Advanced search

Immunity passports

(17 Posts)
Alex50 Mon 04-May-20 07:31:45

How would this work?

OP’s posts: |
Redolent Mon 04-May-20 07:36:12

Uninformed speculation ensues.

LangClegsInSpace Mon 04-May-20 08:41:44

So not content with WHO's explanation of why this is a shit idea, the government proposes to make it even worse by incorporating face recognition technology.

BrexpatInSwitzerland Mon 04-May-20 08:52:42

It's a horrible idea! Even assuming we were confident in the data around immunity.

For one, it may lead to people deliberately getting infected out of desperation.

As a tech sector executive, I'm also recognising another familiar pattern: if it's new and "sexy" in technology, slap it onto everything you can because ... reasons. Face recognition is utterly unneccessary for this purpose. A piece of paper or a digitally signed app in combination with any piece of photo id suffices entirely and is a lot less intrustive.

This reminds me of that time a few years back when some idiot colleague of mine wanted to pitch the idea of tracking pilots using blockchain to a major airline client: first of all, it's not exactly as though there are a) multiple parties involved in a situation where no inherent trust can be built. It's also not as though b) it's at all likely that a pilot's leg would be silently switched with a shorter one in mid flight and noone was likely to notice. Pilots are physical being, not data! Long story short, this was obviously a fucking stupid idea that solved a problem long solved in a new and entirely unneccessary manner - but "blockchain" was sexy and hence had to be pushed. Happy to report we never did pitch this thanks to my boss being eminently sensible and listening to reason despite his initial enthusiasm.

Sometimes I despair of my industry. Let tech solve new problems or improve on things. That's what we're good at.

Also, we generally suck at epidemiology. It's not our field!

Nappyvalley15 Mon 04-May-20 08:59:20

Sounds awful.
Plus facial recognition tech is rubbish for identifying people with dark skin.

MrsWhites Mon 04-May-20 09:45:44

I think any sort of ‘immunity passport’ is a horrible idea. Are those not immune (likely because they followed the rules and stayed at home) to be plunged into poverty or will the government pay their wage until they catch the virus?

Remember chicken pox parties anyone? Will we have people holding the Coronavirus version of these?

CrunchyCarrot Mon 04-May-20 09:49:23

Sounds like a Dominic Cummings idea, or something he'd like. I don't think immunity in the case of Covid-19 is so black and white and simple. I wish they'd spend the money and time on other ideas.

Alex50 Mon 04-May-20 09:52:27

Yes I think it’s an awful idea, you would have 2 tier system, if you didn’t have an immunity passport, you wouldn’t be able to work, you wouldn’t be able to travel, enter buildings, it’s like something out of a horrible film.
There also talking about wristbands

OP’s posts: |
LangClegsInSpace Mon 04-May-20 09:58:18

Sounds like a Dominic Cummings idea, or something he'd like.

Yes I was thinking that. I also notice the contact tracing app now looks like it will be based on a centralised database and not locally held bluetooth data as originally proposed.

Fuck that shit.

Alex50 Mon 04-May-20 10:01:07

It’s scary times, such control over the masses is more frightening than the virus. I don’t think our freedom will ever be the same again.

OP’s posts: |
BentBastard Mon 04-May-20 10:20:58

I hate the idea, although I admit I hate it for selfish reasons. I've barely left the house bar one chemist visit. If I didn't get CV before lockdown, I'm not going to and I will be at the back of the queue for a vaccine.

Ariela Mon 04-May-20 10:43:21

As I see it the best way forward would be testing made available in city/large town areas particularly to determine what % of the population has HAD the virus to determine how tight or lax the social distancing needs be.

LangClegsInSpace Mon 04-May-20 10:51:24

Oh look -

Alex50 Mon 04-May-20 10:52:22

I don’t know how true this is:

OP’s posts: |
LangClegsInSpace Mon 04-May-20 10:54:13

Yes Ariela, I think that's the most useful thing we could be doing with antibody testing at the moment.

Many countries are now testing for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies at the population level or in specific groups, such as health workers, close contacts of known cases, or within households.21 WHO supports these studies, as they are critical for understanding the extent of – and risk factors associated with – infection. These studies will provide data on the percentage of people with detectable COVID-19 antibodies, but most are not designed to determine whether those people are immune to secondary infections.

KenDodd Mon 04-May-20 11:06:12

And look who got the contract for the tracker.

BirdieFriendReturns Mon 04-May-20 11:11:10

KenDodd - I was just about to post that link!

No app for me thank you.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, quick, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Get started »