Talk

Advanced search

17 year old found starved to death in Birmingham

(177 Posts)
PinkPussyCat Wed 21-May-08 14:45:43

sad

Just heard about this on the lunchtime ITV news... Apparently there were several other emaciated children found at the scene following a call to the emergency services.
They don't have any more details than that atm.

How can stuff like this be happening in the UK in 2008?sad

eenybeeny Wed 21-May-08 14:47:39

were they homeless kids? or had been abused? its awful!

belgo Wed 21-May-08 14:47:55

I think you mean 7 year old. here

squeaver Wed 21-May-08 14:48:00

Seven year old actually I think. Even worse...

PinkPussyCat Wed 21-May-08 14:49:14

Apologies for the typo - must preview!

Joash Wed 21-May-08 15:00:19

'Stuff like this' happens all the time, but we don't always get to hear about it. sad

PinkPussyCat Wed 21-May-08 15:02:24

Why do you think this one has been singled out then, Joash?

eeewahwoowah Wed 21-May-08 15:13:16

About 10 years ago a little girl in our town was found dead having suffered terrible abuse at the hands of her parents. It got small mention in the local press and that was it. I have no idea why some cases get widely reported on and others never do.

Mercy Wed 21-May-08 15:13:30

PPC, unfortunately it seems there will always be a few parents who neglect their children(either wilfully or just inability)

cestlavie Wed 21-May-08 15:17:29

How the hell is the charge they're contemplating one of neglect? Surely your starting point in any case like this is a charge of manslaughter.

marmadukescarlet Wed 21-May-08 15:18:42

between ona and two children die from abuse and neglect in the home

marmadukescarlet Wed 21-May-08 15:19:45

that should be one and should have contained the words each week

<must preview>

Mercy Wed 21-May-08 15:27:19

god, that's scary reading marmaduke.

marmadukescarlet Wed 21-May-08 15:29:48

Mercy, I found the figures on the number of under 1's hit weekly most shocking.

marmadukescarlet Wed 21-May-08 15:32:00

I phrased that wrongly, because the death of up to 2 children per week is actually more shocking (along with most of the other facts on there) but I just find it so hard to believe that so many people would hit babies.

Joash Wed 21-May-08 15:32:10

I didn't say that it had been singled out, I meant that things like this happen more often than people realise, but it is only the cases that make the national media that we hear about.

madamez Wed 21-May-08 15:41:49

THe news piece doesn't say the child 'starved'. 'Neglect' can mean that the parents didn't seek medical treatment for superstitious reasons (christian scientists, JWs etc). The death of a child is always sad but it's generally a good idea to know the fact before you start filling your knickers over the Horrible WOrld We Live In.

cestlavie Wed 21-May-08 15:55:15

Madamez: neglect should only be applied to situation in which a parent fails to provide a child either physically or emotionally. A situation in which the child dies as a result of 'neglect' should see a charge of negligent manslaughter... and failure to see treatment for religious/ superstitious reasons would quality for the same (or, I suppose, manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility or insanity).

dittany Wed 21-May-08 15:55:52

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

sweetbean Wed 21-May-08 16:08:47

The Parents should be shot !!!!

PinkPussyCat Wed 21-May-08 16:09:39

Madamez - I was only stating words used by the ITV news at the time.

itsahardknocklife Wed 21-May-08 16:28:14

I just can't comprehend how parents can do that. It's so sad.

tiredemma Wed 21-May-08 18:58:47

I was horrified to see this on the news.

How can people not notice emaciated children????

lilyloo Wed 21-May-08 19:57:15

This is so sad apparantly she had been out of school to be home ed for 3 months so no noe had seen her.

WrongSideOfTwenty Wed 21-May-08 20:08:33

I was just going to post about this, it's terrible sad

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now