Talk

Advanced search

Muriel's Wedding is just so damn sad

(30 Posts)
Hassled Wed 13-Jun-18 22:00:19

She has so many issues - such an awful father, such a desperate mother. When she walks back down the aisle and doesn't even notice her mother there it makes me want to weep. Why does Muriel think marriage will give her value to such an extent? She didn't get that from her parents' marriage. And while she says that life with Rhonda is better than an Abba song, she's a shit friend to her.

I've watched it before and laughed, but tonight I watched it and just thought how horribly sad it is and what a dysfunctional, chaotic girl she is.

annandale Wed 13-Jun-18 22:05:06

Yes I think it's quite a traumatic film. I dislike how it's sold as a pure comedy - it's a drama.

I have read so many articles about it that don't even mention Rhonda's accident and her disability. To me that was one of the most important things about the film. Rachel Griffiths is a goddess.

Hassled Wed 13-Jun-18 22:08:46

Yes - goddess is right - she's fabulous.
And it's no comedy. Even the "You're terrible, Muriel" sister is tragic.

witchmountain Wed 13-Jun-18 22:14:27

I can’t even remember what happens in it now but I very clearly remember thinking the same thing when it first came out (I would have been a teenager) and being horrified about how there was no discussion beyond it being a “hilarious” comedy.

divafever99 Wed 13-Jun-18 22:16:27

Yes I can still remember it clearly now and it's years since I saw it. I'm not sure what the actress called Muriel is called but she was in a series a couple of years ago playing a doctor who was held hostage and was great in that too.

CosmicCanary Wed 13-Jun-18 22:20:33

Tony Collette.
She is in about a boy as the suicidal mother.

annandale Wed 13-Jun-18 22:22:37

I always remember Toni Collette as the particularly unpleasant doctor in Shallow Grave. She does 'surface nice but fundamentally corrupt' amazingly.

Really should have foreseen that going to see Shallow Grave as a first date meant the relationship was doomed...

GreenRedBlue Wed 13-Jun-18 22:30:01

Yes to all of this!! DH and I disagree on this, he just thinks it's hilarious but all I could see was how sad it was for almost every character. Especially her mum - what an awful existence.

JemAppelleLafayette Wed 13-Jun-18 22:30:55

Kerry Fox played the doctor in Shallow Grave. TC is the mother in Sixth Sense.

If somebody had taken me to see Shallow Grave on a first date I would have married him grin. It’s one of my favourites.

JemAppelleLafayette Wed 13-Jun-18 22:32:38

I love Muriel’s Wedding as well, but it is terribly sad. There’s a shot of her mother watching a cup of tea go round in a microwave that makes me feel all horrible and empty every time.

MikeWyzowski Wed 13-Jun-18 22:36:11

I think it's a wonderful film which so many aspects to it. I too saw it as a comedy initially but watched it a few years later and saw it's tragedy. I watched it again recently and was able to enjoy it as the fabulous film it is, tragic but with comedic elements to it: "Deidre Chambers! What a coincidence!"
Some of the characters are so awful but come good in the end, even the dad when Murielmtells him he has to look after the "kids"

Dragonlight Wed 13-Jun-18 22:38:27

Toni Collette. She's brilliant. Muriel's wedding is definitely no comedy, it's incredibly sad.

billybagpuss Wed 13-Jun-18 22:39:53

It’s a fantastic film but so not a comedy.

The bits that are supposed to be funny is just a poor lass seeking validation.

Ontheboardwalk Wed 13-Jun-18 23:12:06

Agree I don’t see how anyone can say it’s a comedy. It’s a brilliant film with some comedy moments but is not a comedy.

I also agree Toni Collette is brilliant in it

BellaJessica Wed 13-Jun-18 23:28:35

Isnt it a black comedy? Almost satirical. Agree though very sad. The parts with her mother upset me especially in the church.

xFreePeaceSweetx Wed 13-Jun-18 23:39:04

How did you watch it please op? Its one of my all time favourites. Muriel resonates with me so much. The bullying "friends", abusive and controlling father, weight issues, wanting to fit in and be treated as an equal...
I always wanted to go to Hibiscus Island but I don't think it exists. grin

0lwen Wed 13-Jun-18 23:41:26

it's like East is East in that you see the humour the first time you see it and the sadness the second time. I rewatched it a while back preparing to laugh my way through it and got a shock.

TheFirstMrsOsmond Thu 14-Jun-18 16:46:34

I love "Muriel's Wedding" and agree that it combines humour & sadness, as the best comedies always do. Toni Collette was on Graham Norton recently and she said people still come up to her now, 24 years later, and say "You're terrible, Muriel". She said it was a film that really seemed to speak to some women. She always makes good choices in her career - my favourite is "Little Miss Sunshine".

Meandyouandyouandme Thu 14-Jun-18 16:51:19

Another good film Toni Collette is in is The Way Way Back, again it’s sad though, another comedy drama. Also stars Alison Janney and Steve Carell.

Hassled Thu 14-Jun-18 17:29:57

Wait - there's a film with Toni Colette AND Alison Janney AND Steve Carell? How have I missed this?

Re how I watched it - I recorded it from a few weeks ago when it was Channel 5 or something. I tried to get 16 year old DS3 to watch with me but he wasn't having any of it.

TheMouseTrap Thu 14-Jun-18 17:43:27

Agree it's incredibly sad, but brilliantly acted. I feel so sad for her mum sad. The Aussie's do dark humour very well.

TheFirstMrsOsmond Thu 14-Jun-18 17:51:08

TheMouseTrap Aussie humour really appeals to me: I still remember watching a film called "The Dish" on a flight from Sydney to Wellington about 18 years ago - I was laughing the whole way. I have a great affection for small town Australia (eg Porpoise Spit in "Muriel's Wedding") as portrayed in films but don't feel the same about small town America in movies.

Charley50 Thu 14-Jun-18 18:04:07

@0lwen - I was going to say that about East is East. I found it really upsetting first time round, with the domestic abuse storyline. But it's sold as a comedy.

DrDreReturns Thu 14-Jun-18 18:08:39

I remember east is easy being hilarious until about half way through, then it was really uncomfortable viewing.

AnyFucker Thu 14-Jun-18 18:11:19

I cry all the way through that film. No laughing here.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: