My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Whether you enjoy writing sci-fi, fantasy or fiction, join our Creative Writing forum to meet others who love to write.

Creative writing

Just written this, be gentle!

21 replies

hazandduck · 05/06/2019 13:52

Hi,

I have just started writing a story I’ve had in my head for some time.

Just looking for opinions and any tips. I think it is probably a bit overly descriptive and wordy. Sorry if it’s crap.

Any who, thank you in advance :)


It was a jewel-bright day of autumn; glassy sunlight, shiny blue skies, a certain, almost imperceptible clarity that sharpened and silhouetted every car and tree and rooftop, penetrating the warmth of the day with a whisper of doubt.

There was a perfect white kiss drawn across the sky where the paths of two airplanes had met that Mary paused to admire as she crossed the bridge.

Despite being dog-tired, her feet aching, she was enjoying the walk, gulping in great lungfuls of the warm, sadness-tinged air, as all around her cars queued and revved, impatient drivers slurping take-out coffees and licking pastry crumbs off fingers in their race to work, students straggled and sulked and bopped, wearing headphones, inappropriately warm bobble hats, clutching oversized folders and a sense of their own importance.

Mary observed them with the hint of a smile drifting, remembering that feeling of change, of self-belief that you were the generation that would change the world.

September was a time of great shift; it always made her feel slightly out of touch and left behind. She thought of people she had seen die and of her own end, because with the hint of amber encroaching on the trees, there was a reminder that everything must end.

She had scrubbed and scrubbed but there was still a smell that lingered on her, of animals and straw, not quite extinguished by the alcohol gel, and she was imagining standing under her shower, washing off the smells of the delivery room, when a homeless man came to her attention just a few feet ahead.

He was hunching forward, draped in an oversized, dirty looking cape or blanket of some sort, and gave off an unhinged, possibly intoxicated energy. His greasy hair stood on end all over his head, and his skin was covered in welts and bruises. He was unshaven, red-eyed, mumbling to himself, unsteady on his feet. He looked as if he had been living under a bridge for some time.

Her instinct warned her to cross the road, to sidestep and avoid avoid avoid, assuming he would ask her for money. But then, he turned and looked directly at her, like a dog in a shelter pleading to be taken home, and Mary had an overwhelming wave of sadness break over her. She stopped dead, and as she watched the man stared at her, glassy-eyed, desperate.

He said something, so quietly and slurred, that Mary had to step forward to make it out. It sounded like “I was supposed to meet someone here…”

As she watched, he dropped the blanket to the ground and in a movement that belied his aged body, hauled himself up on to the concrete wall of the bridge.

“No!” Mary cried involuntarily and dashed towards him, her hand outstretched.

He jerked his head round to face her, teetering on top of the wall, and his cheeks glittered with tears. “I can’t bear it.”

She kept her hand out to him. “Just. Just hold my hand. We can get through it.”

The man snatched a breath, his chest heaving, up, down, and with each breath Mary held hers, watching him teeter and sway on the edge with her teeth clenched.

“Look. What’s your name?”

He bunched his fists and pushed them in to the sockets of his eyes tiredly, as if trying to push out the information. “I can’t remember.”

She swallowed. “I’m Mary. And I was meant to meet you. I was meant to meet you here.”

The man let out a long slow breath, staring out across the expanse of water, the September sun sparkling and cracking on the surface, to the rows of buildings lined uniformly along the embankment and the ant-like bodies of people moving far in the distance, living unsuspecting lives, entrenched in the trappings of another Tuesday morning routine.

Mary became aware of a crowd gathering around them, of people stopping to watch the young woman talking down a homeless man from the edge of a bridge.

He tilted his head at her, his eyes drinking in the blue uniform, bulky black shoes, the gleam of a pocket watch clipped to her breast pocket.

She had a sensation of someone stepping on her grave; the hairs on her arm stood on end. She forced herself to breathe, to keep her hand stretched out to him. “Listen to me. You are supposed to live.”

“I was meant to walk by here just as you climbed up, and I am here to tell you, you must live. The universe made us meet.”

The man stretched out his dirtied, blotchy hand and the tips of their fingers touched for a second. A small sob escaped him.

“I know,” he said.

OP posts:
Report
miffmufferedmoof · 05/06/2019 14:02

I wasn’t a big fan of the description in the first couple of paragraphs but after that I found it quite compelling reading and was disappointed to get to the end. Well done OP, miles better than anything I could do!

Report
cakeandchampagne · 05/06/2019 14:04

I think greasy hair would be matted, rather than looking “stood on end”.
The choice of the name “Mary” makes me wonder if a chapter two would reveal a religious theme.

Report
Arriettyborrower · 05/06/2019 14:07

Agree with miff, first few paragraphs are definitely over descriptive, you could tone them down a little and still effectively set the scene.

But, I was hooked by the end and want to know what happens next!

Report
hazandduck · 05/06/2019 14:13

Thank you everyone for your feedback! As I suspected, too descriptive! I’ll rehash it and carry on :) (when my demanding toddler allows it...😂)

OP posts:
Report
ScreamingValenta · 05/06/2019 17:13

I would get rid of everything before She had scrubbed and scrubbed and rewrite it so that's your opening point.

Report
notatwork · 05/06/2019 17:20

A nurse who uses alcohol gel to try and remove the smell of animals. Everyone else on the way to work but she's heading home (presumably) as her feet are tired?
The timeline is twisted somehow (possibly because of all the adjectives) and is setting off a dissonance which detracts from the plot.
I liked the denouement and like a pp was disappointed to get to the end..

Report
BookwormMe2 · 05/06/2019 17:27

Agree with ScreamingValenta - that's a much better starting point.

Report
hazandduck · 05/06/2019 20:34

Great tips thank you!

Ah yes I wanted to describe the people going to work to show she was finishing a night shift as a midwife, I don’t think I’ve given enough info if it’s unclear. The “animal straw” description was clumsy of me - it’s how I found the delivery room smelt after I gave birth and it’s all I have to go on (I still think my daughter’s hair smells like warm straw weirdly enough!)

I will try and tidy it up and rewrite.

Thank you all for this. I’ve written a little more but not ready to share it yet :)

OP posts:
Report
Hollowvictory · 05/06/2019 20:37

Lots of description like you're trying to use lots of adjectives in every sentence rather than choosing ones that really matter and add to the picture. I don't like stories about the universe making us meet but that's personal choice. I think with some editing of the description and more focus on the narrative it could be good!

Report
Hollowvictory · 05/06/2019 20:39

Ah it passed me by that she was a midwife tbh.

Report
Autumnchill · 05/06/2019 20:49

Agree with all the comments but as others, disappointed it ended. First part felt over descriptive but the latter part drew me in (and I normally ignore descriptive text and just concentrate on the speech).

You left me wanting to read more and that's always good!

Report
Autumnchill · 05/06/2019 20:50

(I thought she was a vet!)

Report
InvisibleHamster · 05/06/2019 20:56

Don’t be too writerly just write :D (most useless advice ever). You have a good plot going on here which is probably harder than developing good writing so I’d focus on keeping it simple. At the beginning I was wondering exactly whose ‘clarity’ I was perceiving, at the end I was wondering if the man was going to live, if they really were destined to meet!

Report
hazandduck · 05/06/2019 20:59

Ha ha definitely need some clarity on the mw part then!

Thank you for your comments, I am glad it has interested you at the end...I’ll keep going!

I love the anonymity of this. I hate people reading anything I write normally.

OP posts:
Report
JinglingHellsBells · 08/06/2019 22:27

@hazandduck

Too many cliched phrases in the first 3 paragraphs ( too much description.)

jewel bright, shiny blue skies,
penetrating the warmth of the day with a whisper of doubt. eh?


The sun didn't have a whisper of doubt? Nope, this metaphor doesn't work.

You're trying too hard with description. Less is more. Same for the rest.

She had a sensation of someone stepping on her grave; the hairs on her arm stood on end

Another cliche- 'stepping on her grave'.

Report
Sugaronjam · 08/06/2019 22:34

I agree the first paragraph is too much it didn't flow well for me. I also was confused about whether she was a vet or a midwife the straw confused me. Apart from that it was really interesting and I wanted to read more.

Report
FenellaMaxwell · 08/06/2019 22:34

It gets very muddied by the floral language and over-use of description. Stop thinking about how to write pretty sentences, and start thinking about what you want to tell us. For example you’ve taken 2 entire paragraphs to say “it was a nice day”. It’s not necessary. Think back to the very basics of storytelling - who, what, when, where, why - and think about the journey to giving the reader that information, not in describing every single thing on the journey there.

Report
Chocolateychocolate · 26/06/2019 13:28

Agree with others; the first couple of paragraphs far too descriptive/adjectivey, I just wanted to skim read them...so I did! The rest is pretty damned good though, imho. Well done for posting too; I am too scared to.

Report
brainfrying · 10/07/2019 15:40

I don't have any advice I just wanted to say how much I loved it and wanted to keep reading. Well done you are very talented, keep going OP!

Report
Morgan12 · 10/07/2019 15:56

I like it. But I would change her name. What age is she? Mary makes me think of someone late 50s or 60s. Also thought she was a vet.

I want to read more!

Report
hazandduck · 16/07/2019 12:48

Wow sorry I somehow lost this thread!

Thank you everyone for such awesome feedback and for taking the time to read my post.

I have been utterly crap and not written anything for ages now as I’m in the throes of the first trimester and forgot just how much it wipes me out. I keep getting in to bed at night with a pen and paper and waking up to find it’s morning! Hopefully when I’m a little less tired I will be able to focus and crack on with writing some more of this story.

Also, thank you for the name comments. I will have a think about changing it, there was a reason for the choice but it’s not essential to the story.

OP posts:
Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.