'But there are absolutely NEVER ever reports of people feeling better about themselves within 4-8 hours of taking their first pill. The earliest is 4 weeks-ish that people start to feel any better'
Allow me to be the first report of this....ADs work like a light switch for me. I start feeling better and more like myself within 2 days. Don't scream 'placebo effect' at me, I've been on and off enough times to know how my brain works.
Whilst I agree ADs are overprescribed and for SOME people they are more helpful when combined with talking therapy, that isn't the case for me. I'm a direct contradiction to what this woman is saying. It has taken a long time for me to accept that ADs are going to be with me for life. I don't think this is or should be the case for everyone.
This opinion isn't new, and it's caused people like me a lot of grief, because we're under pressure to stop ADs. Every time I've stopped, no matter how good my life is, I go into a downward spiral of depressive thoughts and get to the point that I push everyone away, hide from the world, fail at work/education, and generally make a mess of things. Fortunately, I've learned to ignore articles like this and do what I know is best for me. It's not 'chemical' for everyone, but in my case it is.
I've been under the care of numerous psychiatrists and counsellors over the years, and I've had plenty of talking therapy. One thing that has been consistent with all of them is the opinion that ADs work for me, and they work without the talk therapy too.
Most recently, I came off ADs for pregnancy, and it was a terrible mistake. I spent months being miserable, and then finally got back on a proper dose of Citalopram and I was back to myself (as much as one can be when pregnant) within 2 days. The social worker from the community mental health team is amazed, as is the GP, the psychiatrist, and the midwife. The only thing that changed were those little pills.
So if this woman wants to claim I am in a 'drug-induced state' because I can function, prepare for the birth of my baby, and generally not be suicidally depressed, then fine, she's welcome to her opinion. I'd rather be alive and able to cope.