We rely on advertising to keep the lights on.

Please consider adding us to your whitelist.



Advanced search

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. Free legal advice is available from a Citizen's Advice Bureau, and the Law Society can supply a list of local solicitors.

Personal finance expert, Holly Thomas answers your questions

(30 Posts)
RachelMumsnet (MNHQ) Tue 01-Mar-11 14:13:41

Are you looking for ways to get more for your money? Travel rewards scheme Airmiles has teamed up with award winning personal finance journalist Holly Thomas from the Daily Express to answer your questions. With over ten years experience providing top tips on personal finance issues, Holly is happy to answer questions on all areas of money saving and will be offering tips on shopping wisely.

Send your questions to Holly before end of day on Sunday and we'll link to her answers from this page next week.

RachelMumsnet (MNHQ) Thu 17-Mar-11 10:17:51

You can now see the full transcribed Q&A with Holly's answers to your questions here

Holly Thomas Q&A

Trublatmill Thu 10-Mar-11 00:52:36

Whilst I have no reason to question the quality of any advice given by Holly Thomas, when it comes to personal finance (pensions, ISAs etc), Ms Thomas is not registered with the Financial Services Authority (FSA) and therefore not authorised to give financial advice as an IFA would be.

Consequently, should anyone decide to act on one of Ms Thomas's "top tips on personal finance issues" which subsequently goes horribly wrong, they would have no recourse to make a complaint or seek compensation through the FSA or the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS).

I have no axe to grind but just thought this should be brought to peoples attention.

RachelMumsnet (MNHQ) Sun 06-Mar-11 22:45:30

We'll be sending your questions over to Holly tomorrow morning and will be linking to her answers from this page shortly. Thanks to all who sent in questions.

GoldenBeagle Sun 06-Mar-11 17:17:40

Hello smile.
I am 53, have been working since I was in my early 20s, no career break, and have had my NI contributions contracted out since 1994 to Scottish Equitable (now Aeon?) policy that was originally set up as a pension against my mortgage. I now have a repayment mortgage but still pay the Scottish Equitable policy. Should I still be contracting out?

The only other savings I have towards my pension is a L&G Endowment also set up against my original mortgage.

As long as I stay in work I don't need the two policies to pay the mortgage off at end of term.

Thank you!

CradleCrap Sun 06-Mar-11 15:22:07

My son aged 3 was entitled to a Child trust fund, my daughter was born on 1 Jan this year so is not eligible for one. I believe The Junior ISAs that will replace the CTF won't be available untill the Autumn. What can I do with her money? I have a lump sum of £300 and want to put in £10 per month. Ideally I would like it linked to shares rather than a savings account.

CradleCrap Sun 06-Mar-11 15:19:55

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Maiakins Sat 05-Mar-11 16:58:08

Hi. I'm another person worried, as I have no pension. I work freelance and am in my mid-30s. My husband has a small pension, which his employer contributes a bit into too.

What would be the benefit of me having a pension? I put any extra money into the savings bit of our offset mortage instead, into my personal ISA, and into the kids' Child Trust Funds.

Is this wise? Or should I have a pension of my own as well (not that I could afford to put much into it!)?


amidaiwish Sat 05-Mar-11 11:21:27

Also re pensions

dh is a HRT
i am not earning

i have been led to believe there is NO benefit to investing in a pension rather than other investments anymore. infact as we will be forced to buy an annuity then pensions are the least attractive/flexible option. is this correct? (dh is 39, i am 37)

amidaiwish Sat 05-Mar-11 11:20:00

Where do I start with ISAs? What are the different ones, pros and cons?
If i invest in a fund - is it better to go for a simple FTSE tracker with low fees rather than a managed fund. This is all a mystery and meanwhile we have the money sitting in a savings account doing nothing.

makemineapinot Sat 05-Mar-11 08:41:36

Daisy i was told last week at the Job centre that I didn't need ot sign on as my NI contributions would be protected as I was claiming CB.

I would like to ask a wee question about pensions.

I ahve a frozen private pension, a company pension from my last job (PT)with a local council, now I ahve moved I am working 8 hours and am paying into the new local government pension - should I keep my other 2 pensions frozen or transfer them into the new scheme (I really don't earn much in this job at the moment that's why i thought it was best to keep them frozen.).
Thank you.

Guacamole Fri 04-Mar-11 18:11:29

Poxy I phoned HMRC last week and they said this was not the case. Our CB goes into DHs account, but I'm on maternity leave and thought if I changed it to me it would keep my NI protected, they said no.

Poxykids Fri 04-Mar-11 08:49:25

Daisy, I'm pretty sure that if you claim child benefit then your NI payments are protected.

I think that is one of the objections to means testing it.

Could be wrong though.

DailyDaisy Fri 04-Mar-11 05:12:16

I haven't made any National Insurance contribution for about 6 years (went freelance and then stay at home mum). I've read that this will effect any state pension entitlement in the future. Can I make up the contributions / is it worth it?

Guacamole Thu 03-Mar-11 19:30:15

I also have a pension question...
I have worked for the NHS since 2000 and have been contributing to their pension from the beginning. I'm currently on the 1995 section, but I have to decide whether to move on to the 2008 section by May of this year. I've read the leaflet provided and cannot see any benefit to moving on to the 2008 section at all, it's very give with one
hand and take with the other. I'm tempted to just ignore this is happening and therefore remain on the 1995 section (which is a final year salary scheme). Do you know anything at all about this, don't worry if you don't, I realise it's very specific?
Thank you.

cornerstone75 Thu 03-Mar-11 15:56:44

Dear Holly,

Not sure if this comes under the remit, it is personal finance!

We are currently renting and letting our previous home which we had outgrown. We want to sell up and buy a permanent place in the next few months.
We are about £15k in debt for various reasons (studies,childcare costs etc) and we are thinking of selling our property and using some of the proceeds to clear the debt. This would obvs then affect our deposit for a new home.
Would you agree this is a sensible option or would it be better to attempt to get a bigger mortgage when we buy and cling on to every penny of the deposit?

Thanks in advance,

raiseaneyebrow Thu 03-Mar-11 14:36:53

Hi Holly

I want to get a pension (I'm self-employed) but genuinely have no idea how to get one. I don't really trust pensions advisers not just to sell me the one that nets them the highest commission.

So how should I go ahout choosing a pension - or would I be better off with ISAs for example? Can I cash in ISAs when the time comes and buy an annuity?


vickibee Thu 03-Mar-11 14:34:17

Can you please explain the cahnges to child and WTC from april. Will we all be much worse off than last year all other circumstances remaing unchanged? (income childcare costs etc)There is no info available on HMRC website. it just lists changes to the elements which means nothing to most people

goldenticket Thu 03-Mar-11 12:00:21

Is there anywhere on the web that has an impartial "Dummies Guide" to pensions? I've got my head firmly in the sand about mine because I just do not understand them. Any advice very gratefully received smile

Also, if I;ve got an offset mortgage, is there any point in me having separate savings e.g. an ISA or does that totally defeat the reason for having the offset??

DinosaurRumpus Thu 03-Mar-11 11:43:08

I second LemonDifficult's question about heating oil. The cost is crippling us at the moment. We too are rural so no gas supply to village.

My husband's company have gone down to a 3 day working week due to lack of work so I'm watching with interest the questions / replies here....

NonnoMum Wed 02-Mar-11 21:38:22

Maybe a bit unethical but needs must when it comes to faaamlee.

When the CB changes come in, we will just be around the cut off point.

DH is only a teacher so we aren't exactly rolling in it and the CB goes a long way with our 3 kids (4 if you include the teenage DSS but we won't go there as no bearing on CB).

I heard something about making extra pension payments or something to keep under the cut off point?

Any advice?

thank you

Lauri22 Wed 02-Mar-11 21:10:41

Another grocery tip: do your weekly shop in a smallish store instead of the local jumbo Tesco. Its the same effect as the above poster mentions - the total spend will be less because you are not tempted to buy dozens of unnecessary items

sobloodystupid Wed 02-Mar-11 20:20:22

dh works part time (not thru choice - and will soon be let go about 4 months time. he will do all childcare if he can't find work ,as I work full time and am relatively well paid. How do we work out if it is better financially that he doesn't work(am sneakily hoping that it is as he is better childminder, cook, cleaner etc than me!)

missusp Wed 02-Mar-11 17:11:28

Not a question but a tip.
Do your grocery shopping online. Save £££ because I plan the weeks menu, only buy what I need so little or no waste and save fuel (how much shock). I sometimes have to pay for delivery but this is easily offset by what I have previously wasted or bought on impulse!

ethelina Wed 02-Mar-11 16:22:41

We will shortly be going down to one wage as I will not be returning to work from Maternity Leave.

Can you suggest a good budget planner to allow us to plan for day-to-day outgoings?

BoSho Wed 02-Mar-11 15:04:09

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now