Would you eat these?

No way from me.

No

Yes

If I didn't like them enough to have eaten them by now then they would go in the bin. If I was broke I would eat the September one.

No.

Best before means you can still eat them. ... the sugar is a good preservative and they should be fine.

But yeah, generally I would not want to eat them!

Nope

No not a fresh item that was that old. A tin I would have no issue with.

I’m assuming they’re ‘ambient temperature’ ones, not ones hiding in the back of the fridge? If so, yes I would eat them, they’ll be full of preservatives and be fine.

I wouldnt buy those but I prob would eat them having had a good sniff and an experimental taste first. I eat things way over bb dates generally.

The longest was chocolate philly which was unopened but a year over. It was fine but I never bought it again as the very face it had lasted that long put me right off. Like the experiment with the macdonalds burger which never grows mould.

Wouldn't think twice about it. Have they been in some sort of vacuum pack?

Yes.

Of course, they're ambient so will be fine ages after the bbe

I’m an absolute minger and probably wouldn’t