Talk

Advanced search

Hurrah! Law Lords unanimously back Debbie Purdy (assisted suicide case)

(9 Posts)
edam Thu 30-Jul-09 17:22:39

she sounded sooooo happy on the news, was lovely to hear her excitement

RealityIsHavingAPartay Thu 30-Jul-09 17:28:01

Message withdrawn

PortBlacksandResident Thu 30-Jul-09 17:29:58

Thank goodness for common sense.

edam Thu 30-Jul-09 17:32:17

I do hope the DPP responds generously and not in a grudging fashion.

Of course it's enormously difficult and there have to be protections to avoid anyone being coerced, but it is a striking anomaly that suicide is not a crime but assisting a suicide is.

Comes down to the fundamental right to self-determination IMO - people have the right to decide to kill themselves.

edam Thu 30-Jul-09 17:32:50

(Well done those Law Lords, btw!)

sassy Thu 30-Jul-09 17:33:50

Oh good.

About time.

wb Thu 30-Jul-09 19:01:08

edam - I agree with you, but actually all Debbie has asked for is to have the law clarified. Imagine having to fight so hard just for that.

Frasersmum123 Thu 30-Jul-09 19:12:19

This is the best news I have heard in a long time, I saw her on Sky today and she looked so relieved.

edam Thu 30-Jul-09 20:49:56

yes, I know, wb. Was just mentioning some of the stuff that surrounds the case, rather than the strict legal turning point.

I can see the DPP might have thought it was preferable to leave it as a grey area, with each decision made on the facts of the relevant case. A clear policy risks being too harsh, either 'we will uphold the law and prosecute anyone who accompanies people to Switzerland' or the abolition of assisting suicide as a crime - which would risk people being coerced.

But in fact all that does is leave people like Debbie Purdy twisting in the wind, facing the horrible prospect of having to journey and die among strangers, or equally horrible prospect of risking her husband's freedom.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now