Talk

Advanced search

Conservative Party advert promoting bottle feeding

(54 Posts)
mamamea Mon 12-Jan-09 12:23:56

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=_kbaXYPmjU0

Shame we don't live in a country where they could have shown the baby happily feeding NATURALLY without being inundated with complaints, and instead show it sucking on a bit of rubber.

mamamea Mon 12-Jan-09 12:24:37

sorry link uk.youtube.com/watch?v=_kbaXYPmjU0

Aitch Mon 12-Jan-09 12:26:31

you know, i can see why they wouldn't show bfing really (not that i agree) but they might at least have used a bigger child... hmm

Nbg Mon 12-Jan-09 12:27:21

I dont know how DC sleeps at night.

Wonderstuff Mon 12-Jan-09 12:30:38

hmm I agree with you, but I feel others won't.

wenceslasmyeducation Mon 12-Jan-09 12:30:50

Perhaps the point is that bottle-feeding is expensive? wink
No, they just didn't even think about it did they? And that's the problem isn't it, that it's seen as the norm.

Aitch Mon 12-Jan-09 12:42:56

exactly wenceslas. they wouldn't even have thought about it, lol.

Brangelina Mon 12-Jan-09 12:49:24

I don't understand why they couldn't show a baby being bfed. Here in Italy the Pampers ad has a mother bfing on it FFS. Is it a demographic thing perhaps? Are they trying to appeal to the section of society who culturally wouldn't consider bfing?

Aitch Mon 12-Jan-09 12:53:10

you mean people who wouldn't be bfing a child of that age? wink a political party wanting to appeal to the majority... i think they might, brange. grin

Brangelina Mon 12-Jan-09 12:54:58

I noticed the person speaking didn't have a classic "Tory" accent as well, hence my theory. Or is it now all the rage to do political party ads with regional accents?grin

hedgehog1979 Mon 12-Jan-09 12:56:21

That makes me really sad, especially as I am the only one of my NCT antenatal group (of 8) still BF and our LO are only 6 - 8 months.

Hope it might change DH mind about who he votes for though

Brangelina Mon 12-Jan-09 12:57:14

PS. <whispers> I think it might be aimed at Sun readers or suchlike, and the tories didn't want people getting confused about the purpose of breastswink.

madwomanintheattic Mon 12-Jan-09 13:01:45

obviously sales of formula are to be used to top up the economy under a conservative government.
arf.
you bf'ers aren't helping, with your freebie milk y'know.
<hides breast pads>

francagoestohollywood Mon 12-Jan-09 13:04:48

I would have found the ad irritating even if a boob had been put in the baby's mouth grin

madwomanintheattic Mon 12-Jan-09 13:05:30

or maybe the gb greedy formula guzzlers are about to enter the sunlight of change in the conservative, bfing, post-guzzle empire.

cute baby though, ff or not. can i have one?

Nancy66 Mon 12-Jan-09 13:26:17

they're not actually 'promoting' bottle feeding are they? They're just showing a baby drinking from a bottle - as millions do.

Aitch Mon 12-Jan-09 13:31:36

i suppose that it does stealthily reinforce bfing as the norm, which it isn't, biologically-speaking.

fruitstick Mon 12-Jan-09 13:33:10

Ridiculous advert which doesn't even say anything. Why will they be saddled with £17k worth of debt?

Absolutely no reason to show a feeding baby, whether bf or ff.

Just shows a lack of understanding on their part.

ThingOne Mon 12-Jan-09 13:38:36

Don't vote Tory, folks, they'll force feed your baby formula wink.

wotulookinat Mon 12-Jan-09 13:49:43

Very cute baby!
They could hardly shove a boob into the shot could they.
In all honesty though, it's not necessary to show the baby feeding at all.
Maybe the makers should have thought about all the pro-breastfeeders who would be outraged about seeing a bottle-fed baby rather than all the people who wouldn't be impressed at seeing a boob on screen hmm

madwomanintheattic Mon 12-Jan-09 14:00:33

the thought of a big wobbly boob entering from the top right of the screen did make me chuckle for a minute or two...

but totally irrelevant to the topic at hand lol.

PrettyCandles Mon 12-Jan-09 14:11:10

But the message is a negative one - the baby is born saddled with problems, according to the ad. Breastfeeding is a phenomenally positive image - warm, cuddly, protected. Which would have been contradictory to the message.

That said, I'll bet they never even thought about breastfeeding!

Aitch Mon 12-Jan-09 14:12:30

lol, v true...

SwedesInACape Mon 12-Jan-09 14:15:28

How is it promoting formula feeding? The advert mererly shows that bottle feeding exists. shock

francagoestohollywood Mon 12-Jan-09 14:16:41

Madwoman, a bit like that woodie Allen's movie, where is chased by a gigantic breast. Don't think they have that sense of humour though hmm

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now