Advanced search

Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have medical concerns, please seek medical attention; if you think your problem could be acute, do so immediately. Even qualified doctors can't diagnose over the internet, so do bear that in mind when seeking or giving advice.

GP refusing to give private prescription

(128 Posts)
overun Fri 27-Oct-17 17:40:05

My husband visited the GP today and was prescribed 2 items. He explained how he was no longer allowed to give a private prescription as it was seen as defrauding the NHS! My husband pays a ridiculous amount of tax so why should he be penalised again? Anyone else had this happen?

Ginfiend Fri 27-Oct-17 17:40:57

What’s the objection in receiving an nhs prescription??

BritInUS1 Fri 27-Oct-17 17:43:36

I don't understand, why does he not want an NHS prescription?

ooerrmissus Fri 27-Oct-17 17:45:30

None of your post makes any sense.

GnomeDePlume Fri 27-Oct-17 17:45:54

I am afraid it is just one of those things. I have to take a daily medication which costs pence but I have to pay the prescription charge for it.

If your DH has a number prescriptions each year then it might be worth getting a pre-pay certificate. If he has more than one prescription per month then it is worth it.

LaGattaNera Fri 27-Oct-17 17:46:33

Often items are cheaper than the £8.40 NHS prescription charge but only available with a prescription hence private PX works out as a saving compared to £16.80 as items are charged at their retail price which could be pence or just a few pounds

Sirzy Fri 27-Oct-17 17:46:37

So he saw an NHS GP, in NHS time but wanted a private prescription? Presumably to save himself money?

GrowThroughWhatYouGoThrough Fri 27-Oct-17 17:46:47

Can he purchase the items over the counter?

Fairylea Fri 27-Oct-17 17:48:46

I’m confused confused What is a private prescription issued by an nhs doctor?

LadyLapsang Fri 27-Oct-17 17:51:10

Did he consult the GP as an NHS patient? Surely if he wants a private prescription he would consult a private GP and pay accordingly. Does the GP believe the item your husband would like to be prescribed to be clinically necessary?

overun Fri 27-Oct-17 17:55:11

My husband has been to see the GP less than 3 times in the last 5yrs. Each time he was given a white private prescription because it was much cheaper than the NHS one.

Petalflowers Fri 27-Oct-17 17:55:47

Also confused. Nhs doctors can write private prescriptions, but often put a surcharge on as it's outside tor the nhs contract, so the surcharge is for their time etc.

Also, doesn't the pharmacy charge for dispensing private prescription so? This is often above the NHS cost.

Can you explain more about what happened.

Petalflowers Fri 27-Oct-17 17:57:50

your husband was perhaps,fortunate he didn't get charged for a private appointment.

Sirzy Fri 27-Oct-17 17:58:44

Surely you can see why the NHS don’t want GPs doing that? hmm

NorthernLurker Fri 27-Oct-17 18:01:24

Your husband is out of order. You use NHS services, you pay NHS charges. I suggest he finds a private gp if he wants to pay the actual cost. Of course that bites both ways, as he will find.

overun Fri 27-Oct-17 18:03:41

I can see exactly why the NHS do this, but it has never been a problem before. I have been asked by the GP If I have to pay for my prescriptions and given a cheaper private prescription. The first time this happened I was confused and thought I’d be charged for the Gp’s time but this never happened. There can be a huge difference in prices of items bought privately and NHS prescribed.

hippyhippyshake Fri 27-Oct-17 18:05:31

Failing to see the tax connection confused Are you saying that poorer people should pay more for their prescriptions?

Sirzy Fri 27-Oct-17 18:06:19

Sounds like your GP has been told off for doing it then! And rightly so

Pennywhistle Fri 27-Oct-17 18:07:56

If your DH has been so infrequently to the GP and pays enough tax that you think it’s worth moaning about just cough up the full prescription charge.

And yes it is defeating the purpose of the NHS system to give you a private script.

StealingYourWiFi Fri 27-Oct-17 18:08:49

If you want to pay cost price at pharmacy using a private prescription then you'll have to see a private GP.

nancy75 Fri 27-Oct-17 18:09:13

I thought a private prescription was about £20 compared to NHS which is about £8? I’m confused

hiyasminitsme Fri 27-Oct-17 18:09:32

The rules on this are open to interpretation and your GP could indeed be accused if fraud for doing it so they are quite correct to refuse.

overun Fri 27-Oct-17 18:10:30

We have actually never asked for the (cheaper) private prescriptions. It’s always been at the GP’s suggestion. Seems the rules have changed. I was enquiring here to see if anyone else had experienced this?

Ginfiend Fri 27-Oct-17 18:14:57

Tell your husband to get a grip.
Something like only 1 in 5 prescriptions are actually charged for in England, the rest are for people that are exempt in some way.
We are so so so lucky that we are able to get expensive drugs for just £8.40
(Or £10.40 per month if you have a yearly PPC)
I bet if your husband needed expensive drugs he’d be very quick to take an NHS prescription rather than ask for a private one.
If he’s a high earner, £16.80 a month is not going to break the bank is it?

GnomeDePlume Fri 27-Oct-17 18:16:23

Think of it as a tax. If you can afford to pay it then you suck it up. Many medicines are cheaper than the prescription charge but there are many which arent. Think of it as averaging things out. You over pay on the cheap things but get it back on the expensive things.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: