Talk

Advanced search

We've spent weeks researching and testing the best new family cars on the market. Read our family car reviews to find out which ones were awarded Mumsnet Best.

Pulsar/Qashqai or Honda CRV?

(11 Posts)
boilingkettle Mon 11-Jun-18 17:35:40

Just that really, which would you choose? If we go for the Qashqai or Honda, they’ll be 6/7 year old with 60-70,000 miles on them. Pulsar would be younger with less miles but approx a grand more price wise. Interested to hear from owners to get your thoughts. Thanks!

CarDad Mon 11-Jun-18 21:20:57

what is your price range and do you want diesel or petrol?

boilingkettle Mon 11-Jun-18 22:38:12

No more than £7500 ideally, and have never had a diesel so probably petrol. My mechanic did advise one over the other in relation to the Qashqai, but I need to phone him to find out which one! Not averse to diesel. We only do around 8000 miles per year and mostly short journeys, max we’d do at weekend would be a 150 mile round trip.

CarDad Mon 11-Jun-18 22:53:15

my advice is to avoid diesel unless your doing 20,000 miles a year - the fuel saving of having a diesel will be wiped away by the cost of maintaining a diesel and inevitable repairs not to mention a diesel will lose its value a lot faster.

For £7,500 I would look at a used Toyota Auris, it will be ultra reliable provided it has full service history.
You may also find a 3-4 year old Suzuki X-Cross for that kind of money.

PrimalLass Mon 11-Jun-18 23:27:33

A CRV. They are much more solid.

PrimalLass Mon 11-Jun-18 23:28:09

Our Qashqai just feels flimsy.

SugarMiceInTheRain Mon 11-Jun-18 23:31:19

CRV definitely. A couple of friends have Qashqais and have been disappointed.

Littlebird88 Mon 11-Jun-18 23:34:10

Love love love our crv
Can't fault it at all.

CarDad Tue 12-Jun-18 23:42:07

Honda CRV is excellent but at this price range it will be considerably older than a Qashqai

PrimalLass Wed 13-Jun-18 11:01:31

I would get another Qashqai but not a 1.6 petrol.

DiabolicalMess Wed 13-Jun-18 11:07:46

Love my qashqai it doesnt feel flimsy to me at all and I've had a freelander.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: