Talk

Advanced search

Woman failed driving test because she drove through a puddle and splashed a pedestrian.......

(27 Posts)
FAQ Tue 09-Sep-08 07:46:39

here

Is it just me, or is that really bizarre - I mean with this recent wet weather there must be lots of puddles around, and if you were to try and avoid all of them (to keep the pedestrians dry) the risk of causing an accident must be quite high???

TwentiethCenturyHeffa Tue 09-Sep-08 07:54:40

A friend of mine once failed because there was a pedestrian walking on the roundabout (a confused old lady). He stopped so that he didn't run her over and failed because you can't stop on a roundabout. He said that the tester was very apologetic but had no choice. I was a little bit dubious about whether it was possible to fail for that since it seemed so ridiculous.

Much less ridiculous than this story though.

southeastastra Tue 09-Sep-08 08:14:57

it's not that hard to drive slowly through puddles and avoid splashing pedestrians though.

Upwind Tue 09-Sep-08 08:18:17

Depends on the splashing. A white van man recently deliberately splashed me to the point that my ear was blocked with water and I was drenched from head to toe. I had to go home to shower and change and it ruined my day.

If the driver was being observant she should have at least slowed down when driving through the puddle at the bus stop.

FAQ Tue 09-Sep-08 08:18:38

but you can fail your test for "driving too slowly"! Can't win can you really

Moral of the story I guess is don't sit your test on a rainy day grin

Upwind Tue 09-Sep-08 08:20:12

For driving too slowly yes, but probably not for slowing down briefly to avoid splashing a pedestrian.

I have a theory that you are more likely to pass if you explain why you are doing whatever grin

umberella Tue 09-Sep-08 08:20:16

lol! i failed my first test on about a million different faults, but this wasn't one of them!

FAQ Tue 09-Sep-08 08:24:51

Upwind - after the rain the last couple of days the roads round here were full of puddles - they would have to have driven slowly constantly to avoid splashing anyone.

And I've had people slow down to "avoid" splashing me, and despite going at a snails pace I've still got wet grin

belgo Tue 09-Sep-08 08:28:39

If a pedestrian gets soaked because of a car driving through a puddle, then I think they can take the case to court (not sure how you can prove it though).

I think it depends on the circumstances. It is rather irritating to get your clothes soaked with dirty water, and I'm sure the driving instructor used her own judgement as to how the learner driver should have handled the situation.

stitch Tue 09-Sep-08 08:31:11

faq, its a case of noticing whats going on aroujdn you. if htere are pedestrians around, then you need to be aware of how your driving will affect them. and splashing them with water is not being safe.
very hmm at the roundabout old lady story. he was being safe there surely

Jacaranda Tue 09-Sep-08 08:31:35

I think you're right Belgo I've heard that before too.

jenkel Tue 09-Sep-08 08:39:00

I also always thought that you could take somebody to court that had driven through a puddle and splashed a pedestrians.

As somebody who walks 2 young children to school along a very puddley road, it is very annoying, and quite often we have had to come home and get changed again and kids are late for school, its got so bad that I am almost considering driving the car when it rains just to avoid getting drenched by passing cars.

FAQ Tue 09-Sep-08 08:44:08

but stitch if the road is full of puddles, and a car driving at the same speed as I'm walking managed to splash me with muddy water surely it's just not practical to "avoid" the puddles all the time??

And FGS what is this country coming to that people take drivers to court for splashing them with water.

Shall I take the parents of the little sod darling who jumped in a massive puddle right next to me yesterday and soaked me to court too?

Just seems really odd to me.....

Upwind Tue 09-Sep-08 08:48:15

<Suspects FAQ of wantonly splashing pedestrians>

Tortington Tue 09-Sep-08 08:50:34

what you supposed to do drive around the puddle

stop until the rain dries up?

no drive in wet weather

fucking redic

FAQ Tue 09-Sep-08 08:52:00

Upwind - I don't drive - did start learning, but then moved house and didn't see the point (live within 10/15 minute walk of everything) grin

TwentiethCenturyHeffa Tue 09-Sep-08 09:29:15

Stitch - apparently the lady was right in front of the car so if he hadn't stopped, he would have hit her. It always sounded so unfair that I'm not sure whether he just didn't want to admit he'd failed. But I've never even taken a driving test so I have zero knowledge about it.

SaintGeorge Tue 09-Sep-08 10:03:55

She didn't fail for splashing the pedestrian.

She failed for not stopping and exchanging details.

Upwind Tue 09-Sep-08 10:09:26

Fair enough FAQ, I drive every day (mostly on puddly roads this year) and don't believe I've ever splashed a pedestrian. The worst puddles are at bus stops and it is easy to slow down so you don't splash.

I am guessing this outraged woman really drenched the unfortunate pedestrian.

hifi Tue 09-Sep-08 10:21:56

my driving instructor also said you could be fined up to 7k.

edam Tue 09-Sep-08 14:08:39

Good! I hate bloody drivers who soak pedestrians. There used to be a big pothole in the road outside ds's nursery. If you were buzzing to get in it was a real game of cat and mouse with passing cars - shall I leap out of the way and miss my chance to be let in, or stand my ground and get soaked head to foot?

RubyRioja Tue 09-Sep-08 14:14:30

Do you not think the candidate was perhaps just not a safe driver and the examiner pounced on something to fail her. I think it is possible for a driver to not actually do anything wrong, going through the motions, but not actually to be quite aware enough or confident enough to drive safely?

BTW took me ages to pass, and I would not have exchanged details, but would probably have stopped to apologise if had soaked someone.

Kevlarhead Tue 09-Sep-08 18:55:14

Failure to drive with due care and attention... perfectly reasonable to fail her.

DontlookatmeImshy Tue 09-Sep-08 19:02:44

My driving instructor told me it can be classed as 'assault'. Again, nit sure how you'd prove it though.

DontlookatmeImshy Tue 09-Sep-08 19:03:25

'not' not 'nit' hmm

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now