk

Advanced search

"Chistmas Day is next Saturday..."

(70 Posts)
Valpollicella Mon 13-Dec-10 22:25:14

...said by me to DS this evening.

DP overheard and says, "No, it isn't? It's nearly two weeks away"

Me:"Errrm hmm Well it's not 'this' Saturday is it?"

DP: "No, because this Saturday is 'next Saturday' Christmas Day is on 'the' next Saturday"

Me: <rolls eyes> "Fine, I'll start a thread..."

grin

Please, I know I'm right, aren't I?

And I know I am, I'm only really posting this so I can get some back up and show him the thread

tethersjinglebellend Mon 13-Dec-10 22:27:29

I'm with you sister.

I have lost friends over this one.

mylifewithmangers Mon 13-Dec-10 22:27:33

Sorry, but I'm with your DP.

Don't make it any closer than it has to be. Please.

EatingAngelPie Mon 13-Dec-10 22:27:46

this saturday is next saturday, surely?

Xmas is saturday week.

tethersjinglebellend Mon 13-Dec-10 22:28:12

<sits on hands over thread title>

edam Mon 13-Dec-10 22:28:12

I'd say 'a week on Saturday'.

Clary Mon 13-Dec-10 22:30:16

OK when I hear "next Saturday" on a Monday, I clarify with the speaker which Saturday they mean.

Certainly "the Saturday of next week" is one possible meaning; as is "the next Saturday we get to".

If it was Thursday or so then I think you mean the former; on a Monday it's debatable. To be clear, I personally would say "Saturday next week".

Rindercella Mon 13-Dec-10 22:31:11

Christmas <ahem> grin Day is a week on Saturday.

TheSleepFairy Mon 13-Dec-10 22:31:16

This saturday coming is this saturday.
the following saturday is next saturday & also christmas day.

Valpollicella Mon 13-Dec-10 22:31:31

Thanks Tethers grin

I might just have to do a cut and paste job into Word and print it for him, if it looks like I am wrong <rare>

Valpollicella Mon 13-Dec-10 22:33:26

<bangs head against wall at sp in title>

So sorry.

Please blame the head full of gunk I have courtesy of weird flu thing...

That's also why I need MN back up with this argument...too weary to retaliate as usual grin

Hulababy Mon 13-Dec-10 22:33:35

To me, next Saturday is the next Saturday we get to - so in this case in 5 days time.

Christmas Day is a week on Saturday.

gonaenodaethat Mon 13-Dec-10 22:33:52

I'm with you. Christmas is next Saturday.

ClaireDeLoon Mon 13-Dec-10 22:34:06

I think Saturday week would be Christmas Day, this Saturday would be 18th and next Saurday would be ambiguous.

Hassledge Mon 13-Dec-10 22:35:51

You're wrong, he's right. Sorry.
The next Saturday which will occur is the 18th December. So that's next Saturday. It is the next time that a Saturday will occur.

tethersjinglebellend Mon 13-Dec-10 22:36:06

So, nexters, when people say "this Saturday", what on earth do you think they mean? confused

Hassledge Mon 13-Dec-10 22:37:01

Next:
1. Nearest in space or position; adjacent: the next room.
2. Immediately following, as in time, order, or sequence: next week; the next item on the list.

So that would be the 18th, then.

mylifewithmangers Mon 13-Dec-10 22:37:50

This Saturday and Next Saturday are not mutually exclusive though

Hassledge Mon 13-Dec-10 22:38:03

If someone today said to me "this Saturday", I would have no idea whether they meant the 11th or the 18th. "This" is vague. "Next" is specific.

Starisonthetree Mon 13-Dec-10 22:40:16

I'm celebrating next Saturday, but then the real Christmas a week on Saturday - it's just the family can only get together on the 18th. Sorry think your dp is right

FunnysInTheGarden Mon 13-Dec-10 22:40:16

Christmas is next Saturday, this Saturday is the 18th.

tethersjinglebellend Mon 13-Dec-10 22:40:50

Ok, so "next week" starts when?

Why is Saturday (*this* week) next Saturday?

You're all mad (apart from Valpollicella)

Grrr, Hassledge, you and your witty xmas namechange wink

Preggersplayspop Mon 13-Dec-10 22:41:06

I turned up for a netball match once a week early because of this very issue. Though, i was RIGHT obviously and they were WRONG. I was in primary school and was devastated. I always check what people mean now.

cat64 Mon 13-Dec-10 22:41:37

Message withdrawn

FunnysInTheGarden Mon 13-Dec-10 22:43:39

no no no. This Saturday is for the week in which the Saturday occurs. Next Saturday is in the week following this one. Sorry to post twice, just had to clear that one up............

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now