Advanced search

The perfectest fudgy icing recipe

(13 Posts)
IStillMissBlockbuster Tue 25-Jun-19 20:48:33

I am looking for the perfect fudgy icing recipe. Not your run of the mill buttercream. I CBA to make loads just to see, but have narrowed it down to recipes using condensed milk:
like this one here
and then there's this recipe here which looks close to buttercream, but with melted chocolate and stuff and just looks better, don't you think? this one here

Any experiences or thoughts on this?

OP’s posts: |
ZazieTheCat Thu 27-Jun-19 05:13:25

Did one which involved a can of condensed milk (used coconut condensed milk) and then you fill the can with natural peanut butter. Added pinch of sea salt as pb was unsalted. Simmered together for a bit until fudgey. Then I halved it and mixed one half with an equal quantity of dark chocolate, left the other plain. Used plain one as first layer, chocolate one as second layer.

IStillMissBlockbuster Thu 27-Jun-19 05:36:28

Morning Zazie. I tried both recipes I linked to last night and liked the consistency of the condensed milk one, but the flavour wasn't chocolatey enough for me. Perhaps darker chocolate would have been better. As it was, the other recipe was pretty perfect so I used that.

I've never heard of coconut condensed milk (where did you get that?), it sounds amazing. Your recipe sounds kind of epic, but not what i'm looking for this time. Must find an excuse to try it though!

OP’s posts: |
MrsSchadenfreude Thu 27-Jun-19 06:04:06

The icing for Nigella’s chocolate fudge cake recipe is amazing.

ExpletiveDelighted Thu 27-Jun-19 06:25:11

I think you can't beat chocolate/cream/icing sugar combinations. This one is great but might not be chocolatey enough for you

You could always do half and half caramel bar and plain chocolate.

ZazieTheCat Thu 27-Jun-19 07:24:04

Hello Blockbuster. I got the coconut condensed milk online at Realfoods, but I think you also get it on Ocado and Amazon.

It makes so many things possible for dairy free people. Fab flapjacks with the condensed milk flapjack recipe that’s in here. Or boil with some coconut sugar for a fab sauce for sticky toffee pudding.

IStillMissBlockbuster Thu 27-Jun-19 07:27:04

Wow that's great Zazie, I'm not dairy free but it sounds delicious.

OP’s posts: |
villainousbroodmare Thu 27-Jun-19 07:29:06

I found demerara icing sugar. Magical.

avocadochocolate Thu 27-Jun-19 07:32:47

I use this.

Melt butter.

Stir in other ingredients

When combined, turn up heat and stir for a minute or two. The cooking makes the mixture fudgy.

Remove from heat and beat with wooden spoon. Do this until the mixture has cooled to the extend that when it drops off the spoon it folds.

Then pour on cake. If mixture is still too hot and runny, a lot of it will run off the cake.

This will not look fancy but the taste is delicious.

avocadochocolate Thu 27-Jun-19 07:33:48

Thinking about it, Probably cooking is stage is more like 2-3 minutes.

yearinyearout Thu 27-Jun-19 07:35:29

I also like nigella's chocolate fudge icing but it's not quite chocolatey enough for me, so I add about a teaspoon of sieved cocoa powder to the recipe.

ZazieTheCat Thu 27-Jun-19 13:07:37

I used to do something like that when I could still eat butter avocadochocolate.

It was was
2 tbsps butter
2 tbsps golden syrup
2 tbsps cocoa
2 tbsps icing sugar

Melt butter and syrup together til they bubble. Add cocoa and mix throughly. Remove from heat and beat in icing sugar. Continue beating will you reached desired consistency then spoon over cake.

I really miss that one. It was fab on ice cream too.

growlingbear Thu 27-Jun-19 13:11:47

My mum used to melt dark chocolate and mix it with equal weight of condensed milk. It made the most delicious fudgey filling.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »