Talk

Advanced search

harry Plopper = it IS a 12 isnt it? is is too scarey for a 9 year old

(39 Posts)
JohnDory Tue 14-Jul-09 16:24:01

or not

ingles2 Tue 14-Jul-09 16:25:52

I'm taking my 8 and 9 yr old so I hope not...
The only thing I'm slightly worried about is Greyback the werewolf. neither of them liked the idea when we read the book.

JohnDory Tue 14-Jul-09 16:26:27

hmm
right

castille Tue 14-Jul-09 16:27:41

Not taking my 9yo potter-fan DD

She is nightmare prone and only allowed to read the books in daytime

RealiteEstMaSeuleIllusion Tue 14-Jul-09 16:28:07

Message withdrawn

Summerfruit Tue 14-Jul-09 16:29:54

I'm taking my 5 years old..she has been watching all the movies for a while...I know bad blush

RealiteEstMaSeuleIllusion Tue 14-Jul-09 16:31:37

Message withdrawn

TheFool Tue 14-Jul-09 16:31:54

12a

not seen it obv, but if they have seen the others i'd prob take them

PandaG Tue 14-Jul-09 16:32:06

aren't all 12's 12A's these days?

I personally won't be taking my 9yo DS, even though he is a great potter fan. He's read them all and watched the first couple of films but we have decided not to watch any further for a while yet. I think at 9 he can imagine the scary bits in tghe books to a level he can more or less cope with, but will get scared by the on screen images, just as he used to with Dr Who. (which we do sometimes censor still)

Tamarto Tue 14-Jul-09 16:33:03

It's a 12a which means that unless you are over 12 you need an aduilt with you.

It will be a sad one so depends how they cope with that.

hannahsaunt Tue 14-Jul-09 16:33:53

It's a 12A. I am now completely hmm at the BBFC ratings - we have been v strict with our 2 so far and watched each HP DVD before they did to assess; the latter 2 were 12As when on in the cinema. Quite frankly, I don't know how esp given that Quantum of Solace was a 12A and in an entirely different league. We have happily let our 8.75yo and 6.5yo watch all 5 HPs and will be going to the cinema a deux to assess HP6 for suitability for either or both of the boys but fully anticipate being happy to take them both.

Dazmum Tue 14-Jul-09 16:36:54

The dead bodies in the lake might be a bit scary too? depends how they show them. We are taking our 11 year old.

TrillianoftheShineyCult Tue 14-Jul-09 16:58:08

Check it out here.

"Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince', a fantasy adventure film based on the book of the same title, finds Harry and his friends returning to Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry for their sixth year. The film contains moderate threat.

The moderate threat occurs in one quite scary sequence in which Harry and Professor Dumbledore are attacked by menacing looking creatures that have emerged from an underground lake. Harry is pulled into the lake and dragged beneath the water. The scene has the potential to upset younger or more sensitive children. In another scene Draco Malfoy kicks Harry (below screen) and appears to break his nose; blood can be seen on Harry's face. Tables are turned later on in the film when Harry defeats Malfoy in a wand battle in the school toilets. Malfoy, who is rendered unconscious, has several bloodstains on his white shirt and his blood can be seen to mix with and cloud the water on the flooded floor. Malfoy, however, is soon completely healed by a nearby teacher.

The film contains mild language including the words 'God', 'bloody', tosser', 'sod', 'hell' and 'git'."

JohnDory Tue 14-Jul-09 17:47:15

thanks
that is great help

JohnDory Tue 14-Jul-09 17:49:35

i just read it to him. he looked embrassed at the swearing!

janeite Wed 15-Jul-09 19:16:18

I have seen it and it's fab. You hardly see Fenrir. There is one very jumpy bit with the inferi - even though I was expecting it, it still made me jump.

maryz Wed 15-Jul-09 21:55:58

I don't think it's very scary at all - certainly less so than some of the others.

Loshad Wed 15-Jul-09 22:00:38

It's a 12A and not very scarey at all, saw it this afternoon - only the bit where they grab him into the lake. My 8yo cried when dumbledore was killed, but then so did I, he certainly wasn't excessively upset, just the sort of sniffles that films induce in you. Good film imo. much to my embarassment i didn't even notice the swearing.

Loshad Wed 15-Jul-09 22:01:28

oh btw Castille, thought it was a lot less scary than eg film 2 with the large snakey thing.

SobriquetDuJour Wed 15-Jul-09 22:11:12

I took Ds (4) to Transformers II, is that really bad?

<holds breath>

janeite Wed 15-Jul-09 22:23:15

I didn't cry: couldn't feel over-moved now it's Michael Gambon.

SobriquetDuJour Wed 15-Jul-09 22:23:26

<passes out>

janeite Wed 15-Jul-09 22:23:39

Howled over Sirius in the last one though!

LadyGlencoraSnape Wed 15-Jul-09 22:28:15

I'm taking my nine year old. She is pretty imperturbable. Not taking my sensitive, imaginative six year old though.

TheMoistWorldOfSeptimusQuench Wed 15-Jul-09 22:30:56

DD's 7 year old friend has seen it (went to the premier envy) and wasn't remotely scared. She loved it.

Greyback is super scary in the books though.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now