Advanced search

Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have medical concerns, please seek medical attention; if you think your problem could be acute, do so immediately. Even qualified doctors can't diagnose over the internet, so do bear that in mind when seeking or giving advice.

MY friend lost weight like this - what do you think?

(11 Posts)
seeker Mon 08-Sep-08 09:45:23

I met a friend at the weekend I haven't seen since Christmas and she's lost loads of weight and looks fab. She gave up alcohol except on Saturdays, upped her exercise a bit AND - this is the controversial bit - one day a week she eats nothing but raw fruit and vegetables and another day she eats nothing and only drinks water. The other days she eats normally. I think I could go for this - what do you think?
( she doesn't exercise on the no food day)

sunnytimer Mon 08-Sep-08 09:56:44

Message withdrawn

minorbird Mon 08-Sep-08 09:57:22

I take quite a hardline (with myself) when it comes to weightloss. You just have to put less in your body than you use up, regularly. Which means that over the whole week, your friend is still consuming less than she is spending. It might be worth asking her for a food diary and exercize plan. Cos her 'normal' eating might not be 'normal' to you. And she could be a exercize junkie like me. grin

Chequers Mon 08-Sep-08 09:57:44

Sounds like a recipe for screwing up your metabolism to me. Also how is she going to maintain her weight when she gives up fasting?

I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole personally.

Lauriefairycake Mon 08-Sep-08 09:59:55

There are lots of diets like your friend does - how it works is that you are drastically reducing your calorie intake on those two days, the rationale being that no matter what you ate on the other five you wouldn't make it up.

This wouldn't work for me as I am too greedy grin

Rubyrubyruby Mon 08-Sep-08 10:02:09

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Dior Mon 08-Sep-08 10:02:16

Message withdrawn

seeker Mon 08-Sep-08 10:07:13

What about two fruit and veg days instead of a fast day?

SheSellsSeashellsByTheSeashore Mon 08-Sep-08 10:13:51

the nutritional reasons behind diets like these are that you are drastically reducing your weekly calorie intake and the body gets 'used to' a certain amount of calories each day and adjusts itself accordingly to be more efficent. so if you take in a drastic amount of calories for three days your body will get used to burning/storing that amount of calories and will adjust your metabolim accordingly. if you suddenly eat nothing the net day your metabolism will still be working at yesterdays rate and will need to burn off fat for fuel. but go too many days without food and you will go into starvation mode and your body will store every bit of fat you get and burn muscle for fuel instead. unless however you are using that muscle <that is where the exercise comes in>.

they do work and dont really cause as much damage as you would think. but it does depend upon how much you exercise <so that your body doesnt burn muscle instead of fat> and how much you eat on the other days would still need to low enough to ensure your weekly calorie intake is lower than that of which you burn in energy per week.

Rubyrubyruby Mon 08-Sep-08 10:16:09

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

sunnytimer Mon 08-Sep-08 10:28:44

Message withdrawn

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: