Talk

Advanced search

EBM - same benefits re breast cancer or not?

(18 Posts)
RUMPEL Tue 05-Aug-08 15:03:20

Hi I just wondered if anyone knew if the health benefits - reduction of risk of breast cancer - was the same if you were expressing rather than actually bfeeding bubba?

kiskidee Tue 05-Aug-08 15:05:28

yes. it is the fact that you are lactating, not how the milk gets removed that is important.

callmeovercautious Tue 05-Aug-08 15:06:07

I remember the HV that did our BFing class saying it only applied to exclusive BFing not expressing or mixed feeding but I could not understand why. She could not explain the whys either, she just said she knew it was the case.

I will be interested to hear any other responses.

serant Tue 05-Aug-08 15:10:39

My thoughts would be that it has a connection with the release of hormones? Also a psychological health link?

I'm sure someone will be along soon to explain this properly...

kiskidee Tue 05-Aug-08 15:11:27

I think the HV is talking bollocks. The way I have been led to believe, the cancer risk keeps reducing for the longer you breastfeed. I think the studies stopped at bfing at the 2 yr mark. So women who have bf for 2 yrs have lower risk than someone who maybe bf for 6 months. I am sure those women were not bfing exclusively at 2 yrs.

TT maybe along to provide better info.

RUMPEL Tue 05-Aug-08 15:37:01

ta ladies bumpity bump

Pruners Tue 05-Aug-08 15:42:39

Message withdrawn

wontbepreggersagain Tue 05-Aug-08 15:47:24

it is only a REDUCTION in risk though, and apparently is is a very small reduction apparently! i've been continuously breastfeeding for five years and was diagnosed in March!!

Pruners Tue 05-Aug-08 17:57:18

Message withdrawn

Pruners Tue 05-Aug-08 17:57:19

Message withdrawn

RUMPEL Tue 05-Aug-08 20:01:34

Wontbepreggersagain - sorry to hear that and wishing you a speedy recovery.

Ta Pruners - but doesn't really explain if expressing has the same outcome.

Pruners Tue 05-Aug-08 20:42:55

Message withdrawn

RUMPEL Tue 05-Aug-08 20:56:04

I thought if you were on the pill it stopped you ovulating so surely there woud be the same benefits being on the pill? Or even being pregnant at all?

RUMPEL Tue 05-Aug-08 21:17:33

bump

Pruners Tue 05-Aug-08 21:21:35

Message withdrawn

RUMPEL Wed 06-Aug-08 14:41:50

anyone else?

mears Wed 06-Aug-08 14:48:32

this is interesting

It is the production of milk itself rather than how the baby gets it which is important.

Not all women who breastfeed stop ovulating. The link talks about the reduced risk of ovarian cancer when ovulation has been stopped due to feeding.

jem777 Fri 17-Jul-09 15:52:06

I guess try some alternatives, the more natural way.
appendectomy

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now