My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Got questions about only having one child? Find the answers here.

One-child families

An only with an only, thinking about the future...

15 replies

AtLeast · 12/04/2021 11:32

Hi everyone,

I need to get something out, and if anyone has any thoughts, I'd love to hear them.

Some context: My parents had me late - my mother had 2 children from her first marriage, my father had none. They were in their 40s. I was an unplanned surprise, and with a 15 year gap between me and my half-siblings, I was raised as an only.

My parents divorced when I was 14. My father is a very difficult man and we have a fraught relationship. My half siblings have nothing to do with him, so it's just me. He is financially unstable, emotionally manipulative and I find him very challenging. I have often said I wished I had siblings to 'share' him with.

I am close with my half siblings, but their children are older and they do not live nearby.

Now, aged 34, I have one DD aged 3. I have a wonderful DH and I love my family, but I never wanted DD to be an only, based on my experience as an adult only with my own father.

This year, I've had one miscarriage at 13 weeks and more recently a termination for medical reasons after our son was diagnosed with Patau Syndrome and given a prognosis of 3 days. We are currently having genetic counselling.

DH feels the emotional turmoil is too much to risk trying again, and I don't feel that adoption is the right choice for our family, but I am panic stricken about DD being an only. I'm probably being disproportionate about it, but feel completely trapped and like there is no action I take to make this better.

We are engaged and loving parents, with the emotional and practical resources to give her an objectively brilliant childhood, and know we can take practical steps to protect her from some of the financial and organisational burden I feel regarding my Dad, but emotionally, I cannot bear the thought of her being alone as an adult.

How do I process this?

OP posts:
Report
Isitgiroday · 13/04/2021 06:39

Oh gosh, I'm not sure of the answer to this and someone wiser will come along but ultimately you are not your father. You have learned from your experiences (albeit the same experiences that have created this worry!) and know you and your husband have the ability to protect your daughter from what you went/are going though.Flowers
I'm an only, from two only parents (now both deceased) with an only. I can't provide my DD2 with a sibling (she was IVF) and some days feel very envious of others/guilty. I don't know anyone else like me who has so little family but I just have to concentrate on what I have do have and for that I'm incredibly grateful.

Report
Isitgiroday · 13/04/2021 06:41

Also, she won't be alone - she'll have great friends and eventually a great partner and she'll be a strong, resilient woman because she's had loving, supportive parents!

Report
Theworldisfullofgs · 13/04/2021 06:44

I can see it feels difficult. It is highly unlikely that you will be to your daughter as your father was to you. There is also no guarantee if there was other siblings they would share the load. I have lots and did most (all) of the heavy lifting with my dm.

Report
justanotherneighinparadise · 13/04/2021 06:51

Well it’s not for your DH to decide, do you feel you can come with the ‘emotional turmoil’ to try again? We went through so much grief and trauma to try and give my first a sibling. Eventually we managed it and never once did my partner question whether I could cope. We just ploughed on together and weathered the shit storm that cane with it.

Report
JustLyra · 13/04/2021 06:55

@justanotherneighinparadise

Well it’s not for your DH to decide, do you feel you can come with the ‘emotional turmoil’ to try again? We went through so much grief and trauma to try and give my first a sibling. Eventually we managed it and never once did my partner question whether I could cope. We just ploughed on together and weathered the shit storm that cane with it.

Her DH is perfectly entitled to say he feels the emotional turmoil is too much and he doesn’t wish to try again if that is how he feels. There’s nothing in the post to say he’s saying the OP wouldn’t cope. He’s allowed to have feelings of his own.
Report
JustLyra · 13/04/2021 06:56

You are very different to your father so your DD will have a very different experience.

And siblings don’t always mean support. I did all the care for my Nana (we lived with GPs) and I’m one of four and she had two children around as well.

Report
justanotherneighinparadise · 13/04/2021 07:04

@JustLyra it’s meant to be a partnership. He can voice it but it’s not for him to decide whether the OP can cope or not. If the OP says she can’t cope then that’s different. But she hasn’t said that. Instead she sounds utterly traumatised about the prospect of NOT trying again.

Report
Chunkymenrock · 13/04/2021 07:08

Really and truly, children don't NEED a brother or sister. Its no guarantee of anything at all, except more noise, mess and financial implication. Please don't think it's the golden choice.

Report
JustLyra · 13/04/2021 07:09

@justanotherneighinparadise You’ve missed my point completely. He’s not said that the OP can’t cope. He’s said he feels it’s to much for him.

It is a partnership. Which means he is also allowed feelings and a point where he is allowed to say it’s too much.

Report
justanotherneighinparadise · 13/04/2021 07:18

Hopefully the OP will clarify as I assumed he thought the emotional turmoil for her was too great but you’re correct, perhaps he’s talking about himself. That feels like an even more bitter pill to swallo!

Report
alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 13/04/2021 07:25

Well for what's its worth I'm an only with a dad that wasn't brilliant too. But I was always happy to be an only and it has made me very independent which has helped me have a very fun and varied life. My son is also an only, and has never wanted siblings ( he knows what side his bread is buttered!). So it definitely has its plusses!

Report
JustLyra · 13/04/2021 07:27

@justanotherneighinparadise

Hopefully the OP will clarify as I assumed he thought the emotional turmoil for her was too great but you’re correct, perhaps he’s talking about himself. That feels like an even more bitter pill to swallo!

I assumed given she didn’t mention him thinking it was too much for her that he was talking about himself.

As difficult as it is it better he’s being open no honest now, rather than further down the line.
Report
CateTown · 13/04/2021 07:30

I cannot bear the thought of her being alone as an adult

You cannot future proof your DD's adult life with or without siblings. You can raise her to be a strong, independent young woman who goes off into the world determined to make a good life for herself because her parents have instilled in her self esteem and self reliance.

No parent can control the relationship adult siblings have and if you haven't had any or your relationship isn't what you long for, it's easy to idealise siblings and the supportive role they might play.

So, I'd suggest you and your husband give yourselves sometime to grief your bereavement, enjoy your little girl and at a later date you can decide if you want to try for another child because you'd love to have more children and not because you feel obliged to provide a sibling. And trust your DD to embrace life and build a network of friends and maybe her own family one day.

I have an only. She's 16 now and has weathered lockdown admirably because, whilst she's a sociable person with good friendships, she is also content in her own company and has inner resources to draw upon.

The greatest gift you can give a person is a secure, loving childhood where they feel confident to take risks.

Best of luck Flowers

Report
Flittingaboutagain · 13/04/2021 08:19

I'm sorry for your loss, which I understand is very recent if this year and into the second trimester. Your husband may feel differently with a bit more time to grieve. Mine did. If not, I'm not sure how you'll process this.... you might want to turn to the miscarriage association (both of you) to see each others perspective and support each other. There are also some good podcasts out there you could listen to together on grief that night help.

The greatest gift you can give a person is a secure, loving childhood

^ this is great advice and will protect them more than a sibling. Of course it is true that it isn't either/or; people do benefit if they have a sibling who they are close to throughout life. I'm not sure what the downside of having a sibling is if you get on really well, it just isn't guaranteed if you see what I mean.

Report
AtLeast · 13/04/2021 10:08

Thank you so much, everyone, for your responses. I wasn't expecting so many replies to this thread.

@justanotherneighinparadise & @JustLyra - it's a bit of both. My DH wanted our babies as much as I did (do?), but our most recent loss has been especially hard on him. He kept a lot of hope during our early antenatal tests, when things were starting to look bad, and found the eventual diagnosis to be very shocking. There was a lot of waiting around for things to happen which was hard on both of us, but he describes that time as 'waiting to be hit by a train' - we knew that ultimately we would have to make hard decisions, which we did, and will now live with. So, there is definitely trauma there. He dotes on our daughter and is the most wonderful father you can imagine. At the moment he feels he just wants to devote himself to her, but he does also worry about the physical and emotional impact of trying again on me - trying to conceive, the anxiety if we do fall pregnant, having a high risk pregnancy and all that comes with that. I understand that - I worry for him too. It would undoubtedly be very challenging.

It may be that we need more time to grieve, as a PP says, and I may be displacing my grief by over indexing on worry about my DD being an only. I recognise this. Unfortunately, I'm just not finding the 'good' things about being an only to be reassuring right now. 😭

OP posts:
Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.