Advanced search

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. Free legal advice is available from a Citizen's Advice Bureau, and the Law Society can supply a list of local solicitors.

Please someone recommend a Bank Account with reasonable charges???

(31 Posts)
Demented Fri 25-Mar-05 14:04:13

I am very, very ! I have just been to check my on-line balance with the Abbey National and I have gone a whole £11 over my overdraft limit! I phoned the number and was connected to a call centre in India somewhere to woman who could barely understand me and I could barely understand her. After about five minutes she eventually managed to tell me that I would be charged £90 for going £11 over my overdraft!!! Three tiny transactions have caused this! I have got to get to the bank today with some money as this is going to get worse (am terrible for switching two or three pound).

Does anyone have an account with better charges than this?

I have NEVER gone over my overdraft before and will certainly try to get these charges reduced perhaps when I visit the counter today as they completely ridiculous!

Demented Fri 25-Mar-05 14:25:29


Are they all like this???

I am currently browsing Martin's Money Saving site and can't see anything better.

nutcracker Fri 25-Mar-05 14:27:12

Nationwide only charge £15 for every transaction when you are overdrawn.

That is disgusting though £90 for 3 items. I am with Barclays and they charge £25 per item but you can only be charged 3 times within a monthly period.

Snugs Fri 25-Mar-05 14:29:28

I think most of them have silly charges if you go over agreed limits - though £90 does sound a little bit steep, IME there is normally a 'capped' maximum in any one month.

I'm with Natwest - mainly because I used to work for them which gives me some advantage of inside knowledge - but they are fairly reasonable.

And their call-centres are UK based!

Socci Fri 25-Mar-05 14:34:19

Message withdrawn

Demented Fri 25-Mar-05 14:41:09

Am currently bugging DH rotten to give me some money (he owes me £25 at the moment anyway) so I can get down there and put it right. £15 a transaction with the Nationwide seems more reasonable to me. Looks like Cahoot (part of the Abbey) seem to have a flat rate charge of £25 for each statement month you are overdrawn, no mention of individual transaction charges.

I was ready for a £25/£30 hit but not this! It's only £11!!!

NomDePlume Fri 25-Mar-05 14:48:42

I'm with barclays and I hate them. But I know as a SAHM with no income (aside from a small monthly direct debit from DH and my child benefit) it will be difficult to switch accounts over, especially with a maxed out -£530 balance . Desperate to pay it off so that I can just move banks and get back in control of my finances again.

serenity Fri 25-Mar-05 14:50:01

Abbey normally let you go overdrawn as a one off without charging you. I'm pretty sure that you can do it once every 6 months.

I'd wait until tuesday and speak to them again - it's a UK call centre during normal working hours.

JanH Fri 25-Mar-05 15:01:18

Alliance & Leicester , Demented - Martin recommends it. Their premium current account pays over 5% interest and atm they pay you up to £50 to open an account!

Agreed overdraft rates are very low and you are only charged interest on the amount o/d on a daily basis. If you exceed your o/d limit and there is a debit they will charge you £25 for it. And you can either do it online or ring up and speak to a British human (in L'pool generally).

JanH Fri 25-Mar-05 15:04:19

btw your bank will be shut today as it is a Bank Holiday - maybe the charge is higher because you will be o/d for 4 days before you can fix it?

When you do speak to someone here tell them you will switch accounts unless they cancel the charge (and then do it anyway, hehehe )

milge Fri 25-Mar-05 15:09:18

First Direct are fab, imho

GeorginaA Fri 25-Mar-05 15:23:57

First Direct are FAB FAB FAB ... can't recommend them highly enough.

flic23 Fri 25-Mar-05 15:32:30

hate the RBS they willingly ripped me off for a 6000 pound loan, i would have got a lower interest rate from yes car credit! They then changed my bank account, i have to pay £15 for the pleasure of having it, they canncelled my overdraft when i changed account but didnt tell me so i suddenly had to find 800 pounds. I then asked for a £200 overdraft as a buffer as I live a long way from the bank. Some snooty cow who was below me in school and had been working in tescos until 6 months before told me no i was high risk. I personnaly dont see the prob if they leant me £6000 and £200 is hardly going to bring the bank to its knees. I have lost count of the amount of £30 charges they have taken because money was in like 2 days to late. The moment my loan is paid which is soon i will take so much pleasure in closing all my accounts and moving to the clydsdale. Rant over.

JanH Fri 25-Mar-05 15:40:51

A&L's over-overdraft charges:

<<If you have an unauthorised overdraft for any 2 days (days in total, not necessarily consecutive) in a monthly charging period, you will be charged £25. If you have an unauthorised overdraft for a further 3 days (days in total, not necessarily consecutive) in a monthly charging period, you will be charged another £25. Unauthorised overdraft charges are capped at £50 per calendar month.>>

So they would charge you £50 for this weekend. It's really bad luck it's happened now.

Ah - also:

<<Customers who allow their account to become overdrawn without approval or exceed their agreed overdraft limit will be charged the unauthorised rate on the entire overdrawn balance.
- Paid item charge £25 per item. Paid items are items Alliance & Leicester pay where you may have incurred or have incurred an unauthorised overdraft (including 'Forced to Pay' items such as guaranteed cheques and debit card transactions).
- Unpaid cheques, standing orders and Direct Debits are charged at £30 per item.>>

If your 3 tiny items were all over the limit A&L would have charged £25 for each one apparently - it's the number of transactions, not the amount of each.

This is First Direct's equivalent:

<<- If during any statement month your overdraft exceeds the agreed limit, an Overdraft Fee will be incurred for the first day the excess occurs. In addition, an Excess Overdraft Fee will be incurred for each subsequent day during the same statement month that further debits increase the excess, or an excess recurs after the overdraft has been brought back within the agreed limit. If at the end of the first working day of the next statement month, there is an excess, even if caused by deduction of overdraft fees incurred during the previous month, an Overdraft Fee will be incurred, with an Excess Overdraft Fee incurred for any subsequent day where there is an increase in the excess or recurrence of an excess during that month. The Overdraft Fee is £30 and Excess Overdraft Fee is £25. Overdraft fees are payable in addition to interest.
- The return of cheques, standing orders and Direct Debits unpaid owing to lack of funds or available overdraft will be charged at; £15 where the total value of the items is less than £40 and £37.50 where the total value of the items is £40 or more.>>

So they would be charging you £40 for the first day and £25 for each subsequent day.

Demented Fri 25-Mar-05 16:02:46

We are in Scotland so at least the Bank was open today (most Scottish branches only take the Monday at Easter). The teller was lovely and said that they were only allowed to take off one of the charges, but she said that she felt it was unreasonable too. She went off into the back room and came back with a plan (I think after checking up on my DH's account and the credit card we have with them ), she said she would fill in a form saying that the Bank had made a mistake with my account making me overdrawn and would reduce the charges down to £30. Making me a very happy bunny (never thought I would say that about £30 bank charges).

Have now made a resolution to sort out my Bank account as I am constantly running it to the hilt and am going to start by reducing my overdraft by £50 when I get paid next week. If I stop running things to hilt then charges should be avoided in the future.

NDP, I am like you, although a WAHM for my DH's company, I'm not most Banks idea of their ideal customer and am not eligible for accounts that require a minimum payment of £1,000 a month.

TBH after looking on Martin's Money Saving site the Abbey is fairly competative as many of the banks want £30 or so and then £25 or so per transaction.

Thanks for all your help, today has been a big long overdue wake-up call!

JanH Fri 25-Mar-05 16:11:06

Oh, I am glad they were open, Demented! (And that you are happy with the £30 charge!)

A&L's Premier current account only requires £500 per month but their charges are the same as the others; OTOH they do at least have British humans on the end of the phone...

pixel Sat 26-Mar-05 02:33:02

I've got a Nationwide Flexaccount and went slightly overdrawn because someone had delayed paying in a cheque I had written so it came out of my account unexpectedly iykwim. When I explained to the building society what had happened they waived the charge and then gave me an agreed overdraft(£100) to stop it happening again. Now if I go slightly over by accident I don't get a letter and it only costs me a tiny amount as long as I sort it out within a few days.

Demented Sun 27-Mar-05 22:13:08

That sounds positive Pixel, I have asked Nationwide to send me one of their leaflets. Funny thing is when I left School and started working I had an account with Nationwide (just a cash card account, not a current account) and ended up leaving them because they started charging for using cash machines other than their own, very often their own was out of order and you had to remember to go into the branch and ask for the charges to be removed from your account.

Surfermum Sun 27-Mar-05 22:18:17

I have always found First Direct brilliant. Their staff are just so helpful and pleasant. And you get straight through to speak to someone - none of this press 1 for this, press 2 for that.

I get a weekly text to tell me what my balance is and they will send me a text alert if I'm starting to get near my overdraft limit.

sunnyskies Tue 29-Mar-05 18:23:17

We have Halifax current account that has a £200 overdraft facility and NOT lots of charges - can't find the actual charges thing (filing cabinet needs a clear out! sorry)

Demented Tue 29-Mar-05 22:30:40

Will check out Halifax too then.

First Direct is an internet only bank, isn't it? I think I really need the option of going into the branch as I don't like the idea of not being able to go in on the day and pay money in if my account is looking like it is going overdrawn.

Demented Wed 30-Mar-05 09:31:02

My account have gone over the overdraft again!!! I work for my DH and he didn't take account of the Bank Holidays (think his business bank was closed on Friday), wages are usually in on the 28th, sometimes sooner!

DH seems a bit blaize about it but it's another three items, I need him to give me some money so I can get down there and rectify it, it just happened today so as long as the money goes in today there shouldn't be a problem (usually)! Grrrrrrrr!!!

tribpot Wed 30-Mar-05 09:44:13

First Direct is an internet and phone bank but is part of HSBC, so you can pay money in at a local branch, although in Scotland branches of HSBC are not all that common of course ....

vickiyumyum Wed 30-Mar-05 09:52:41

demented- i know exactly how you feel, my wages were late going in didn't go in until today because of the bank holidays. so i have 10 fees of £30, which is costing me £300 at the end of next month and i only get paid £500 per month cos i am a student. have spoke to abbey and they are not willing to reduce my charges, she just basically said tough and that i shouldn't have written cheques until the money was there and should have cancelled my direct debits.

Demented Wed 30-Mar-05 15:34:26

vickiyumyum, I am soooo for you! Have you been into your branch? They can apparently lift one or two (can't remember) of the charges as a courtesy. I was told if you phone it depends who you get. I asked today when in (had to lift money out of my DS1's savings account so currently feel really awful about that) if they ever put a ceiling on the charges (some banks limit the charges to £90) and she said no and it wouldn't be the first time someone has come in with hundreds of pounds of charges. IMO it's not fair, I do realise that if I go over my agreed overdraft I should pay charges of some sort but the sort of charges the Abbey has been dishing out are OTT. I really hope you can get it sorted out.

Still looking for a new Bank account, got a leaflet from Nationwide and they charge £15 for going overdrawn and then £21.50 for each item, so certainly for the first item it would be more expensive than the Abbey.

I've not seen an HSBC locally so I think that probably rules out First Direct.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: