Advanced search

How much for a second-hand violin please? tips and advice wanted

(12 Posts)
OhYouBadBadKitten Mon 20-Jul-09 20:55:01

dd started off on a very affordable 1/2 size 'beginner' violin. Shes now ready for a 3/4 (we were going to wait a bit but somehow her bow has broken - stripped thread on the tightening bit and violin teacher says would be better just to get new one, so if we are doing that then we almost may as well just be brave and sort it now)

Cos dds old violin went out of tune so very easily and she really loves playing, practises every day and is really making progress we want to buy her something that will sound nice and will behave itself. We are going to go to a proper shop but don't know what we are looking at and want to end up with something reasonable, not extortionate. So what should we be looking at and how much would it cost?

marialuisa Tue 21-Jul-09 22:03:36

DD's new stentor conservatoire "outfit" cost approx £175. It's great and quality/tone wise would last until at least G5. Can't begin to describe the improvement against the old Skylark she had borrowed from school. I guess a secondhand version would be around £100?

LadyGlencoraSnape Thu 23-Jul-09 12:11:58

DD's secondhand Stentor student was £55, but we got it for £20 because we traded in her half-size against it at the very good local music shop. I would see if there is somewhere around you that does similar. She may not need the 3/4 size very long (DD only had hers for about 18 months) and the Stentor Student was absolutely fine (she took grade one on it). Then you can trade in the 3/4 against a decent full-size.

OhYouBadBadKitten Thu 23-Jul-09 12:13:41

Lovely - thank you
I think almost anything would be an improvement on the one she has now!

pugsandseals Thu 30-Jul-09 14:06:36

Find a proper dealer!
Anything set-up by them will behave itself as the pegs will have been sanded to the correct size. They will also set the soundpost (little wooden stick inside) perfectly for the best sound.
Other things to consider:-
1 What strings does it have? Might be worth upgrading. My favourites on this type of instrument are piranitos by pirastro, if you have a little more to spend try dominants or tonicas
2 If you are buying a full outfit, upgrade to a fibreglass or carbon fibre bow if you can- they are far less breakable by children!
3 Avoid Antoni, Hudson, & cheap coloured violins they are dire! Look for names like Stentor, Paesold, Rainbow, Yamaha or P&H & you won't go far wrong!
Where about's are you? I maybe able to recommend a good dealer as they are few and far between!
From a Violist

pugsandseals Thu 30-Jul-09 14:08:00

Ooh, one more thing- don't spend too much as they may well have grown out of a 3/4 size in 2 or 3 years! Set up is the important thing, try lots & trust your ears

JeMeSouviens Thu 30-Jul-09 14:10:55

on a side note, BadKitten, you might want to put a warning before someone opens your profile pics

<teach me to be nosey!> ARGH! shock shiver, vomit

SueW Thu 30-Jul-09 14:34:35

Agree re the sizing - DD was only 3/4 for just 1-2 years, before moving up to full size. It was still cheaper than renting but I'm not sure it was a wise decision as we still have a 3/4 violin I keep meaning to get rid of!

When she moved to full-size we went to a [ proper shop] with her violin teacher and she got to try out a selection of violins within a price range, but also a selection of bows too and find the perfect match for her.

Bit like Harry Potter and Ollivander's Wand Shop!!

I'm not sure how far this one will take her before she'll need to upgrade again, or whether she'll need to, it wasn't cheap but the expectation is that she'll go to Grade 8. At least next time hopefully we won't be buying a saxophone in the same week or so. <Gulp>

pugsandseals Thu 30-Jul-09 15:10:46

Turner's is a fantastic shop!
So is Caswell's/Heritage Music (near Silverstone)- my favourite if I'm being biased!
Cremona House (Bristol)
Foote's (London)
Guivier (London)
& these are just off the top of my head- don't have any idea about up North/Scotland- sorry!
All well worth the day trip though!

MarmadukeScarlet Thu 30-Jul-09 15:17:37

At Britton's I was quoted well over what marialuisa paid for a conservatoire, in fact that was the cost of a Stentor student II.

DD has been playing a family instrument (Austrian) which is very good, but I do not want to pay for a conservatoire that she may only use for 2 yrs also do not want to listen to a poor quality sound.

I like a doninant string too, but probably not worth putting on a Stentor student I.

AMumInScotland Thu 30-Jul-09 15:33:38

Stringers in Edinburgh is great if you're up here - they do everything from secondhand beginners ones up to seriously expensive ones. And they'll always take back ones from there in part-exchange when you want to move up a size or up to an individual one. I like the comparison with Ollivanders smile. We spent one afternoon picking out DSs new violin, then another afternoon a few weeks later to pick out a bow. But they're also very friendly and approachable when you're just starting out.

pugsandseals Thu 30-Jul-09 16:21:14

I love violin shopping smile

I find Pirastro strings much better than dominants though- they always seem to disintigrate over the bridge or nut!

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: