C section with Dr. Ian Treharne at st T, anyone knows him?(11 Posts)
Really sorry but I saw this man when I was a student in Colchester in the 80s for a gynaecological problem. He was an absolute brute - I was very young and terribly traumatised. As was the girl before me who was only 17. He may be a good obstetrician but was totally inappropriate in his conduct in many ways as a gynaecologist - when I wrote to him afterwards he stated it was the nurses that were at fault being chauvinistic , not him. I think this is why he was put under observation in Essex. Sadly, the trauma lives with me to this day and after having had two children and no such further incidents. I'm sure he wouldn't make the same mistakes again - but the record did need to be put straight here. I saw him in 1986 but the complaints didn't surface until 2000. Probably with a culture change. Things were bad back then.
I'm really surprised by reading some of these posts as I had Ian as my Consultant with my son and he was wonderful! He treated me as an inpatient and outpatient (antenatal) and delivered my son via a tricky section. He also stopped my significant bleed during the section so I'm eternally grateful to him.
I can't comment on the article that is mentioned but my experience of him was caring, professional and competent; I'm just sad he doesn't work at the hospital anymore to help me with my second pregnancy!
I hope all the ladies who were about to have their babies had positive outcomes
I actually wanted to post a positive note about dr Treharne on this post. It was a while ago now (around 1.5 years ago) and I had a planned C section performed by him (I had to deliver thruogh CS) and I found him extremely professional, polite and very caring doctor! I had to spend 10 days in antenatal ward (as he was concerned I might bleed with my condition). He visited me amost every day, after performing his daily c section procedures, even though he wasn't on ward duty! The c section went very well and he also visited me after delivery although I was then transferred into private wing at st. thomas and was under the care of different doctor!
If I get pregnant second time, I will request for him to be my consultant again....
Dr. Treharne was my consultant during the pregnancy and performed emergency c-section under general anaesthetics. I had to spend about a month in hospital antenatally and he always was polite, caferul and professional.
When I first ended up in hospital, one of the registrars whom I was seeing read in my notes that Dr. Treharne is my consultant and told me that "I souldn't worry because I'm under the care of one of the best doctors at the hospital".
I will aslo have my c section performed by this consultant...I would be great if you could give me some information as well (also as private message if you do not want to talk on the forum). I would really appreciate it as I am so scared of this whole procedure!
Thanks a lot
Hi, I have just had a last minute change in consultants to Dr Treharne as my previous consultant will now be away. Do you mind me asking how you found him and how it went? Also if anyone else has any advice. It's just a bit scary changing at the last minute for a big operation! Thanks
He performed a potentially tricky c section on me (tricky due to the awkward transverse lie of the baby) in 2010 with no problems or complications. All was fine (and yes, he is very nice). I was unaware of this bad publicity he'd had in the past (which was probably just as well as I was very anxious at the time).
Of course that is just my one experience, so I can't tell you much more. Overall, I thought the ST team were very good though (its just the postnatal ward which was horrible).
If you have concerns I think you could always ask to talk with him or one of the team there though (they must have to deal with these issues sometimes -see how you feel after that as I'm sure you can always request someone else).
The info i ve got so far is that the doctor is one of the top consultants at st Thomas; also nothing wrong has been proved regarding his case at 2000. Hope this will be helpful for those who might be interested
Hi laluna, i sent you a PM via 'Message poster' on the top right of the post, may you please check? thanks
Need to pm you but don't seem able to. Will reply if you get in touch.
Due to medical reasons Ill have a C section. The operation will probably be under Dr Ian Treharne at St Thomas hospital. He seems to be nice and experienced, however, a google search has put us in a state of panic! We found on BBC news:
it says he has been suspended following concerns over the standard of his work, conduct and attitude to his patients it was 10 years ago but we are still worried as no further information on him since then! Also Ive never had any operation in my life!
Anyone has any info on him? or any advice please? Thank you!
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.