Talk

Advanced search

does all formula smell horrid? SMA does :-(

(15 Posts)
meladeso Tue 30-Aug-16 20:06:03

Hi

I used SMA with my first DC, and am now starting to use it for my second. I'd forgotten how horrible it smells, and wondered whether they're all like that? Or are any any better?

I recall visiting a friend overseas when we were both using formula, and hers smelt quite nice and a bit vanilla-y. Much more appetising!

Feel a bit mean (daft I know) feeding her something that makes me pull a face.

Nottalotta Fri 02-Sep-16 19:10:02

I think they are all pretty foul smelling.

Hughpughbarneymagrew Fri 02-Sep-16 19:20:07

DS has hypoallergenic formula. Now that is rank. Smells like horlicks mixed with tuna.

paddypants13 Fri 02-Sep-16 19:29:16

I've used Cow and Gate and Aptamil and never noticed a bad smell.

Then again my sense of smell is not great so maybe it's just me.

meladeso Fri 23-Sep-16 09:34:02

thanks guys, might try and sniff someone's C&G and Aptamil .... ha!!!

TriJo Fri 23-Sep-16 14:06:36

Aptamil smells terrible IMHO.

user1471461436 Fri 23-Sep-16 14:11:38

I think hipp smells better but not actually "pleasant". I like the smell of all formula tbh its the smell of leftovers in a cold bottle

DubiousCredentials Fri 23-Sep-16 14:27:01

All the ones I ever used smelt rank. So much so that I was continually surprised how much babies seemed to love it confused

LuckySantangelo1 Fri 23-Sep-16 14:34:48

The nicest one is hipp organic. Yes I tried them all!

CalpolOnToast Fri 23-Sep-16 14:36:09

I found SMA caused awful smelling poo, C&G and Aptamil were OK

OvariesForgotHerPassword Fri 23-Sep-16 14:37:31

Cow and Gate was fine for us, SMA was rank.

divafever99 Fri 23-Sep-16 14:37:31

Only used cow and gate and I think that smells of white chocolate buttons!

DownWithThisSortaThing Fri 23-Sep-16 14:38:14

Yes they all smell revolting IMO. At best like sour milk, but they don't taste off they taste sweet (I've tried them blush)

OvariesForgotHerPassword Fri 23-Sep-16 14:38:25

Was the overseas friend from the US? Many of their formulas come in vanilla variations once you get past 6 months.

meladeso Fri 23-Sep-16 23:47:44

Ok will check out hipp too, thanks

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now