Advanced search

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently, see our mental health web guide which can point you to expert advice.

st john swort, kalms, ad's

(7 Posts)
stitch Wed 16-Jul-08 00:28:04

thinking of takingsomething.
st johns wort is pharmacollogiccally active, apparently. plus, its very very expensive at 15 opounds for thirty. but the tesco one is 1.50 for sixty. why the huge discrepancy?
or should i try kalms first?
really really dont want to go back to antidepressants.
any advice appreciated

Bowddee Wed 16-Jul-08 00:34:56

IME, go for Kalms. St Johns Wort did bugger all. Have a look at the Bach Flower Remedies as well. I don't go out without my Rescue Remedy.

stitch Wed 16-Jul-08 09:15:16

i have my rescue rememedy, but if i rely solely on that, i dont always use it when i need it as i forget. iyswim,
kalms it is then
any idea about the price difference?

jellybeans Wed 16-Jul-08 09:28:31

I think SJW is fab, it worked for me and my doc said was proved to be as good as ADs for mild - mod depression. I liked the vega ones (£8) but tesco were fine as well. As long as it has hypericin (sp) and hyperforin (sp) it should be fine, takes 2-6 weeks to work. Kalms/valerian or rescue remedy did nowt for me and are not clinically proven.

puffylovett Wed 16-Jul-08 09:35:37

the difference in cost will be for numerous reasons.

source of the herb
wether it's organic
how strong each tablet is
what the tablet is bound with
how much of the active ingredient is in it (Hypericum)
wether it's made to pharmaceutical standards, ie wether the machines that make the pills are broken down and cleaned between runs

you get what you pay for. if you want to see wether or not it works, you need to go for the more expensive one. You MUST NOT take it with anti depressants, they are contra-indicated.

IMO you would be best consulting a medical herbalist, or at the least using the tincture rather than the tablets, youusually pay around £13 for a months supply - and it doesn't have to be broken down, it's absorbed directly through the stomach.

I hope you feel better soon and find something that works for you smile

jellybeans Wed 16-Jul-08 11:23:59

The more expensive are not necc better, I didn't like the Kira ones (£15) as much as the VEGA, the vega had a nice calming effect, think they had chamomile in too.

janmoomoo Fri 01-Aug-08 18:36:40

Lots of research evidence to show that SJW can be really effective and as good as anti-depressants. Dont take if you are on the pill and you need extra care in sun.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now