Advanced search

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. Free legal advice is available from a Citizen's Advice Bureau, and the Law Society can supply a list of local solicitors.

Which Stakeholder Account for Child Trust Fund ?

(22 Posts)
Chooch Sun 06-Mar-05 08:46:43

Hello - can anyone recommend a good STAKEHOLDER account for a Child Trust Fund ? Anyone a financial expert ?

There is lots of info. and comparison tables on savings accounts on the internet, but as these do not grow as well, I want to go for the share-based STAKEHOLDER account.

From what I have seen the STAKEHOLDER offers from different banks are not very different, so would you simply go with a "name" - i.e go with HSBC because its a huge global bank rather than one you have never heard of (there are a few on the list that provide CTF's that I have never heard of !!) ??

pixiefish Sun 06-Mar-05 09:01:06

Hia Chooch- i'm the same as you- no answers sorry but i know that i want to put the money in stakeholder. The good thing about this is that I've decided to do something with other monies that she has rather than just leave it in savings accounts (not the horses btw )

pixiefish Sun 06-Mar-05 09:05:24

just found this- don't know if it'll help you

Mud Sun 06-Mar-05 09:07:13

I'm putting mine into a tracker fund. I have noticed from the information that L&G are doing one (and I quite like Legal & General's funds) however the way to invest through the CTF source seems to add an extra 0.5% management fee so I am going to ring round directly on Monday

I am going to call L&G, Virgin and Invesco Perpetual I will post what they say

If anyone else wants to investigate tracker funds could you post back their fees (as this is the key determinant ie the lowest fee wins)

maybe together we can crack this?

(I am not an FA or financial person, but am quite financially astute I feel)

Mud Sun 06-Mar-05 09:10:15

I'd like to say I think a 1.5% fee is a rip-off for a tracker account (although probably not for the company as it is very low money for the admin involved with yearly statements)

I will not be adding any more money to the stakeholder, I will put any savings into a seperate fund that I can control and determine when and where the money is spent

Chooch Sun 06-Mar-05 09:11:21

Wow - everone up on a Sunday morning thinking baby money like me !

Me too, I am a lawyer, so quite financially aware, but most certainly not an expert. Also rubbish at adding links on MN Could someone tell me how to do a link here, I have a few things I can share with you, although let's keep going on this thread until we all feel happy with our stakeholder choice ! Thanks so far.

Chooch Sun 06-Mar-05 09:16:21

Mud - you make an excellent point about just going the tracker route. I was considering switching what I have already saved for baby in his child savings account (before CTF existed) into a tracker. So may also put his £250 into a tracker instead of going the CTF stakeholder route. I agree that 1.5 % is too much. I am sure I have seen trackers that charge far less. The FSA website has comparison tables. I would like to do links here, but don't know how to ? Help !

Mud Sun 06-Mar-05 09:20:07

open the page and copy the link in the address bar



then paste your address

finish the url with a \ and type a description of what it is then close with the curly bracket


MunchedTooManyMarsLady Sun 06-Mar-05 09:26:44

do you all think it would be worth sending a letter to number 10 about our concerns about a lump sum landing in our little darlings 18 yo hands? Like others I have concerns that my gorgeous darlings may have their heads turned with a nice sum and spend it on a kilo or something.

Mud Sun 06-Mar-05 09:36:58

no I don't think £250 is going to make that much difference to an 18 year old (bearing in mind what it will buy in another 17 years time even with the increase in value)

but I think if you add the £1,200 a year then you should put it into a fund you can control (not a CTF)

bathmummy Sun 06-Mar-05 09:42:09

MTMML - lol
I am keeping our savings separate too and putting this small amount in a standard account, more options and control that way. I am annoyed that so many companies just see this as a way of grabbing our children’s cash. Felt really patronised at Barclays when I went in to get the up to date info - offering a small stuffed toy as if that would make up my mind for me...How thick do they think parents are?

MunchedTooManyMarsLady Sun 06-Mar-05 09:48:43

So, if I'm following the herd (you guys that is ) which account should I open to save that is NOT a CTF but one that I can guide (control lol) when my gorgeous darlings are 18? Also I need it to be one that I can't get my hands on until they are 18, otherwise I'll use it for other things (all very noble you understand).

MunchedTooManyMarsLady Sun 06-Mar-05 09:50:24

ooh yes, Mud - I wasn't thinking about them blowing £250, it was the added money etc that I was thinking of. I had such visions of uni fees being paid, or cars bought or flat/house deposits paid, then someone said that as the babes themselves get the money directly... well that was my mind gone up the path of nightmares...

jenkel Sun 06-Mar-05 10:51:56

I'm watching this thread with interest. DDs voucher has just come through, think I want to put it into a Stakeholder ctf. Not that I'm grateful for the money to be given to DD but wish they had decided to do something a bit more worthy with it. She has her own savings account, which I will continue with. Just think about the amount of money they have spent out and wouldnt it be better to put all that money into Education, there it will make a difference and all children will benefit. What will £250 be worth in 18 years time!. She has more than that in her own savings account anyway. OK, we are fortunate and not all children have savings but still think all children would benefit if they money was put into education or something similar. Ok rant over now, just need to figure out what to do with it.

Mud Sun 06-Mar-05 11:10:09

Marslady you cannot control the CTF that's the point it goes to the child once they reach age of majority, you can just invest it in the best plan you see fit and then ignore it

other money you want to save for them, I would personally suggest if you don't use up your ISA allowance to put it into a tracker ISA with a low fee and just ignore it (you cannot ring fence it but you can discipline yourself to ignore it )

you could I suppose set up a trust for your child but that involves solicitors and legal fees and prob. not worth it (I wait to be corrected)

listen to me .I have a savings account for DS that is in the closest BS and that's about it, I sound so sorted though need to follow my own advice that's what I need to do

MunchedTooManyMarsLady Sun 06-Mar-05 11:13:41

discipline.... discipline....

Oh dear Lord, I'm so cr*p at that. Will continue to put the money in their N/W BS and give books to my sister.

Open a trust... honey I can barely open my eyes at the moment lol.

Thanks for your advice honey. I hope you manage to take it as well.

Mud Sun 06-Mar-05 11:16:30

at Marslady

..go have a sleep and ignore all children .. it is mother's day after all

(I will never take my own advice though I try)

Chooch Sun 06-Mar-05 12:22:35

Ok ladies - sorry I started all this and then went off to Asda to shop !

Thanks Mud. I will do some useful links later today or tomorrow when DS is napping.

Right now he is blowing rasberries at me (I think he is hungry and fed up ) - so will post later.

Chooch Mon 07-Mar-05 09:48:01

I don't know if you have seen this, but it was mentined on another thread. There are several recommendations by stockbrokers for the stakeholder:


I think the problem with the standard tracker is that it is tax-deductible (unless you wrap it up in an ISA), whereas the CTF is taxfree. But the limit on an ISA is £7,000. So it's still worth paying the 1.5% on a stakeholder CTF (the Govt. has put a cap on the charges, so noone can charge more than 1.5% on a CTF) if you are going to invest the max. of £1,200 per year.

I have emailed an IFA for help, so may be able to tell you more once he gets back to me.

Chooch Mon 07-Mar-05 09:49:55

Sorry, my link hasn't worked.

Chooch Mon 07-Mar-05 09:52:42

have a look at this

Chooch Mon 07-Mar-05 09:53:10

Sorted !

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: