This was floated on a previous thread back in the spring, but:
If we had no choice other than to do blended learning, TVs might well be a better medium than the internet.
Put Oak. style filmed lessons and mini lectures/explanations on BBC channels (it is a public service, after all--this is what we have public services for) and then distribute standardized and centrally produced worksheets correlated with the content. To be done in paper format, the old fashioned way. No computer required. Teachers would only have the job of collecting and checking work, doing feedback and making contact individually with pupils and families to offer advice.
Virtually every family has a TV set, so this guarantees access without requiring multiple devices or a certain level of internet speed or quality, and does not create conflict with parents who also need to use devices and internet access to WFH.
The TV content could also be streamed online for the small number of families who have a computer but no TV. Very very few people have no TV and no other devices either; the few that do are likely to be fairly "alternative" types who will most likely be doing their own version of homeschooling in any case.
I don't know if UK TVs allow parents to control which channels can be selected, but if this is possible, it also avoids the problems caused by the huge amount of distraction created when children are handed internet-enabled devices.
This is sort of roughly what happened in much of Japan, where I live. Pen and paper worksheets, plus TV for lesson stuff (NHK, in our case). It was not perfect, but it was frankly better than trying to get multiple-laptops-per-household-plus-fast-internet-for-all sorted out in about 10 seconds flat.
"TV" has an outdated image compared to online learning, but I think it is perhaps the "least terrible" solution if we have no choice other than to close schools.
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Mumsnet doesn't verify the qualifications of users. If you have medical concerns, please consult a healthcare professional.
Covid
Reviving a previous idea, but using TV would be better than computers if we have to do remote schooling
9 replies
Kokeshi123 · 02/11/2020 01:01
OP posts:
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.