Skip to main content
Skip to main navigation
Skip to talk navigation

Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Add post

Watch this thread

Save thread

Start a new thread

Flip thread

Hide thread

My feed

Saved Active Unanswered threads

Getting started FAQ's

Unanswered threads Acronyms Talk guidelines

Hide shortcut buttons

Talk

Flip

For related content, visit our food content hub.

1 2

For related content, visit our food content hub.

Food/Recipes

My DD keeps eating coal what can i do to stop it?

28 replies

Darciesmum · 19/06/2006 12:17

Hi

My DD 14.5 months, loves eating the coal off our fireplace, all the blocks have chucks out of them where she loves to eat it.
She has a very healthy diet, no sugar as such, eats plenty of fruit and veg a day, so not sure what else to do, suggestions grateful please

OP posts:

Report

YellowFeathers · 19/06/2006 12:19

Have you got a fire guard? I would probably get one if not.

How about giving her some carrot sticks or making some ice lollies for her to satisfy the crunch craving?

welshmum · 19/06/2006 12:19

No suggestions I'm afraid but just to add that ds is currently committed to eating stones and gravel, don't know what to do either. I know that he now thinks it's a good game though...sigh....

Darciesmum · 19/06/2006 12:22

We have a fireguard its enough for her to pull out of the way tho, she is freakishly strong lol

Welshmum DD also has a thing for gravel but throwing it not eating it!

She doesn't like carrot but has got plenty of ice lollies so tried that, and doesn't seem to be working!

OP posts:

YellowFeathers · 19/06/2006 12:23

Freakishly strong, lol

Is she still teething?

Darciesmum · 19/06/2006 12:24

She has cut 2 more of her bottom teeth but i think more of the top ones are coming through but she won't let me have a look n see!!

Little Moomin that she is lol

OP posts:

SoupDragon · 19/06/2006 12:24

Remove the coal.

charliecat · 19/06/2006 12:26

Get the fireguard fixed to the wall as if she can pull it away to get coal she can pull it away to get burnt:(

Darciesmum · 19/06/2006 12:28

we never have the fireplace on as good central heating is there for effect so she can never get burnt!!

OP posts:

charliecat · 19/06/2006 12:29

ok, move the coal then :)

Darciesmum · 19/06/2006 12:37

I'll have to i suppose, but i shouldn't have to move it i want her to learn not to touch, she doesn't touch ne thing else she knows shes not allowed to. she also knows she not allowed to touch the coal but she does.

Shes in her highchair at the moment eating a bowl of fresh peach and grapes

OP posts:

tissy · 19/06/2006 12:40

fill the firebasket with pine cones or a vase of flowers. Ditch the coal!

Darciesmum · 19/06/2006 17:09

bump for the evening ppl, ne more suggestions

OP posts:

cadbury · 19/06/2006 17:15

My nana (who had 12 kids) had this problem with quite a few of them. She would keep one lump of coal sterilised and quickly hand it to the baby when they reached for the pile - for some reason (that I never got to the bottom of) this was better. Maybe that peice wasn't crumbly so it was less of a problem. I got the impression from her that it didn't do any of the kids any harm internally. But sadly I can't ask her now as she passed away in January - so many things I wanted to ask her

ScummyMummy · 19/06/2006 17:35

Is it dangerous to eat coal? My son loved eating sand at that age. Harmless, if odd. If it's not going to do her any harm and you don't want to remove the coal you could just leave her to it perhaps.

sugarfree · 19/06/2006 17:40

Just want to check..it is real coal she's eating,not those coal effect block things.
Bizarrely,my reasoning is that real coal would be better for her than 'pretend' coal.Along the lines of the sugar/sweetners argument.
Real coal is just carbon isn't it?Like burnt toast?
Would you listen to my inane,rambling,wittering?

nailpolish · 19/06/2006 17:43

does eating coal not signify a lack of something or other? i remember a friend of mine eating coal while pg and the dr telling her she was deficient in carbon or something

the hv should be able to help, or chat to the dr

i dont think its dangerous

quanglewangle · 19/06/2006 17:45

lol sugarfree.
So wean her on to burnt toast......

nailpolish · 19/06/2006 17:46

LOL!

so we are all hoping its real coal, i mean, should it not be organic?

sugarfree · 19/06/2006 19:12

and rinsed in spring water?And at what age should one wean one's baby onto organic coal?

(OP,taking the p**s out of myself,not you )

Darciesmum · 19/06/2006 19:27

we have a mixture of real and the crumbly stuff but she has a munch at both!

Sorry to hear your nana passed away Cadbury, i've spoken to the Hv and she said is something most ppl go through and not juts babies, its a lack of Iron deficency but she knows all about DD diet so knows not lacking in fruit n veg everyday. And it won't harm her in little bits.

Just want to know what to do to get her out of it!! lol

OP posts:

TooTicky · 19/06/2006 19:39

Try giving her slightly burnt toast.

saffymum · 20/06/2006 14:14

Sorry but I just think this is the funniest thing I have ever heard of, just move the coal! Or put something else in its place and bring it back at a later date when the obsession subsides. She might be so much more interested in it because you keep giving attention when she eats it.

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Email address

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

sazhig · 20/06/2006 14:20

At her age I wouldnt really expect her to understand why she shouldnt be touching or eating something she has access to. Move it or attach the fire guard to the wall - simplest solutions are the best ones at this age imo

Codmamma · 20/06/2006 14:21

is it organic>

Idonthaveenoughtime · 21/10/2012 22:02

Coal contains uranium (radioactive) and small amounts of arsenic. I wouldn't advise it as part of a healthy diet!
Also, the fake coal bricks are very dangerous to injest, they contain all kinds of harmful chemicals.

Flip

1 2

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.