4 year old ds with stutter - will private school help him??(33 Posts)
He is currently having therapy (his dad has a stutter too). I would prefer to send him to a state school (he will be starting reception in September), but would a smaller class size in a private school help him? Money would be an issue, but it is doable and I want to give him the best chance possible.
Any advise would be welcome - I am really worried about him....
Thanks schmedz. We are going to keep him in the state system. Thank you everyone for your feedback. Tb x
Test bunny, my DD is on the autistic spectrum and not in the state system. In hindsight, were she in a non-independent school she would have been referred through the school for diagnosis and had access to support services in school that have to be paid for privately because she is not in the state system.
There are probably very few state primaries that 'specialise' in supporting stammering, but at least in the state system you have the resources of any SEN team in the LEA more easily accessible (in theory). Michael Palin centre seems to be well respected and about the only specialist centre I have heard of to help with stammering in particular.
If the support you need is something that would normally be accessed through the LEA then you are better off in state school. If you choose private school you are closing the door on any help from the LEA.
Ds was well supported by the NHS from birth to starting school. He then needed something that was under the LEA's budget and the NHS could not help at all. We were told that if ds was in state school then he would be supported but as it came out of the LEA budget we could not because ds was at private school. Even the consultant in charge of the Child Development Centre couldn't do anything to help (she was equally frustrated by the attitude of the LEA).
testbunny please don't feel bad, you have done the right thing to get your child early intervention and I really don't think the actual school can do much to help in the sense of therapy. What I would suggest is speaking to the school at an early stage and explain that you child stammers and how to deal with it (e.g. not questionning, listening etc). If you don't feel confident I am sure your speech therapist will be happy to.
What you do need to sort out is the speech therapy into the future as well as how you can help at home. The Michael Palin Centre website has some really useful helpsheets etc as well. We found "time to talk" and "special time" really helpful as well as the more conventional approaches. We also went on a couple of parent/child courses there to learn the various techniques.
I felt awful when my DD developed her stammer at age 4. I was really hopeful that she would overcome it (they say if they have it after 7 years old it will most likely not go). But she didn't. Speech therapy in later years has concentrated more on helping her with techniques to deal with it. She also did a group course with other children as a young teenager. She is now 16 and still stammers. It doesn't stop her speaking in class or anything like that but she is quite self conscious about it.
It is strongly hereditary in my family, my Mum and Grandfather had it. My husbands and his brothers have dyslexia which one of my children also has. We were told that the genes for dyslexia and stammering often seem to run together in families. In my opinion dyslexia is much more difficult to deal with.
I think smaller would only be better of social phobia were part of the anxiety.
Personally we got no help from school private or state. My DD saw a local speech therapist for delayed speech and they refused to see her again for her stammer - refused to believe she had one. i rang up the head of speech therapy in my area and had a screaming row with her and contacted my MP. She eventually referred us - that was to the Michael Palin centre. DD has been seen there on and off for the last 12 years.
If you go to a state school you are in all likelihood going to have better access to any LEA services for speech therapy. In a private school you will pay for any extra support on top of fees.
I do think SEN is better supported in the state system.
OP please look at the Michael Palin Centres' website - some useful advice there. Sorry can't link as on phone.
I have a child who will have a stammer for life - it seems to be genetic like that of OP's child. I am very concerned that OP does not get the wrong impression. You are entitled to your opinion but I am not going to sit there and watch someone recommending solutions which in 12 years of studying stammering I think are utterly the wrong approach.
Emetophobesmum In my personal experience as a mum of a dc that had a very severe stammer/stutter, I actually found elocution to help him! One of the techniques we used was sitting together and chatting, and if he had a problem with a particular word or sentence, we would sound it out and practise it.
What works or doesn't work for YOUR child doesn't mean it will or won't work on another child. Your statements are only opinions, as are mine, and I found working alongside the ST as well as my own interaction and particularly practising sounds and words, helped my dc to overcome it. As I said, it has almost disappeared completely now. I think your comments to MissLurkalot are rude though and perhaps you need to relax.
Emet, please stop with your unkind remarks. I have not been unkind to you. I am purely offering advice to the OP about my experiences with young children who came to me, aswell as their Speech Therapist whilst at private school.
Stop trying to discredit everything I say. It's unkind to me, and frustrating for the OP and the other people following this thread.
Miss Lurkalot you should read up on how stammering is treated and you will see how it is blindingly obvious why speech and elocution are completely the wrong approach. It is likely to undo all the work the SLT has put in.
Ok, that's your opinion. I'm sorry it didn't work for your child.. But, that doesn't mean it wouldn't work for others.
As soon as you move out of the state system you lose access to Local Authority specialist support teams - Ed Psych, statements, funding etc.
The right school for your DC will make the most difference IME rather than smaller classes. So supportive knowledgeable SENCO.
I do not think speech and elocution are suitable for children who stammer. I did read your post and as the parent of a stammering child I think it would be an absolute disaster.
Talk to the SENCO after Easter. Then, and this may not be easy, try to set up a meeting between the class teacher, the speech therapist, and yourself and your child for September. Everyone will then know what they are supposed to be doing and, hopefully, using the same approach.
Emet.... I never said Speech and Drama replaces Speech Therapy.. !!!!
I would never suggest to replace it with what I do.
Read my post properly please before you put words into my mouth.
Of course Speech Therapy is vital. I was only saying Speech and Drama would work well alongside it. I've taught a number of pupils who had Speech Therapy aswell as coming to me! It can work hand in hand, especially with confidence.
No, a speech therapist will help him.
DS went to a private school for reception to year 2. When I took him privately to an Ed Psych, he said that he had LD of a dyslexic/dyspraxic nature. The so called SENCO did not even meet with me. (She had taught him in reception, and basically said he was lazy.) TBF, his classroom teacher was very supportive.
Anyway I have moved him to an other private school, but with much better SEN provision and he has come on apace.
So, do check with any school about how they will help him, before forking out a deposit!
(It would be cheaper to pay privately for a speech therapist than school fees......)
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now »
Already registered? Log in with:
Please login first.