Advanced search

What's for lunch today? Take inspiration from Mumsnetters' tried-and-tested recipes in our Top Bananas! cookbook - now under £10

Find out more

Will you treat all your children the same financially in future years?

(31 Posts)
posieflump Sun 20-Jul-08 09:16:08

So say when you are 70 you get a windfall of 20K - you have 2 children, would you give both 10k? One of them is unemployed, lives at home , has no savings etc. the other is married to a doctor , has loads of money , own home etc. Would you still be fair or give all the money to the one who nees it the most?

aGalChangedHerName Sun 20-Jul-08 09:17:39

On the recieving end of this atm so yes i would treat all my dc the same.

posieflump Sun 20-Jul-08 09:23:39

actually it was your thread that was making me think!
my parents helped my sister and her husna dout loads more than me because I married someone who earnt more and was seen as 'stable' in his job, whereas her and her dh's combined income is quite a bit lower.
I was thinking of my 2 in years to come - if dd married someone very wealthy and ds didn't (or vice versa) I think it would be natural to help the one struggling more wouldn't it?

sarah293 Sun 20-Jul-08 09:29:03

Message withdrawn

aGalChangedHerName Sun 20-Jul-08 09:29:29

Well i can see why my mum helps my brother more. She thinks my dh earns loads and we are secure,but we have 4 dc and my earnings as a CM are in no way huge or secure.

My db has left 2 different partners in the lurch with dc,does not help financially,is a pretty rubbish dad all round.

Has run back to mummy again and getting everything paid again. Being spoiled with money has ruined him i believe. He has no sense of responsibility and no morals.

Left his last partner before xmas,was still sleeping with her until 3 weeks ago,has a new gf whom my mum has staying at her house,and introduced her to his unhappy dc.

My mum aslo doesn't know that he was asked to leave his job last time vecause he is on drugs and the money she is giving him now is going on that!!

Sorry that was a rant,but money can help out,but spoiling someone never helps.

FabioUnblogged Sun 20-Jul-08 09:32:13

Treat them the same. I am the financially unfavoured child, it's pissed me right off. The doctor's spouse may not have as much money as it appears, and it never hurts to have savings.

(Sean Connery is leaving his son fk all of his £50 million fortune.

The tight tartan bastard.)

As you were.

Martha200 Sun 20-Jul-08 09:40:36

Treat them the same also. I am also unfavoured child financially though it no longer bugs me!

with our dcs, 1 is 5, we are going to make sure when ds2 turns 5 he has the same amount of savings in the bank of his brother as now, so we can tell them that.. what happens after that, how much other people give or what they choose to save as they get older is variable but if we run 20k I'd like to think we would split it fairly.

Martha200 Sun 20-Jul-08 09:41:11

maybe they would get it when I pegged it though, at 70 I could easily need the money for other things!!

aGalChangedHerName Sun 20-Jul-08 09:43:18

It's the dc thing that annoys me more than anything tbh.

Secretly buying stuff for my neice,who by the way is lovely and getting her to keep it a secret is wrong whichever way you look at it imo.

I worry that my neice will end up like my db.

I am the opposite with my dc and i worry about that too. Ds1 who is 17 in September had to get a job last October to pay for his treats as i couldn't afford to bankroll him any longer. He is very responsible. Still at school doing highers/advanced highers and working part time when at school and full time in the hols. Has bought himself a lap top and a 42" tv etc. I want him to never ever be anything like my db but i don't want him to feel i don't care etc.

Carmenere Sun 20-Jul-08 09:43:37

Same in the will, might be more helpful to one or other as they grow and need help.

AuntyJ Sun 20-Jul-08 10:40:55

Id leave them exactly the same. It would just create bitterness to the one who recieved less or nothing.

LackaDAISYcal Sun 20-Jul-08 10:53:58

I might help them out financially as there need dictated when I was still alive, but whatever estate I had would be split equally.

but, I'm secretly hoping that they will all be tres successful and loaded and will be keeing me in the manner I'd like to be accustomed to when I'm older wink

Poppychick Sun 20-Jul-08 11:37:56

Unless one was a lottery winner or something then yes totally equally.

notasheep Sun 20-Jul-08 11:41:12

Treat them the same

MrsWeasley Sun 20-Jul-08 11:43:54

Mine would all get the same.

My mother has already told me that my younger brother should/would get most of her money because he is her favourite, not sure if I should be angry or sad. I am and always have been disappointed in her! I find it especially harsh as I used my redundancy money to buy my parents house for them. My dad assures me it will all be alright but I have no faith.

nkf Sun 20-Jul-08 11:45:29

In principle yes but what if they wanted to do very different things. For example, if you are thinking of paying university fees and one wants to be a doctor and the other does Maths. One degree is twice as long. Would you give the Maths student some cash to even it out?

aGalChangedHerName Sun 20-Jul-08 11:46:05

MreWeasly sad for you. How awful especially after you buying the house for them.

Parents are crap at times eh?

nkf Sun 20-Jul-08 11:47:54

Oh, I see. You are talking about dividing up a windfall. Yes, I'd divide it equally. In principle. Would you give money to a child who was going through a wild phase? Or a drug phase? You might think that cash was the last thing they needed.

snickersnack Sun 20-Jul-08 11:56:47

Hmm. Not sure I would - would depend on the children. I don't believe in treating everyone the same just for the sake of it, whether it's financially or in any other way. Agree with LackaDAISYcal that I'd split the estate equally, though.

My parents have always treated us the same, but there's never been a big difference in need between the siblings. On the other hand, they sent my brother to an independent school and not me - there was a good state option for girls but not for boys. Never occurred to me to think that was an issue.

DH's brother and sister have received significant financial help from his parents, and he hasn't. But that's because they've needed help at various points when relationships have gone wrong or they've lost their jobs, and he really hasn't. And he's in no way bitter about it. But they did ask him in advance if it would be an issue, and said if it would be then they'd do it differently.

Uriel Sun 20-Jul-08 11:57:43

Yes I will.

MrsWeasley Sun 20-Jul-08 12:00:06

I have to say that I feel nothing, am numb from years of her silly games and mind bending.

MY mother told me older brother and I that our younger bro was and always would be her favourite. We were between 8-11 when she first started telling us this. Their is about a year between each of us.

As we got older my little Bro actually told us he would use it to his advantage and boy does he. For example: Free childcare for his 2 DC's, regular sleepovers for DC's so that he and his DP can stay out all night. She lends them money, pays for holidays for them all and also takes DCs on holiday with them to give parents a break hmm if DC need anything they are told to ask nanny so she buys toys, clothes, school stuff, the list is endless.

Older Bro has nothing to do with them and has even changed his name to avoid being assoicated with them!

Families eh! arent they great

juneybean Sun 20-Jul-08 12:00:15

I would split it evenly.

As my mum had some..thing for us I don't know what it was, and it matured when I turned 21, so she split it three ways for me, my brother and her and my dad.

My brother owed her alot of money so his third was kept by her (with his permission)

But in effect it was shared evenly

juneybean Sun 20-Jul-08 12:00:15

I would split it evenly.

As my mum had some..thing for us I don't know what it was, and it matured when I turned 21, so she split it three ways for me, my brother and her and my dad.

My brother owed her alot of money so his third was kept by her (with his permission)

But in effect it was shared evenly

georgimama Sun 20-Jul-08 12:04:57

Treat them all equally, anything else risks "rewarding" fecklessness or faiing to recognise the efforts of a more fortunate child. In any case good fortune may not last for the better off child.

My brother has married someone whose parents are comparatively wealthy and she is only child. They will get a lot of money from her parents when they die, and do get a lot of help now. I wouldn't expect my mum to give me more than him to commpensate.

olyoly Sun 20-Jul-08 18:47:05

This is a bit of a sore spot for me. My sister is a bit of a waster, and now she is marrying a waster and they have said that they are just waiting until my parents die so they will collect 'a lot of money.' angry My parents' solution? To offer to buy my sister a new car and house if she will leave this terrible man! This has been a pattern since we were young.

I am in a v comfortable position financially, but it breaks my heart that my parents are seen as a bank and that they perpetuate this view. I would always be fair with money, as anything else creates animosity between the children.

I might like to take my entire family on a trip if the money was mine. Something fabulous so that we would all create memories (or am I dreaming and really we would all fight?) hmm

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: