Esher High or Hinchley Wood?

[lisa17]

Evening! I'm currently looking at secondary schools for my dd and thought I was dead set (as she was) on Hinchley Wood, which thankfully we are in the catchment for. However, our visit tonight to Esher High has thrown a spanner in the works as we both loved it and remarkably, it's now her 1st choice! I know that currently HW is 'outstanding' and Esher is 'Good' according to OFSTED but would really love some more insight into these schools to help make the right decision for her. Hope someone can help me out! TIA