Talk

Advanced search

Should they have shown this??

(30 Posts)
Freckle Sun 07-Sep-08 08:59:21

I was watching the breakfast news this morning on BBC1. They had a report about Amir Khan being knocked out in the first round of his fight last night.

They showed one punch to his head in slow motion and the effect on his head and face made me feel quite ill (am not normally squeamish). They then proceeded to show several more punches which knocked him down and him trying to get up but clearly unable to control his limbs. Was it really necessary to show this so graphically? Fortunately none of my children was in the room, but, if I found it distressing, how would it have affected a child? Showing those images did nothing to enhance the report at all.

Or am I being too picky??

SoupDragon Sun 07-Sep-08 09:00:36

I think it's completely unnecessary.

belgo Sun 07-Sep-08 09:02:02

I wouldn't expect to see that on BBC on a sunday morning.

giddykipper Sun 07-Sep-08 09:02:17

I saw it too and was quite shaken by it - particularly the slow motion shot which showed how distorted his head became when hit. I'm not sure how I feel about it being shown, I can completely see your point. It did serve to show how brutal boxing is as a sport though.

belgo Sun 07-Sep-08 09:02:27

and agree with Soupdragon, it's not necessary either.

Cies Sun 07-Sep-08 09:05:33

Agree with you all. It´s unnecessary and would also make me feel a little giddy if I saw it I´m sure.

GreenMonkies Sun 07-Sep-08 09:17:44

Like boxing in general it's totally uneccessary.

I don't understand how anyone can find it entertaining to watch, or consider it sport.

Freckle Sun 07-Sep-08 09:17:49

Maybe I'll complain then. I wasn't sure if I was just being a bit sensitive - which I'm not normally. It just made me feel ill, particularly the slo-mo shot.

GreenMonkies Sun 07-Sep-08 09:18:41

you see, it upsets me so much I can't evenspell unnecessary! blush

LittleBella Sun 07-Sep-08 09:25:42

I think it's a good thing they show it. It shows just how dangerous and horrible boxing is and if it brings it home to people who think it's OK because it allows a handful of poor men to escape poverty, what a grotesque and insulting response to poverty that is, then good. A few more people might have been won over to the idea that boxing should be phased out because of seeing that clip.

kittywise Sun 07-Sep-08 09:28:25

Prob not nescessary, but ds1 (10) is starting boxing classes next week, he can't wait!

Freckle Sun 07-Sep-08 10:03:17

Well, I've complained, but doubt it will do any good.

I agree that, as a piece of propaganda showing boxing as a brutal and vicious sport, it was very good, but that clearly wasn't their aim. It was meant to be an illustration of the news report and should have carried a warning.

notsoteenagemum Sun 07-Sep-08 10:23:51

I think the news is always showing unnecessary images. I think its horrible when they show injured people in wars etc like when they showed the baby being treated in a Hospital in Georgia.
It's not that I want to be shielded from such things but I alays think it's undignified for the people they are showing to have news reporters and cameras shoved in their faces. They ca tell you whats going on witout the images.
I can't stand boxing thankfully its always on in the middle of the night.

combustiblelemon Sun 07-Sep-08 10:26:20

Rightly or wrongly it is classed as a sport. During the Olympics there was live boxing shown in the middle of the day. I suspect that the BBC will view it on the same level as showing cricket highlights or the Grand Prix winner crossing the finish line.

Moomin Sun 07-Sep-08 10:33:45

I complained once about something that was on the bbc lunchtime news. I had to ring up and spoke to one of their operators in scotland. By tea-time it had been amended and the offensive bit taken out.

so don't think it's not worth it - give it a try.

Freckle Sun 07-Sep-08 12:26:03

I understand that they would show the boxing, but to show that particular shot in slow motion was entirely unnecessary. Also the following shots were gratuitous. They could have shown the knock downs in isolation without focussing on his dreadful inability to even stand up afterwards.

edam Sun 07-Sep-08 12:27:56

Seems a bit strong for breakfast news but agree it might bring home to people what boxing is REALLY about.

Overmydeadbody Sun 07-Sep-08 12:29:54

Not necessary.

I have a thing about news in general though and don't like DS being within earshot of it let alone actually watching it. Mayby ober the top, but it always affected me really badly as a kid and I want to shelter DS from those worries.

georgiemum Sun 07-Sep-08 12:31:08

I really though this thread was going to be about the helicopter tv newsteam who transmitted live a woman swimmer being chased ashore by a shoal/flock/gang of sharks.

roisin Sun 07-Sep-08 12:34:26

I didn't see this, but agree with Edam it might make people realise what happens in boxing. That is what it is about.

I can't stand it at all, and would never ever have boxing on the TV. Even if it comes on in a news report I turn it straight off. I find it thoroughly unpleasant and it has no place in my civilised house.

kittywise Sun 07-Sep-08 15:03:15

Well I hope ds1 enjoys his first boxing session tomorrow.

GreenMonkies Sun 07-Sep-08 15:38:31

Roisin, did she get away, or did the sharks eat her live on tv??

GreenMonkies Sun 07-Sep-08 15:39:57

oops, I mean Georgiemum!

Although I'm completely with you Roisin, I won't have boxing in my house, not even om the Wii.

georgiemum Sun 07-Sep-08 16:00:37

Oh she got away luckily. I couldn't believe they'd show this live...

Freckle Sun 07-Sep-08 16:10:49

If the purpose of the report was to show boxing for what it is, I wouldn't have a problem provided a warning was given. But it wasn't aiming to do that. It was merely a bit of video to illustrate the news report and, as such, was gratuitously violent and graphic.

I don't normally have boxing on the television and wasn't really watching intensely, just gazing at the television in an early morning on a Sunday haze. But that clip really shook me.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now