Advanced search

Nice to know the courts take domestic violence so seriously... not.

(91 Posts)
McEdam Tue 21-Aug-07 22:04:31

man brands his wife with an iron and walks free

Outrageous. Apparently the judge said the husband was too busy working to do a community sentence, and wouldn't offend again because his wife had left him. Good grief.

TotalChaos Tue 21-Aug-07 22:12:08

yes, saw an article about this today and was absolutely appalled.

Kathyis6incheshigh Tue 21-Aug-07 22:12:33

bloody hell.

Heathcliffscathy Tue 21-Aug-07 22:12:49

don't want to read it.

Bubble99 Tue 21-Aug-07 22:14:12

I saw this. There has to be an appeal, surely?

McEdam Tue 21-Aug-07 22:16:14

It must be a prime candidate for that newish right of appeal against lenient sentences. I hope. If anyone in the judicial section gives a toss.

McEdam Tue 21-Aug-07 22:16:40

system, I mean

SenoraPostrophe Tue 21-Aug-07 22:16:50

well he is a cambridge graduate on 90k a year.

perhaps he would have got more than a 2k fine if he had been a bricklayer?

Carmenere Tue 21-Aug-07 22:17:02

What kind of message does this give

Bubble99 Tue 21-Aug-07 22:17:12

Judge mentions circumstances that may have 'provoked' the attacks.

mosschops30 Tue 21-Aug-07 22:17:32

that because most judges are old cunts who let men literally get away with murder.

This country sucks

<and breathe mosschops, breathe>

snowleopard Tue 21-Aug-07 22:18:03

That is shocking. The poor woman, to have that happen and be humiliated in court by the judge suggesting the "circumstances of the marriage" somehow made it understandable.

I also noticed how the DM described her as "Mrs Read, who has reverted to her maiden name Axe" So why not call her Ms Axe, eh? No no, have a pic of her too and caption it "Elizabeth Read". They just can't help themselves can they.

berolina Tue 21-Aug-07 22:19:08

exactly what I was thinking, snowleopard.

WaynettaSlob Tue 21-Aug-07 22:22:52

Excuse my French, but that is fucking disgusting
I cross paths with many management consultants and my God, if his company EVER comes near me, they shall be left in no doubt as to my opinion of them if they continue to employ him.

tatt Tue 21-Aug-07 22:26:54

that man is an obvious risk to any woman who gets involved with him. It's a disgrace and there should be an appeal against the leniency of the sentance.

Hurlyburly Tue 21-Aug-07 22:29:25

Okay this is bad. Really bad. He is a total tosser who should have had a custodial sentence. It is another instance of class discrmination and I am ashamed that a Cambridge education means a get out of jail free card.

I am consoling myself with the thought that his career is effectively over - in that sort of field, no-one will employ a man with a criminal conviction for violence. His firm will squirm and either let him go now or quietly make sure he exits stage left in a few months' time.


SueBaroo Tue 21-Aug-07 22:31:41

well, a busy man's got to have a shirt ironed, hasn't he?

Tell you what, given that I expect Judges to give adequate sentences for despicable crimes, and this one hasn't, I feel I'm within my rights to shove his gavel up his mysogynist arse.

McEdam Tue 21-Aug-07 22:44:38

I am so cross about this I have emailed the Attorney General, Baroness Scotland, about it. The AG has the power to review unduly lenient sentences. So I hope this one is drawn to her attention.

Good God, we have at long last got to the point where racism is seen as an aggravating factor, why is violence against women still somehow trivialised?

divastrop Tue 21-Aug-07 22:44:47

well,what did she expect?she was his wife,it was her job to make his sandwiches and iron his shirts.of course she should be punished for not doing it.and he must be a decent bloke cos he earns 90k a year.he cant be a wife-beater,they are all on the dole or working down t'pit,no?

i get the impression the judge has been around since the days when it was legal for a man to beat his wife with a stick and has just forgotten to die.

i wonder what sort of sentence he'd have got if he'd attacked a stranger in the same way?or a male friend/collegue?

LaDiDaDi Tue 21-Aug-07 22:48:55

Absolutely shocking !

McEdam Tue 21-Aug-07 22:49:04

I like your description of the judge, diva. v. apt.

Pan Tue 21-Aug-07 22:58:35

Am breathless at this. And the pre-sentence report offering Unpaid Work?? I can't believe that happened.

On the facts as reported, he committed a Section 18 Wounding. The start off point for that is something like 2 years. Or possibly more.

Yes the appeal against leniency has been there since 1988. I should imagine this will be nooo problem to appeal. I would like to think.

DV cases are notorious for being plea-bargained down. He is rich. He engaged a good barrister.

McEdam Tue 21-Aug-07 23:01:13

If you want to injure or kill someone, marry them. If you are a man.

Lizzer Tue 21-Aug-07 23:29:47

This is why I didn't bother prosecuting either. I'm sure he would've been drunk or high on something, says he 'can't remember' - I've heard that old chestnut before... Probably doesn't want to believe what he's capable of. Now he doesn't have to face up to it he'll do it again to the next woman in his life, poor girl. This makes me so

NormaStanleyFletcher Tue 21-Aug-07 23:35:32

That is just fecking appalling!!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now