Advanced search

Mumsnetters aren't necessarily qualified to help if your child is unwell. If you have any serious medical concerns, we would urge you to consult your GP.

is 113cm in height worryingly small for a 5yr old ?

(30 Posts)
Pancakeflipper Tue 17-Jun-14 12:43:20

DS was seeing his consultant today at hospital. Our GP had wrote an update letter regarding DS.

3 issues in the letter from GP - and 1 issue was DS "is worryingly small for his height. "

The nurse always weighs/measures when we see the consultant. Today he is 113cm.

I have never thought to worry about his height..... he looks average to me.

Still bemused by this and I cannot find that bloody book with the centile in it.

tobysmum77 Sat 21-Jun-14 21:50:25

its 9th centile for bmi not weight. children are meant to be between 2nd and 91st according to the nhs.

movicolforimpaction Sat 21-Jun-14 21:16:47

9th centile for weight and 91st for height is a large disparity as you would be expected to be on a similar centile or just one or two different. It also depends what he was at the hospital to see the consultant about for example if he was being assessed for coeliac or similar then this disparity would be very significant.

tobysmum77 Tue 17-Jun-14 21:54:07

according to the nhs calculator he is 9th centile bmi so perfectly healthy weight.

tobysmum77 Tue 17-Jun-14 21:51:40

his weight sounds fine to me, on the slim side but fine. dd is a couple of cm shorter but under 18kg and I think she's about 25th centile bmi do I don't 113 and 18kg is underweight. I think the doctor is bonkers, God knows what he's on about.

Percephone Tue 17-Jun-14 21:22:28

I wouldn't worry too much if he looks healthy and is eating well. Some children are just slim! My baby's weight is 25th centile and his head is 91st. We all have big heads blush

SantasLittleMonkeyButler Tue 17-Jun-14 19:10:12

Yes, I read that comment as being a weight concern rather than a height one.

That said, I wouldn't worry if you are happy that DS is eating well enough. We once worried ourselves sick when a Consultant told us that DS1's head was "worryingly huge", and that it was almost certainly a sign of something sinister.

He is 17 this year. It wasn't anything to worry about. He's just got a big head! As have I & as did my DM.

Pancakeflipper Tue 17-Jun-14 19:04:44

I think you could be right Percephone. Looking at it like that there looms to be a difference. Thing is, genetically we are more of a runner bean shape than a marrow. And he looks chunkier than he weighs...

Would be easy for the clothing manufacturers if we were all the same shape.

Percephone Tue 17-Jun-14 18:07:26

Oh sorry you said 18kg. Well if that is around 25th centile and his height is 75th centile perhaps that is the concern?

Percephone Tue 17-Jun-14 18:05:16

What is his weight?

Sirzy Tue 17-Jun-14 17:19:27

DS is 4.5 and 105 cm (and 17kg) nothing has ever been mentioned at his hospital appointment about his height/weight

306235388 Tue 17-Jun-14 13:28:39

Dd is 3 and 112cm and is the same height as most of the 5 year olds we know so If have thought that height wise he was average just maybe a bit skinny.

CustardFromATin Tue 17-Jun-14 13:15:58

Agree it sounds like a weight concern. Can you see what the weight was when measured by the nurse? The school weigh in could have had quite a different number, variances between scales, what was eaten for breakfast and clothing could easily sway it 1-2kgs either way.

fledermaus Tue 17-Jun-14 13:03:16

A difference of a centile or two between height and weight isn't worryingly skinny though. My DS is similar, 50th for height and just below 25th for weight and has a low but healthy BMI.

Seeline Tue 17-Jun-14 13:00:24

That weight is between 25th and 50th percentiles for 5 yo - so much lower than his height would indicate.

fledermaus Tue 17-Jun-14 13:00:00

The NHS BMI calculator puts 113cm and 18kg at 9th centile for a 5 yo boy - slim but still healthy.

Enb76 Tue 17-Jun-14 12:58:12

That's a concern about weight, not height.

poorbuthappy Tue 17-Jun-14 12:57:41

My twins are 105cm at 5.5

Pancakeflipper Tue 17-Jun-14 12:57:00

I am sure at weigh-in today they said he is 18kg (no shoes but school uniform on).

He was a chunky baby but has slimmed out especially leg-wise. That fits our family size -siblings are very skinny, the knobbly knee kids with stick legs - in fact he's not as slim as them. He has chubby cheeks!

Thank you for sharing your shapes and sizes - it's not something to be worried about but probably just be aware of.
Thank you lovely people. Appreciate the info and reassurance.

Boudica1990 Tue 17-Jun-14 12:55:07

Im only 47cm taller than your 5 year old blush !! Wow I'm short... I would t worry about his height, it sounds.more like there is a concern for his weight. Is he quite thin?

RoganJosh Tue 17-Jun-14 12:53:04

If he's 75th centile for height and about 5, then he would be around 3 stone according to the charts.

hazeyjane Tue 17-Jun-14 12:51:50

Ah, yes small for height sounds like a concern over weight?

RoganJosh Tue 17-Jun-14 12:51:17

Shows the centiles.

hazeyjane Tue 17-Jun-14 12:50:59

Looking at ds's chart, 113 cm for a 5 year old is approx 75th centile, so not short at all?!

Ds is 4 and just under the centile lines!

Undertheboredwalk Tue 17-Jun-14 12:50:16

Just re-read and worryingly small for his height does sound like the dr thinks he's underweight rather than small. What was his weight?

WowOoo Tue 17-Jun-14 12:49:11

That does not make sense, sorry!

Does the GP think he's too thin for a child of 113cm or that 113cm is too short for his age?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now