Advanced search

lodger in child death case wins appeal

(28 Posts)
duelingFANGo Tue 27-Oct-09 14:05:48

story (didn't want to put Baby P in the title)

I am kind of glad about this. It seemed a bit over the top to give him an indeterminate sentence as there is no evidence he was involved in any of the abuse.

PixiNanny Tue 27-Oct-09 14:29:14

Hang on, why did the parents get lesser sentences than him in the first place?! This system is screwed up.

PixiNanny Tue 27-Oct-09 14:29:29

sorry, one of the parents.

PixiNanny Tue 27-Oct-09 14:31:15

And they're getting new blooming identities?! This country absolutely disgusts me.

Jujubean77 Tue 27-Oct-09 14:32:44

I thought he was pivotal to the abuse, I thought I read he actually spurred it all on.

thedollshouse Tue 27-Oct-09 14:36:42

They are getting new identities because there is a risk to their lives if they don't. I couldn't care less about them and would not lose any sleep if they were killed but as a society we have a duty to protect the vulnerable which they will be. Shame we didn't also offer that same protection to their son. sad

duelingFANGo Tue 27-Oct-09 15:08:52

I read that he failed to alert the authorities but he did tell the parents to take the child to hospital.

Jujubean77 Tue 27-Oct-09 15:11:21

The abuse accelerated when he moved in.

AngryFromManchester Tue 27-Oct-09 15:11:53

I thought the lodger was the partners brother? and they had tortured even their own grandmother before this? <goes all daily mail>

duelingFANGo Tue 27-Oct-09 15:18:06

From what I remember he moved into the house only 6 weeks before the child died.

While I think his part in not reporting them and other things in his life are wrong (having a 15 year old girlfriend for example) I am not sure that there was evidence that he abused the child himeslf.

thedollshouse Tue 27-Oct-09 15:19:53

He must have played a part in the abuse, he wouldn't have be given that sentence otherwise.

Jujubean77 Tue 27-Oct-09 15:21:38

Yes he definately played a part in the abuse, albeit by spurring on his brother. Isn't he also on trial for the assault on a 2 yo girl?

fifitot Tue 27-Oct-09 15:27:03

The news report on bbc is confusing. He does get an indeterminate sentence but the length of the mimimum has been cut. At least this means he won't get automatic release.

I can't believe what some of the remarks from the judges are. He is 'feckless' and 'irresponsible'. Oh I see that's what you call someone who tortures and terrifies a baby.

Idiot judges.

duelingFANGo Tue 27-Oct-09 15:28:29

"on the orders of the judge, Stephen Kramer QC, the jury found the mother and Owen not guilty of murdering the baby on August 3 last year."

and technically - he hasn't been given that sentence ... it's been overturned on appeal in a court of law.

duelingFANGo Tue 27-Oct-09 15:31:28

fifitot - I think you are wrong.
the Guardian reports it as "Jason Owen, 37, was originally given an indeterminate sentence for public protection – with a minimum term of three years – at the Old Bailey in May. Three judges at the court of appeal in London allowed his appeal against the indefinite term of imprisonment, and replaced it with a sentence of six years' imprisonment"

so he doesn't have an indeterminate sentence at all.

Lulumama Tue 27-Oct-09 15:33:35

i think he is culpable for not doing anything to help the child. telling the 'parents' to take him to hospital, but not doing anything himslef makes him culpable

duelingFANGo Tue 27-Oct-09 15:36:44

I think he is too, but I think the previous sentence was probably a bit too much. Not that I think 6 years is enough either. Maybe if he is waiting to be tried for other stuff he will stay in longer?

fifitot Tue 27-Oct-09 15:45:18

Well the Guardian might be more accurate, the BBC site is confusing.

If he did get a determinate sentence of 6 years he will be out in 3 automatically. Some sentence for what happened to that baby.

Lulumama Tue 27-Oct-09 15:47:15

i think he should have a longer sentence, he was culpable in as much as he did not proactively try to protect baby P, he was on the run with a 15 year old and had made her a hiding place, should hte police have come looking.. i think he is a danger to children and on that basis, needs a long sentence and / or intensive help/probation/tagging etc..

AngryFromManchester Tue 27-Oct-09 15:51:47

they never got charged for torturing their own grandmother

anmd yes, how old was he to be having a 15 yr old girldfriend?hmm

I am not at all sensationalist but I think they need to be made a spectacle of. This country is going down the pan. peoples 'normal' behaviour is horrendous and unluckily their whole charade of 'normality' ended in several children being abused and one dead.

benjysmum Tue 27-Oct-09 16:04:29

How is his behaviour different from leaving the scene of an accident (except for being a thousand times worse)? I think not reporting abuse should be criminal especially as he could have done it anonymously.

Besides if he's at that much risk, then surely jail is the best place for him. Permanently. With any luck, all the other criminals in there will make his life miserable.

DollyPS Wed 28-Oct-09 01:29:44

the automatic half sentence is only if the parole board let him out and he has shown remorse.

He should of got longer as he did nothing to help that little boy.

He is as bad as P parents even if he only moved in 6 weeks before so what he knew what was happening and sat back and did nothing at all.

I better stop now as I will just rant.

fifitot Wed 28-Oct-09 08:25:04

Dolly that used to be the case - not now. Since the 2003 criminal justice act unless someone is serving an indeterminate sentence they automatically released. Yes they are on licence until the end of the sentence and can be recalled at any time but the parole board has no say at the release stage.

Parole board only involved now in indeterminate sentences.

sarah293 Wed 28-Oct-09 08:28:45

Message withdrawn

serajen Wed 28-Oct-09 13:28:31

Am with you, Riven, the whole setence thing sickens me, leave them to bloody rot, they'll all be out in a few years, max, this country's justice system is in a sorry state

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: