Advanced search

What makes a good cheesecake? I need a majority opinion

(68 Posts)
stealthsquiggle Wed 09-Jul-08 18:35:32

I am making a (surprise) birthday cake for someone and have been told that what she would really like is a cheesecake. Decorating ideas are, as it happens, transferable to a cheesecake, and I haven't made the cake yet, so that is fine.

Now I have strong opinions as to what constitutes a good cheesecake, but I have no idea if she (or indeed anyone else) shares them. So in the absence of more information from the cheesecake suggesters(I have asked for more) I need a majority opinion to go with...

AllieBongo Wed 09-Jul-08 18:36:28

apparently organic digestives don't go soggy if you use them for the base. Don't ask me why!

ProfessorGrammaticus Wed 09-Jul-08 18:37:44

I prefer the baked ones, definitely. Vanilla always good

stealthsquiggle Wed 09-Jul-08 18:39:25

OK, so I am not entirely alone, but are ProfG and I a minority of 2?

oggsfrog Wed 09-Jul-08 18:43:14

Baked vanilla with a very thick topping..... raisins can be nice..... as can raspberries... and blueberries...

...there isn't a definitive cheescake.
All cheesecake is good smile

stealthsquiggle Wed 09-Jul-08 18:45:36

oggs you see there I disagree with you.

lemon cheesecake = bad
raisins in cheesecake = bad
(and I love raisins in other things!)

awkward, me.

sophierosie Wed 09-Jul-08 18:45:52

I really don't like the baked ones - prefer the chilled ones.
You can mix in some ginger bisuits with the digestives - goes well with strawberries!

MaureenMLove Wed 09-Jul-08 19:04:11

I'm with sophierosie. Chilled ones for me too and ginger nuts!

Lemontart Wed 09-Jul-08 19:10:42

DH loves baked cheesecake served warm and fresh with blueberrys and double cream

Kids and I love chilled no bake "English" cheesecake with crunchy biscuit base and zingy creamy filling with lemon zest.

CantSleepWontSleep Wed 09-Jul-08 19:14:28

I love baked and unbaked cheesecake, but always vanilla and definitely no ginger!

stealthsquiggle Wed 09-Jul-08 21:35:08

I guess it was a bad idea to look for consensus from MN, but I was hoping for a clear majority.


The recipient is way too polite to say if I make exactly the wrong sort of cheesecake.

dizzydixies Wed 09-Jul-08 21:39:22

my most requested one is a white chocolate cheesecake and its FABULOUS and ridicliously easy to make so everyone thinks you're a genuis!!

christiana Wed 09-Jul-08 21:41:59

Message withdrawn

buttercreamfrosting Wed 09-Jul-08 21:42:02




dizzydixies Wed 09-Jul-08 21:43:39

tesco oaty biscuits make a lovely base too smile

Pavlovthecat Wed 09-Jul-08 21:44:56

Vanilla a must - I prefer simple NY style cheeecake myself.

Pavlovthecat Wed 09-Jul-08 21:47:04

Vanilla a must - I prefer simple NY style cheesecake myself.
No ginger, lemon or raisins. EVER.

dizzydixies Wed 09-Jul-08 21:47:52

seriously - nobody else for the white chocolate??!

CantSleepWontSleep Wed 09-Jul-08 21:50:35

Chocolate and cheesecake should never be mixed.

Waitrose do the most divine NY cheesecake pavlov. Have you tried it?

totalmisfit Wed 09-Jul-08 21:51:42

baked with raisins, lemon and vanilla... mmmm... I have to make that again.

WilfSell Wed 09-Jul-08 21:52:15

I like:

baked WITH raisins
chilled with LOTS of lemon and made with fresh Quark and digestives.

NO chocolate or pink-jam-food-product

stealthsquiggle Wed 09-Jul-08 21:52:20

[evil cackle]

the thread is turning towards my own inclination (identical to Pavlov's)grin

Dizzy - your suggestion leaves me torn as I hate white chocolate but I suspect the recipient might love it...

girlandboy Wed 09-Jul-08 21:53:41

Chilled, not baked.

Need a good thick layer of fruit topping.

jojo76 Wed 09-Jul-08 21:55:09

Oh,can I join in this discussion? I would LOVE to know about the white chocolate one, I love cheesecake and white chocolate! I always make an Annabel Karmel one. It's easy, always turns out gorgeous, and it always gets lots of compliments.....if you want the recepie?! Its just a simple baked one, with the option of sultanas, but Ive never put them in....

dizzydixies Wed 09-Jul-08 21:55:37

stealth I made is as dh is a white chocolate fan and now I have to make it for every family gathering/party/work do/ just because occassion ever

its lovely on its own or with strawberry/raspberry topping too smile

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now