Advanced search

I've just been told that vegans don't eat honey. Is this true and if so, why?

(112 Posts)
Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 21:56:09

That's it really.

I'd always thought that vegans don't eat animal products that have been produced by causing pain or exploitation. Does honey fit with this? I'd have thought that bees can, off ...if they don't like where they are.

Carmenere Fri 09-May-08 21:58:00

I dunno probably something to do with disturbing the bees natural environment, I suppose honeycomb is where they live.

Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 22:01:12

OK. I suppose that fits.

How about eating vegetables grown using animal manure produced from a farmed diet? Or am I just being silly now? grin

CombustibleLemon Fri 09-May-08 22:02:11

See here for a full explanation.

Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 22:07:42

Ah! OK. That explains it.

Do vegans use animal manure to grow vegetables?

Miggsie Fri 09-May-08 22:08:08

I have a good friend who is vegan, and no honey!
If you really want to wind a vegan up start talking about YEAST!

Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 22:10:31

Yeast! Help!! I'm making pizzas with some children next week (including one who is vegan) and I'd planned to make dough using, er...yeast.

Is that a no-no?

StopSpyingYouFreak Fri 09-May-08 22:11:18

Because it is stolen from bees

Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 22:12:34

How about yeast?

Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 22:13:48

A fungi. Nowt to worry about, I hope.

CombustibleLemon Fri 09-May-08 22:19:01

This is about the use of manure as a fertilizer.

RIELOVESBACARDI Fri 09-May-08 22:20:31


WigWamBam Fri 09-May-08 22:20:55

Ah, but yeast is also a living organism. Vegan friend of mine used to get her knickers in a knot because of that ... she was a bit intense and prone to over-thinking these things though! Most vegans are OK with it given that it is not animal in origin.

Do be aware, though, that some dried yeasts contain emulsifiers, which can be of animal origin - fresh yeast is OK, but read the label of any dried you use and check it states that it's suitable for vegans.

Blandmum Fri 09-May-08 22:23:40

Well, plants are living organisms too. smile

5 kingdoms of living things
Protoctista (eveything they can fit into the other 4 basically)

If vegans are only interested in Animals, then Yeast is fair game, at least as fair as mushrooms.

Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 22:25:29

So human manure is OK but only if it comes from a vegan?

CombustibleLemon Fri 09-May-08 22:27:45

Don't ask me, I only did the link!

WigWamBam Fri 09-May-08 22:29:34

Oh, I know, MB.

My friend's argument was that yeast differs from mushrooms because it continues to live and multiply until it is killed by the action of baking it ... but as I said, she was a bit intense about these things!

Blandmum Fri 09-May-08 22:29:59

You have to be very careful if using Human manure. Or you can spread disease. You have to make sure that any composting has been done very well and the composts has gor high enough to kill off the bacteria.

A 1/3/ to a half of the mass of human faeces is bacteria....most will be dead, but not all, and obviously there is the resk of contamination

Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 22:30:33

grin Thanks, CL.

I can understand the not eating animal products but the manure thing sounds a step too far in my (un-vegan) opinion.

Blandmum Fri 09-May-08 22:31:44

WWB, well, point our that her veg is still busy respiring until it is cooked or eaten.....that is why veg and fruit produce water that you see inside a plastic bag.

Or I see in a plastic bag, if she is that intense she probably spurns plastic ! smile

Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 22:34:13

I definitely couldn't fancy a carrot grown in human manure.

CombustibleLemon Fri 09-May-08 22:34:35

The site suggests urine which is pretty much sterile. I know that they mean people should collect it in a bucket or something, but now I've got the image of vegans squatting in their vegetable patches stuck in my head.

wannaBe Fri 09-May-08 22:34:59

I can sort of understand vegy but imo vegan is barking.

How do they know the plants don't suffer?
wtf is wrong with eggs?
and manure? I mean an animal has to crap, it will do so regardless of whether said crap is going to be spread over the plants, no?

WigWamBam Fri 09-May-08 22:36:16

Even non-vegan organic gardeners pee on their compost heaps. It's good stuff, is pee.

Bubble99 Fri 09-May-08 22:36:17

Does baby poo have less bacteria? As in, less bacteria in the gut at a young age?

I can see a sideline to the children's daycare business opening up. grin

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now