Talk

Advanced search

If vaccine what would be order list of distribution

(48 Posts)
scotlandg Tue 19-May-20 19:38:20

In terms of people what would think think maybe the roll out eligibility order?
Do you think people in the vulnerable but not critically vulnerable would be on the list to receive ?
Thank you

OP’s posts: |
NotAnotherUserNumber Tue 19-May-20 19:51:55

This is just a guess, but I think it would be frontline key workers first (doctors, nurses, carers, police etc.) followed by the most vulnerable and then people in care homes and other residential settings.

FourPlasticRings Tue 19-May-20 19:55:01

Pregnant women are classes as vulnerable- it would be interesting to see whether additional testing is required to make it available to them.

MereDintofPandiculation Tue 19-May-20 21:13:04

I think it would go by risk, so first frontline key workers, then care home residents, then other workers and children, and anyone shielding or self isolating at home will be last on the list.

cptartapp Tue 19-May-20 21:19:53

The immunosuppressed often have a suboptimal response to vaccines, as do the elderly which is why the flu vaccine was adjusted for the over 65's a couple of years ago. I wonder whether the reduced efficacy in this age group would influence the prioritising to whom it's given.

PlanDeRaccordement Tue 19-May-20 21:23:57

It’ll probably be the same as the way they did the swine flu shot- so the shielded and vulnerable, the healthcare workers, first.

Disquieted1 Tue 19-May-20 21:34:51

I know nothing, but I guess it might be influenced by how long it takes to be effective. I can't imagine that you have a shot and voila you're immune, it could take weeks or months of several shots to be effective. If so, it might de-prioritise pregnant women for example, or those who require imminent operations, or even some who are shielding as one dose may make them worse.
Usually a new vaccine would have years of rigorous testing to iron all of this out. In the case of a covid vaccine I don't believe that the world will wait.

scotlandg Tue 19-May-20 21:49:45

Thank you. I have fairly bad asthma so vulnerable but not shielded. I am also a carer for my disabled son and have two other children. I feel guilty that because of me we will keep them off preschool etc so hence wondering.

OP’s posts: |
oralengineer Tue 19-May-20 21:53:16

With swine flu they prioritised Primary care and NHS so they could look after everyone else.

EdwynCollins Tue 19-May-20 21:56:20

They have just addressed this on Horizon on BBC2.
NHS and care staff then vulnerable including care home but not if its a life vaccine. If its live it will have to be care workers and those who don't have a compromised immune system

Confuzzlediddled Tue 19-May-20 21:56:56

@MereDintofPandiculation out of interest why do you think those who are shielding would be last, given that those are a high risk group? Not all who are in the shielding group don't work!

DahliaDay Tue 19-May-20 21:58:57

I think retail workers should be added in with key workers too

OceanOrchid Tue 19-May-20 22:11:41

NHS, care workers first. Next on my list would be emergency services. Then food chain workers (everyone seems to remember supermarket staff but forget farmers and food haulage workers). Finally all other “key workers” from the government list before general population.

Personally, I wouldn’t choose to give it to vulnerable people first because it will not have been tested to the same extent as vaccines normally are. “Fast tracked” means “we need to skip a few steps” and that makes me nervous, though I’m normally hugely pro-vaccine.

IncrediblySadToo Tue 19-May-20 22:11:55

Assuming it's suitable/safe for each group I'd like to think...

NHS & careworkers - any other at risk 'proper' healthcare workers
Carehome residents
Shielded
Dentists & other key workers
Vulnerable (yes, even us diabetic scum)
Over 50's

No one who has uttered the words 'it's only a cold' or 'Hiding at home/pathetic/something scathing about people who have been scared'

Who makes the decision PHE? The Govt? Other??

Kittywampus Wed 20-May-20 08:24:14

I would think it would be

Shielded
NHS / carers
Care home residents
Other vulnerable (the flu jab list)
Everyone else

However I guess it depends on the vaccine trials. If they decide that the vaccine doesn't work as well in older people, or is risky for certain people in the shielded group. If so they might have to try to create herd immunity by giving it to the fit and healthy people.

SpnBaby1967 Wed 20-May-20 08:38:00

I read that it would make more sense to give it to the carers/household members of the shielded rather than the shielded themselves as many of these people have immunocompromised issues that could make the vaccine ineffective for them.

I think it'll be

Emergency services/HCPs (possibly their household members)
Care home workers
Children
Carers

NotaFreeloader Wed 20-May-20 08:39:56

I don’t think anything is ever ‘tested’ as such for pregnancy as it’s unethical in case something goes wrong so they have to make sure it’s safe for the general population then weigh up benefit v risk

Alex50 Wed 20-May-20 09:46:29

Why children when they are the least at risk? Why do they need the vaccine at all?

FourPlasticRings Wed 20-May-20 12:50:11

@NotaFreeloader

That's interesting. I decided to Google it on the back of that and found this from the FDA, though obviously that's American so procedures might differ here.

FourPlasticRings Wed 20-May-20 12:51:37

Why children when they are the least at risk? Why do they need the vaccine at all?

Depends on how effective the kids are at spreading it, really. If they are capable of passing it on, then vaccinating the kids protects the adults and other children they come into contact with who for one reason or another cannot be vaccinated.

MashedPotatoBrainz Wed 20-May-20 13:01:01

On Horizon last night they seemed to suggest that the most vulnerable would get it first. The reason being there will be risks involved in a rushed through vaccine, so start with the ones where the risk of not having it outweigh the risk of having it. Made them sound a bit like guinea pigs to me.

cornish009 Wed 20-May-20 13:01:20

My fear all along has been that the shielded group (my husband is in it) will be the first, and almost used as guinea pigs before it is released to others. In recent weeks I have found some of the actions and language used about the shielded group has made me feel they are second class citizens (and therefore expendable). The perception of the shielded group in some media outlets is that they are all ancient and very disabled - when actually in my husband's case, and thousands of other, that is not the case at all. So I am truly frightened by the direction things seem to be headed in.

Tfoot75 Wed 20-May-20 13:03:18

Too far down the line to speculate I'd have thought. Presumably, like flu, there would not be a benefit vs cost of delivering vaccine to all, when healthy young people have very little risk of severe illness. Health and social care workers would obviously be first due to their impact on the R rate.

cornish009 Wed 20-May-20 13:03:24

MashedPotatoBrainz - cross posted but yes I agree with you. I also feel that during these tragic times the loss of life of someone in the shielded group will not be deemed as serious/upsetting as those not being shielded. So guinea pigs for sure!

Alex50 Wed 20-May-20 13:05:48

I wouldn’t want to be one of the first to take it and why risk children taking it when the virus is of such little risk to them.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »