Advanced search

This topic is for discussing childcare options. If you want to advertise, please use your Local site.

CMs - Need some advice about adult child ratio for 4 yr old at school

(17 Posts)
katalex Sun 25-Oct-09 10:15:02

I went to see a cm yesterday to meet her and discuss her providing before and after school care for my 4 year old daughter. I was so relieved to find someone who can help me after trying 27 other childminders in our town. It was all going really well until she told me that, because dd is under 5, I will also have to pay her for the time dd is in school because she would then be unable to fill the space with a full time under 5. I said that I thought the rule was that if they were at school then they were considered over 5 (my mum was a cm for 25 years). But she said that she has been advised to do this. I had a look on the NCMA web site which agrees with what I said. Are there any exceptions to this rule? Is it at the discretion of the cm?

crace Sun 25-Oct-09 11:06:01

I will wait until someone who knows for sure, but yes I would think she would be a rising 5.. and considered 5 and above space

Katymac Sun 25-Oct-09 11:20:32

If she attend full-time school she is a rising 5 - the CM should check with OFSTED but imo she counts as a 5yo (exceptshe will need to administer EYFS for your DD)

nicm Sun 25-Oct-09 12:10:03

are you in england? ni has different rules and would still be an under 5 even if at school ft.

footychick Sun 25-Oct-09 17:33:31

OK, if your daughter is under 5 BUT attending 10 sessions (full-time)of school per week, she is a rising 5, so will not affect her under 5 ratio, so therefore should have no reason to charge any additional fees. If she was is in the process of starting school,ie only attending a percentage of the 10 sessions, then the childminder could request a variation from Ofsted or charge you an additional fee whilst she took the under 5 space. I was at a meeting with Ofsted recently and this was confirmed. They did say the childminder should let Ofsted know that they have a rising 5 on their books and this would be recorded on the childminders registration certificate, however they also said that they will let childminders know this when they inspected them.

atworknotworking Sun 25-Oct-09 18:17:17

footychick why do we have to inform Ofsted if we have rising 5's?

katalex most cm's don't charge when a child goes to school full time, usually just for the time they are with the minder, however CM's can state their own terms and has nothing to do with NCMA or Ofsted they do not have any regulations over business arrangements only quality of care.

If your DD is in the rising 5's catagory, cm can count her as an over 5 for the purposes of ratios / registration.

Danthe4th Sun 25-Oct-09 18:53:39

Perhaps she only wants full timers, or are you after holiday care or term time only. She may be misunderstanding what you wanted.

footychick Sun 25-Oct-09 19:22:52

katalex My understanding of this from the meeting I had with Ofsted is that they are going to tell all childminders who mind rising 5's that they are going to impose a variation on their registration, and actually state that they have a rising 5. This will take away the 'holiday' issue. They do not want to cause panic and will inform childminders during their inspections.

katalex Sun 25-Oct-09 21:15:02

Hi, thanks for the confirmation.

nicm - Yes I'm in England.

Danthe4th - I told her it was term time only.

I'll give her a call tomorrow to discuss but if she still wants to charge full price then I'll just have to pay it until dd turns 5 as she's the only cm who has a vacancy who can go to dd's school.

sofewbraincellsleft Sun 25-Oct-09 22:10:29

Katalex, there is no reason for her to charge full fees if your dd is attending all 10 sessions at school.

I agree childminders can dictate their own terms and conditions but blowed if I would pay full fees if my child was attending full time school.

Katymac Sun 25-Oct-09 23:26:24

The inspector that came to see me most recently said thatin our area we won't be getting variations on our certificate

Rising 5's are just that - no discussion

Nice to know they all say the same thing hmm

atworknotworking Mon 26-Oct-09 08:12:16

I can't see why they would want to add a variation for rising 5's, they are still counted in ratios in one group or another. It seems like a lot more paperwork for nothing.

Its all very hmm

katalex Mon 26-Oct-09 11:05:30

sofew - I know what you mean. I would be very unhappy about having to pay full time fees but, sadly it's either that or I have to give up work and I won't be able to find another full time job when/if I'm made redundant in December.

Any ideas how I can tell her without causing offence i.e. implying that I didn't believe her?

Katymac Mon 26-Oct-09 11:35:14

Bottom of p15 in this doc

Danthe4th Tue 27-Oct-09 12:15:48

How did your discussion go with the cm. Just wondered if youve got it sorted.

katalex Tue 27-Oct-09 19:44:31

Hi Dan. It seemed to go ok. I told her that it had been confirmed that Katelyn would not be counted as one of her under 5s. She said that she had been told different and was once told off for having too many under 5s, one of which was a 4 year old at school. I asked her if she would be able to look into it and get back to me. She agreed but she hasn't called back yet. I'll let you know what she says when she calls.

katalex Thu 29-Oct-09 15:35:17

The cm phoned today to say that the NCMA confirmed what I had said. She has agreed to look after dd and only charge for the hours used. I'm so pleased grin

Thanks everyone.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: