After getting married & selling my flat around five years ago, we searched for a house, looking at an objective ranking of transport, amenities and most importantly, schools. We eventually found a nice house in a good area, near a train station and a great school. Given this, we then set about having a child. After said child was around two, the school’s catchment area dramatically decreased (technically the cut-off distance at which the furthest child was admitted). The next-nearest school was a dire wreck, falling in standards every year (and now is being converted into an academy).
Alarmed, suddenly our rosy situation was looking desperate. Initially, we considered moving home; we’d find another nice house, near a (another) good school and transport. This, it turns out, is what everybody was doing - and indeed the law of supply and demand saw to it that the cost of these homes were given a hefty premium (more so than when we were looking before, the market had moved on, birth rates had increased). We worked out that in order to move, we would need to sell and increase our mortgage by a hefty 400K (yes, we live and work in London, and have to stay for work and family)- so, dazed, we set about planning our move.
At some point in the middle of that planning, we started looking at the cost of a paid education. Initially I was vehemently against the idea of private schools - I believed, and still do, that education should be in the public domain for all, and most importantly it should be available to everyone without restriction (money should not be able to buy knowledge, or more importantly, having less money should not mean a compromised education - which in turn leads to divisions later in life). But given that my options were running out, I’m sure every parent would agree that the child’s welfare trumps all. So, after a lot of painful soul searching, I relented. In short, there were two events that altered our outlook. I had a conversation with my wife’s uncle, who as it turns out had sent one daughter (the eldest) to a local comp and then several years down the line, sent his second daughter to a private school. In his experience, the contrast was stark: he believed both daughters were brought up roughly the same, showing the similar levels of intelligence and awareness at around age four. Whilst the eldest tried her best, she could only ever seem to achieve a C grade in most subjects (at best). The other daughter had no issues in obtaining A grades across the board. Now, I know that this isn’t a true like-for-like comparison, there are many issues here and hundreds of variables between, but for a father’s subjective view, the experience he had was an eye opener. The second event was more mundane: as the costs associated with moving were high, we decided to look at alternative solutions, this inevitably brought us to doing the sums for private vs. free schooling. At first glance, the fees we looked at were eye-wateringly expensive- around £4000 per term but, quantifying this, we gleamed some insights. The total cost (until age eighteen) of private education (including extras) worked out at around 450K - which is in the same ballpark as the house move (if stamp duty and conveyancing were included). Also, we had five years left on the mortgage, so, in theory, if we were frugal for a relatively short amount of time, we could live normally again. However, this comes with a big compromise: we can only have one child. Yes, that's right, we're effectively sacrificing a child for the sake of a better education. In reality, that decision was taken away from us as it seems that (after a number of miscarriages) baby number two wasn't to be anyhow. Although it does seem sad to shut the door on that possibility, especially for monetary reasons. We'll just have to live with that, I guess.
Overall, I feel a little frustrated by the experience. No-one should be in a position which balances money over education - and this, I believe, is a direct result of underfunding: both in not building new schools and not giving the existing schools enough resources to improve. Austerity comes at a price, the biggest casualty hitting those in most need, exaggerating differences and widening the gap between the rich and the poor. And yes, before someone points this out, I am a hypocrite for both waving a leftist flag and then sending my child to private school. But then it's my child and I'm OK with that.
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Join the discussion on our Education forum.
Education
Our Story
27 replies
DirtForBrains · 01/09/2016 19:25
OP posts:
Don’t want to miss threads like this?
Weekly
Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!
Log in to update your newsletter preferences.
You've subscribed!
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.