Advertisement

loader

Talk

Advanced search

The New Contented Little Baby Book

(32 Posts)
Expectantmum Mon 21-Mar-05 14:33:04

Am just about to read Gina Ford's Contented Little Baby Book and just wondered how many others have read it, tried it and found it worked?

CountessDracula Mon 21-Mar-05 14:33:25

<ducks>

Expectantmum Mon 21-Mar-05 14:35:13

What does that mean, good or bad?

mrspink27 Mon 21-Mar-05 14:37:00

read it, thought about it, decided that i am too easy going and spontaneous for her regime!
have friends who swear by it, but also friends who were completely ground into the dirt trying to jump through hoops and her timetable!
think it depends how you live your life and how much routine you like.

vict17 Mon 21-Mar-05 14:37:21

people have very strong views on Gina Ford. Some swear by her rigid routines and others abhor them. I suggest reading it and making up your own mind. Personally I went with what my ds wanted, rather than waking him up at a certain time for feeds etc.

mancmum Mon 21-Mar-05 14:37:38

oh no and it had all be so nice and uncontraversial here for a while....

Stand back and watch the fireworks!!

RudyDudy Mon 21-Mar-05 14:38:15

Well I'll be brave and tell you what I think

When I first tried to read it I couldn't as I found the style really annoying and got very wound up by it. However, I persevered and am really glad that I did. IMHO/E you have to use it to suit yourself and not feel tied to eating a piece of toast at 8am because the book tells you too, etc but I found some of the basic principles, the bedtime routine and having the feeding times as a guideline very useful.

TBH I think that whether or not you get on with the book depends on what sort of person you are. I am quite an organised person who needs some of structure to keep my sanity. Therefore, it worked for me and I am looking forward to using it again in Oct with #2

HTH

CountessDracula Mon 21-Mar-05 14:38:30

Sorry, I just meant that there was bound to be a row about it!

I read it, used some of the routines for about a week and found it so restrictive that I gave up.

mancmum Mon 21-Mar-05 14:38:56

I feel very strongly against it unless you are made of very strong stuff.... if you child fails to stick to her rules, you can feel like a failure and most kids don't stick to the rules... use it a rough guideline ... but don't get obsessed with it...

JoolsToo Mon 21-Mar-05 14:40:14

get your jack boots out then!

RudyDudy Mon 21-Mar-05 14:41:03

I always thought of the routines as something to aim for rather than something which had to be achieved for the book to 'work'. For me this was better than having no clue at all what was going on.

lunavix Mon 21-Mar-05 14:42:38

Well what I think is:

I thought it was far too restrictive ^for us^ , I really couldn't get ds to nap 10.00 - 10.45, play for 30 minutes under his gym, feed for 30 minutes....

He would NOT (and still doesn't!) structure his naps, they come at a different time each day. Also I found it restricting in that there's only certain times each day you can go out - baby groups and activities cut across this. Plus as a quick feeder he'd down a bottle in 5 minutes and I wouldn't know what to do with the other 25!

On the other hand...

It was FABULOUS for structuring his feeds. I followed the routine for the one before his age group (think she suggest this if you are starting later) and even now his feeds have stayed the same. It's great knowing when his bottles would be, and as a first time mum I wouldn't have known how to do this myself.

HTH!

Expectantmum Mon 21-Mar-05 14:43:35

Oh dear, sorry, didn't realise I would pick on such a controversial subject ! As I said, I haven't even started to read it yet, someone gave it to me so thought I would give it a go. Briefly flicked through it and some feeding and sleeping tips sound OK but not sure I could stick to the whole thing.

Feel very bad now for asking!!! Hope I don't start any arguments!

dot1 Mon 21-Mar-05 18:06:11

Hi - I'll add our experiences for what they're worth..!

We used GF for ds1, almost to the letter, as we lived a long way from family, friends, help etc. at the time and found it invaluable for just being a real source of help and support. If you can take it with a bit of flexibility (eg we never had tea and toast at 8am!!) it's fantastic.

Haven't used it so much with ds2 as we're now living near wonderful parents and it's harder to be honest to fit the routine to a second child. Ds2 has pretty much fitted in to a very similar routine anyway...

So, go for it if you need a routine and haven't got much support around you! But don't worry if you find it too restrictive - babies tend to slot themselves into a routine anyway..!

hermykne Mon 21-Mar-05 18:24:24

i used it and its great for the feeding and bedtime.
u dont have tofollow to the last detail
but now with my 2nd, it does make sense, logically.
1st time its not that restrictive with sleep/daytime naps becuase you can travel or go out for walks (burn the weight gain)!

bakedpotato Mon 21-Mar-05 18:31:26

agree absolutely with rudydudy. the style is appalling, and you need to take the restrictiveness and bossiness with bucketloads of salt, but *if you are a certain sort of person* she is a godsend.

there's stuff in there that is invaluable and no one else ever tells you -- like the fact that babies get knackered around 2 hrs after they get up, and need to nap at/just before that point.

she's also brill on explaining how to structure feeds, awake time and sleeps so the baby doesn't end up feeding to sleep, but learns -- in a very jolly, painless fashion -- to go to sleep on its own.

f only midwives and HVs told new mums these things, there would be no threads on the 'sleep' topic.

we're doing it, the Lite version, with No2 (No1 loved it), and so far it's working every bit as well as the rather slavish approach

Prufrock Mon 21-Mar-05 23:12:32

Used it with 2 kids, loved it, but do take it with a pinch of salt. Do an archive search for Gina Ford and you'll know more than you ever wanted to.

Does anyone else miss those pre-yurt days of proper GF arguments?

milge Mon 21-Mar-05 23:38:03

Curiosity got the better of me( and the cat) had to see a MN GF live link

Read it, tried it, it worked for me

<leaves quickly before armed combat begins>

Surfermum Mon 21-Mar-05 23:39:41

I found it in a charity shop and thought "what a funny old fashioned book"! I think I'm the complete antithesis of everything GF is about though. Some people swear by it though, I think it's whatever rocks your boat.

Expectantmum Tue 22-Mar-05 08:53:04

Well, I had a general flick through last night and thought the tips on feeding and naps/sleep were very good, although don't think its something I would stick to. As a first time mum I have absolutely no idea what either I nor baby will be like when the time comes so am just gonna play it by ear. Thanks for the advice ladies!

MissChief Tue 22-Mar-05 09:11:30

Go for it - I was amazed that I would want to work to such routines, but as you say, you can't really predict how life is going to be with baby until it happens, honestly, was a godsend!

desperatehousewife Tue 22-Mar-05 09:20:14

I'm with Bakedpotato and Rudydudy - her style taken with a pinch of salt it was the thing that saved me from utter total insanity. If it hadn't been for Gina I might never have suspected and then had diagnosed reflux in my baby...as the doctor didn't have a clue about it.

Amanda3266 Tue 22-Mar-05 09:50:49

It didn't work for me. My DS had reflux so needed feeding little and often - no way could he keep up with Gina's routine. I read it when I was pregnant - thought it looked good but couldn't cope with it once DS was born. And the tone is seriously annoying - do I really need some childless maternity nurse telling mw what time to eat breakfast etc?
On the other hand there is some good stuff in there - my advice though would be to pick and choose from it. Gina can put any baby into this routine as she's being paid to do it - it's more than her job is worth to pick up the crying baby. You and I on the other hand are mere mortals with a huge emotional tie to the shrieking bundle in the cot and often the urge to pick them up is overwhelming and entirely natural and right.
I broke just about every rule she gave and yet at the age of 2.3 my DS sleeps soundly from 7pm through to 7am every night. Do what feels right and natural and you won't go far wrong.

KathH Thu 24-Mar-05 10:09:06

can i ask a really stupid question but who is Gina Ford - i'd never heard of her with dd1, dd2 and ds1 but whenever i go to the baby clinic with ds2 (6 mths) everyone is always quoting her!

RudyDudy Thu 24-Mar-05 10:29:45

have a look at Gina Ford website

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now