Talk

Advanced search

Mumsnetters aren't necessarily qualified to help if your child is unwell. If you need professional help, please see our mental health webguide

Has anyone's child been diagnosed with PDA (Pathological Demand Avoidance)?

(19 Posts)
Oh2beatsea Sun 09-Apr-17 22:14:52

We recently saw a Paediatrician who didn't feel my 9 year old daughter had autism as she has friends and can make eye contact!
When I asked about PDA the dr said they don't diagnose it as it would come under the autistic umbrella but I could ask our GP to refer her to a private clinic specialising in PDA (costing £3000) which would need CCG funding. This didn't make sense as she didn't think my daughter had autism. Has anyone managed to get PDA diagnosed via the NHS?

Jamhandprints Sun 09-Apr-17 22:17:38

What is this?

OneThingAndThenTheNext Sun 09-Apr-17 22:19:11

I know a few people with a private diagnosis, or an NHS diagnosis of autism with demand avoidance traits. Don't know of any NHS actual PDA diagnosises.

outputgap Sun 09-Apr-17 22:25:20

A child psychologist working in this area told me recently that the UK doesn't really recognise PDA as a separate diagnosis, but instead it is an expression of autism, and that's what the diagnosis would be.

emochild Sun 09-Apr-17 22:25:31

My dd has a diagnosis of aspergers with demand avoidant traits

Nhs psychologist said that's the closest they can diagnose to pda in our area

We have discussed the pros and cons of a private diagnosis but the demand avoidance listed as part of her diagnosis, and a fantastically supportive camhs worker, means that she's getting the support she needs in terms of EHCP provision without an explicit diagnosis

soapboxqueen Sun 09-Apr-17 22:25:38

It isn't in the WHO diagnostic manual so it's a bit of a catch 22. It isn't diagnosed because it isn't in the manual, it isn't in the manual because nobody is diagnosing it.

My ds has autism with pda traits.

Starlight2345 Sun 09-Apr-17 22:27:47

I am on a FB group for PDA uk.. It does talk about areas that diagnose and under what.. My DS doesn't have the diagnosis but head thinks he does have it.

Mogtheanxiouscat Sun 09-Apr-17 22:45:02

You can make eye contact and have friends and still have aspergers. Particulary girls.

Can you get a second opinion?

Oh2beatsea Wed 12-Apr-17 15:24:51

Thanks everyone. We have a CAMHS first appointment coming up soon. I'm thinking of printing off the PDA checklist to discuss. The SENCO at her school also explained the difference between boys and girls with autism and how girls mask very well. The Paed diagnosed General Anxiety Disorder, hence the CAMHS referral but I feel she missed the point really. I feel if we don't get the correct diagnosis now, it could become really difficult as she moves up to senior school and when the hormones kick in!!

potatoscowls Wed 12-Apr-17 15:27:07

Go to the lorna wing centre in kent if you can. They diagnosed me (after 18 years undiagnosed)
All the best

Blossom789 Mon 17-Apr-17 15:19:09

I think camhs would be far better placed to assess. Take your queries about PDA but also think about autism as pda comes under this umbrella. Look up the triad of impairment and consider any examples where your daughter may fit. The Australian aspergers scale is also helpful www.aspennj.org/pdf/information/articles/australian-scale-for-asperger-syndrome.pdf I wouldn't imagine camhs would pay too much attention to what the paediatrician has diagnosed and will make their own assessment. Hope it goes well.

Oh2beatsea Fri 21-Apr-17 11:09:12

Hi Blossom. Thank you so much for this - you seem very knowledgeable. The Australian scale is pertinent too - I can tick lots of those!
Thanks again- much appreciated.

Blossom789 Fri 21-Apr-17 12:54:12

You're welcome, I work for camhs and have quite an interest in assessment and understanding young people's behaviour and mental health. I always find it helpful to have some written examples when using the questionnaire especially if your scoring 5 or 6's. Good luck, will you post again when you've had the appointment. Any other queries give me a shout.

differentnameforthis Fri 21-Apr-17 13:50:54

Urgh..I wish paediatricians would get with the times!!! Making eye contact and having friends does not rule out autism!!

OP, be aware that often times, in my experience, autism in girls can be and is misdiagnosed as a behavioural issue.

Oh2beatsea Sun 23-Apr-17 20:31:02

Thank you Blossom and Different for your help. Yes I will report back when we've had the appointment.

notapizzaeater Sun 23-Apr-17 20:40:40

My son has ASC with demand avoidance and makes lovely eye contact, has a wicked sense of humour and lots of real empathy ...... Bloody annoying when they blanket everyone !

differentnameforthis Mon 24-Apr-17 09:49:15

Good luck! We have an assessment booked for May for ASD for our 8yr old. She has friends, although misses many social cues, and she is hit and miss with eye contact.

Imnotacelebgetmeouttahere Mon 24-Apr-17 09:51:37

My 3yr old DD was diagnosed with Autism with a PDA profile as it's not considered a stand alone diagnosis in our area - but she has autism anyway so sort of irrelevant!

Eye contact is common in girls hmm as are superficial social skills so she may well have friends and still have ASD

imip Mon 24-Apr-17 09:52:42

Op, looking around the SN boards here is also very useful. My dd8 has ASD and is demand avoidant. She can tick every box on a PDA checklist but it isn't diagnosed by cahms in my area as it is not included in DSM5.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now