Sorry, had not seen these responses... it is very interesting what both of you say...
If I am honest, yes, I will be bothered by what other people think/their reactions, but, at the end of the day, we still have to do what is right for our children. I intend to put the focus very firmly on our own daughter and her specific needs and try very hard not to criticise the school - where all our friends remain and are mostly happy with (although, given the number of grumbles already -year 1 - I can easily forsee a lot of change along the lines of goldenoldie's friends - tutors, move to independent later on etc). And yes, there are many i think who would object to our move from a political point of view too - they are so busy being right on. Interestingly I (in bold) kind of object to what we are doing too!! In an ideal world your local state primary should be the right thing to do. But at the end of the day i am not going to let right-on-ness come before what is right for my girls. I also think that, where we face hositility, there is likely to be some jealously, even if it will not be expressed as such. If we had NOT made the move and one of our friends did, I know it would raise lots of worries and questions for me and i might well have convinced myself that it went against what i believe in - in order to not feel jealous. So I will try to be 'gentle' with people even if they are hostile, because I think, for some, we will be opening a can of worms being the first of the parents to bottle out of the state system.
And at the end of the day, if people cannot see our point of view, especially when we will go out of our way to explain the decision as a very personal one for our child's needs, then there is nothing we can do... I can probably name the two lots of parents that will object politically. I can probably name also the parents who would secretly like to do the same - but probably can't afford to (which is why the 'gently' approach has to be kindest - afterall it ISN'T fair)- so there will be lots of 'we are really lucky' and 'we still think the school is good, but when you see your own child not thriving - unlike yours - you have to do something etc. etc....".
Anyway, fingers crossed!
Also interested what you say goldenoldie about tutoring etc. Part of our decision is based on a lack of willingness to go down that route - so much pressure on a little person and just as 'immoral' in right-on terms (if not more!!)as sending your child into indep. sector, in my view. I just think it is crazy to go all the way through primary and then at the end decide that the education there is not good enough and suddenly ram a whole load of info. down your child's throat in a mad panic to make amends for what they have been doing for the last 5 years. And if they then DON'T get into the selective schools, how demotivating is that for them? I think it is hypocritical really.
So very interesting questions raised definitely. Particularly sensitive for us as we MOVED to the area and bought our house specifically for the school we are now leaving and have made most of our local friends via school, so to then be considered bad eggs locally would be very upsetting. NO-ONE we know locally goes to private school. We are just going to have to be tough. And of course we leave this school's social circle but mustn't forget that we also enter into a NEW school with its own social thing going on so hopefully where we lose out we will also gain elsewhere...
Frogs, it sounds to me as if you can easily make a similar very personal case... You don't have to do your child down too much but can explain very clearly that while the school is fine for most and you wish it was fine for yours (which i am sure is true on some level), you don't think it will be a positive experience for your particular child - and what responsible parent would enter into something that they know wouldn't work - you wouldn't be able to live with that, if you feel like this already about the school.
It's definitely tricky!