Talk

Advanced search

cow & gate ad ASA report.

(16 Posts)
noolia Wed 17-Sep-08 11:44:11

I've just had a copy of the report. It's confidential so I shall just say 'grrrrrr' and shout 'you completely missed the point on purpose!'.
angry but not shock

mamadiva Wed 17-Sep-08 11:51:38

ooh am intrigued, is it something bad? I used cow and gate formula for a year. EEK you have mne worried.

noolia Wed 17-Sep-08 12:12:07

No need to worry! Just that some people complained about the advert for their follow on milk.

mamadiva Wed 17-Sep-08 12:15:00

Oh right LOL.

Ah see I shall just back away because I quite liked that advert...

likessleep Wed 17-Sep-08 12:32:15

How can they miss the point?
Have they got off scott free?

AbricotsSecs Wed 17-Sep-08 13:30:11

Message withdrawn

morethanasong Wed 17-Sep-08 13:39:28

Why's it confidential? Is it possible to get hold of a copy of it, or do you have to have complained?

noolia Wed 17-Sep-08 14:24:11

They've sent me a draft of the report, I guess you have to have complained to be sent one.
I think they missed the point in the way that they summarised the complaints. They had 62 complaints and from those drew three main points which were what they investigated. IMO the points they investigated didn't really get to the heart of the matter.
Not surprised though - the companies are very clever/well advised by their lawyers!

morethanasong Wed 17-Sep-08 14:30:08

I wonder if it's too late to complain? I must admit that whilst the advert annoyed me so much that I wanted to complain, I wasn't sure exactly which laws/guidelines it was breaking.

CuppaTeaJanice Wed 17-Sep-08 14:32:02

At least they didn't refer to a baby as 'it' like the Heinz milk ad.

thebecster Wed 17-Sep-08 14:33:33

I complained too, so also received it. angry angry angry

Completely missed the point on purpose about sums it up.

StealthPolarBear Wed 17-Sep-08 16:05:44

It can't be confidential - they are sending it out! You;re not employed by them (presumably) so I can't see you have any duty of confidentiality to them.
Post it!

GillianLovesMarmite Wed 17-Sep-08 16:12:19

I complained about the Heinz nurture ad and am waiting for the ASA recommendations...

GillianLovesMarmite Wed 17-Sep-08 16:14:13

I get cross as I don't feel they make it explicit enough that you aren't supposed to stop bfeeding at 6 months and switch to follow on - although they appear to think that putting this in the worlds smallest writing for 3 seconds on the bottom of the screen will get them out of this...
Is the cow and gate one the one about 'do I look like I need vitamins', 'does my tummy look upset' in writing above the children?

StealthPolarBear Wed 17-Sep-08 16:16:02

yes thats the one

GillianLovesMarmite Wed 17-Sep-08 16:26:22

I do find it annoying - although I can see the point of people who use forumla that depending on how it was handled it could be seen as 'another' reminder that they aren't breastfeeding - I started a discussion on this whole shebang when I complained to the ASA and it was really interesting to get a range of opinions (you can probably find it by looking up my post history or something as I couldn't find it in my threads I started to link to here...).

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now