Advanced search

Using nipple for comfort...advice please

(13 Posts)
crazybutterflylady Wed 10-Aug-11 19:39:59

My 11WO DD is EBF and after a tricky start it all seems to be going well...until a week or so ago when, between the last 2 feeds of the day, she has started screaming constantly and the only thing that comforts her is sucking my boob. She's not really feeding from it, just sucking.

I should say she has just started cutting her first tooth -not sure if this is related. I have tried a dummy since about 4 weeks with varying success. Some days she loves it, others she spits it out continuously and just isn't interested.

In general I'm ok about her using me for comfort but concerned a) that it means I am tied in the evenings so couldn't go out/leave her and b) not sure how I would wean her out of this habit when trying to wean her onto solids/bottle.

Advice/experience appreciated!


nethunsreject Wed 10-Aug-11 19:45:45

Normal behavior, yup.

As she gets older, there will be other ways to comfort her, so try not to get too worried about 'rod for your own back' stuff.

Also, she may be reaching a growth spurt, so this might stop again.

Wrt evenings, I'd cross that bridge when it comes. First, you won't be there so she won't look for the boob. Also, they grow up so very fast, there will be other means of your dp/granny/whoever providing comfort.

Well done overcoming the tricky start. smile

MoonFaceMamaaaaargh Wed 10-Aug-11 20:06:44

what nethuns said.

They need comfort...but ways of providing this change with time and depending on who is available to provide it. Don't worry about habits etc...trying not to make them seems to result in a whole set of other ones sometimes.

barelyutterly Wed 10-Aug-11 20:17:52

Have you tried using a finger to soothe her? Mine won't take a dummy and hasn't learned to suck her own thumb or finger yet, but when she's fussing the way you describe and wants to suck on my nipple for comfort rather than milk, I often substitute my little finger to settle her. Saves my nipples and also DH can take a turn.

crazybutterflylady Wed 10-Aug-11 21:12:26

That's all really helpful, thanks. I have been using a little finger to rub her gum a bit to help her tooth come through but not as a soothed, so I'll try that ging forward. She screamed so hard tonight that she threw up everywhere bless her, that made my mind up to just give her the boob when she wants it!

Wrt other people being about to comfort her, I do worry about her becoming too clingy since she won't settle with DH at all - but this could be because he is only around when she's awake for about an hour a day during the week. I think I should stop worrying so much and just go with the flow!

kickassmunkiii Wed 10-Aug-11 21:16:50

I would suggest a dummy, I know not everybody likes them but our HV suggested this for us when my DD was using me as a dummy 24/7!

You can buy 'cherry' dummies which are more like nipples.


kickassmunkiii Wed 10-Aug-11 21:18:23

Sorry- just realised you had tired that blush

Have you tried the various teether/comforter combos? Tommee Tippee do a good one. Other than that perhaps a moist flannel or muslin may help?

crazybutterflylady Wed 10-Aug-11 21:18:48

She's not keen on a dummy, certainly not enough that I can rely on them when she is screaming

crazybutterflylady Wed 10-Aug-11 21:21:15

Sorry - cross posts.
I bought the horseshoe shaped TT teethers today but I couldn't fit it in her mouth! When she is in a state, she doesn't seem to close her mouth around anything but my nipple, must be a smell thing.

kickassmunkiii Wed 10-Aug-11 21:25:24

Oh bless her, my DD has a tiny mouth as well and until 7 months old we had to use the dummy a lot as she tried to get everything in her mouth but nothing fit and she would howl.

I am afraid I have no more ideas, but I really hope you find a solution. Do you have a good HV? Or mother and baby group? It is very hard isn't it.

My DD has a milk allergy and severe reflux so comfort sucks a lot.

kickassmunkiii Wed 10-Aug-11 21:26:32

I wonder though about putting a muslin or soother down your top? I did this with her blanket and the smell transfer helped.

Clutching at straws I know.... but you never know do you grin

FrozenNorthPole Wed 10-Aug-11 21:31:20

Great job in getting through a tough start smile
I've been there and done that twice. I'd just go with the nipple, honestly. As long as it's not hurting or exhausting you, my focus would be letting her get on with it whilst you get on with other things e.g. perfect hands-free feeding to mumsnet, eat, read a good book ... I look back on those early snuggly baby days with so much pleasure, even though they were tiring, and I definitely wouldn't say that I made a rod for my own back. I loved the fact that DD2 could hear me breathe, smell me, have milk when she wanted, reach out and touch me in her sleep ... no dummy's going to meet all those needs.
As an aside, I do feel it also helped boost my supply up easily when growth spurts came - which made for less crying and more sleep for us both.

crazybutterflylady Wed 10-Aug-11 21:40:43

Yeah Frozen I think you are right. I am planning to feed for 6 months then introduce formula so it's not the end of the world; I should enjoy it while I can. And I am mega lucky in that she sleeps from 9pm-6am, so her being stuck on me for a couple of hours/not bring able to go out for a few months is preferable to sleepless nights! smile

Thanks for all your responses and advice, really appreciated.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: