My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Infant feeding

Looking for more balanced info about the impact of breastfeeding?

51 replies

foodiemountainbiker · 12/04/2011 21:16

I am very positive about BFing and BF DD1 for 13 months and (so far) have been BFing DD2 for 18 months.

I am getting joint pains in my hands and, having been to the doctor today, it appears that I am getting the pain because I am still BFing (similar to carpel tunnel that I got when pregnant). The doctor was obviously very reluctant to say that to me (I guess, because she wants to be seen to promote BFing). A few months ago there was another issue (pain in my episiotomy scar) that also turned out to be due to me still BFing.

I am really annoyed that it is almost impossible to find out anything about any negative impacts of BFing. What I would really like is balanced information about the whole subject. I feel as though the BF counsellors, NCT, LLL etc. are trying to brainwash us into thinking it is all positive.

Is anyone aware of any more balanced information about the whole subject?

OP posts:
Report
serant · 12/04/2011 21:19

? are you a troll

Report
weasle · 12/04/2011 21:29

well, it is true that your hormonal status when bf or pg is different to that when not bf or pg. So conditions that are exacerbated by that hormonal state will be worse. i suppose joint laxity springs to mind, will have a think/look for others. i don't think it is a long list.

on the other hand, the things that are less frequent, such as breast cancer are more studied. And it physiologically/anthropologically being pg and/or bf for most of our adult lives is normal, rather than now when it is the other way round in our society. (and i mean the natural term bf, hunter-gatherer, baby every 4 years model, not the baby every year Victorian type model).

I'm sorry you are having health problems, but bf organisations are there to promote bf as normal and help with problems, they are not brainwashing! try kellymom that may have something?

Report
foodiemountainbiker · 12/04/2011 21:36

weasle - Thank you. I'll have a look.

serant - Shock No I'm not

OP posts:
Report
japhrimel · 12/04/2011 21:37

Part of this issue will definitely be that only a low percentage of mothers in the UK breastfeed as long as you have managed!

Having said that, I've done a lot of work related to chronic pain issues and GPs frequently mis-diagnose all kinds of ongoing pain. So just because a GP has reluctantly said it's due to bfing, doesn't mean it's necessarily true.

Report
MoonFaceMamaaaaargh · 13/04/2011 09:03

I would imagine that such things are rarely discussed because they rarely occur.

Report
RitaMorgan · 13/04/2011 09:07

How did bfing effect your episiotomy scar?

Report
otchayaniye · 13/04/2011 09:12

Could she explain why it is related to breastfeeding? I'd imagine at 18 months the hormonal effect is becoming muted.

You could try maybe easing off the demand feeding if that's what you're doing? I did this to bring on a period after 2 years' demand feeding.

I'm 6 months pregnant and feeding a 2-1/2 year old and yes, my hormones are different but I cannot imagine how that would seriously impact pain. I'd love to hear an evidence-based explanation.

Report
silkenladder · 13/04/2011 16:25

Magnesium deficiency can cause leg cramps, iron deficiency cracks at the corners of the mouth. I could imagine that other deficiencies could cause other minor ailments. Long-term bfing on a not-always-optimal diet could presumably result in mineral or vitamin deficiency, since the body prioritises bm quality over the mother's needs. Just my thoughts, of course.

If bf really was linked with higher rates of any disease, however rare, someone on here would have found out about it by now and would bring it up at every bunfight Smile.

Report
MigGril · 13/04/2011 16:35

silkenladder has a good point there, you milk will be produced at the expense of your health. Even near staving women can sucesfully BF but it probably does effect the mum. Why not try adding a vitamine/minarule suppliment into your diet to see if that helps.

Note I'm no expert in nutrian just an idea.

Report
peanutdream · 13/04/2011 19:38

www.arthritis-treatment-and-relief.com/foods-or-vitamins-that-help-with-joint-pain.html some of the foods in this article sound delicious!

i reckon silkenladder is on the right track here too. i bf ds for 15months and felt pretty exhausted by the end. the milk does contain vits and mins so it makes sense that it would take your supplies to do this. i have heard that during lactation metabolism is more efficient - the lactating woman gets more vits out of foods or something like that (sorry no links) but still, it stands to reason that you may be lacking in some vitamins.

no expert either and agree something about how it drains the mother would be helpful - in terms of how to replenish your stores etc

Report
tiktok · 13/04/2011 20:01

I think I can be 100 per cent confident that pain in the episiotomy scar is unrelated to breastfeeding. Ditto carpal tunnel - though I do know that it can take a little while after childbirth for this to go, and there is a hormonal influence.

Hormone levels after 18 months of breastfeeding are virtually back to pre-prgnancy levels - prolactin is only raised by the most miniscule amounts, and breastfeeding is sustained almost 100 per cent by the autorcrine system not the endocrine (hormonal) system. Perhaps enlighten your doc on this point?

You can't find evidence of the negative effects on mother's health of breastfeeding not because of brainwashing - but because there is no evidence!

I might as well have a rant and say how annoying it is there is no 'balanced information' that wearing a yellow hat on Sundays causes cross eyes, and that opticians should be telling us the truth!

:)

Report
MoonFaceMamaaaaargh · 13/04/2011 20:02

now recall that in PoBF she mentions that a particutlar is leached during bf but that the body goes into overdrive afterwards to replace it and that this is why bf is associated with lowered risk of osteoperosis (sp)

Am sure silkenladder is right. If anything was known we'd hear no end of it. It's bad enough with the way stuff is misreported in the media. Imagine what the mail could make of something that was actually based in fact!

Report
tiktok · 13/04/2011 20:02

'autorcrine' should be 'autocrine' for people who want to look it up :)

Report
MamaChocoholic · 13/04/2011 20:12

I am hypermobile. I had SPD in pregnancy that didn't resolve postnatally. two bf counsellors have told me it's unrelated to bf, several physios and a lactation consultant have told me it is. who should I believe?

the pain is manageable, it doesn't affect my decision to bf, but if it is affected by bf, then at least I could look forward to it clearing up eventually. tiktok, do you know?

Report
tiktok · 13/04/2011 20:16

MamaChoc - I don;t know . I know there is not a consensus about it - SPD is a bugger and there are conflicting studies about its relationship to bf.

Report
immortalbeloved · 13/04/2011 20:28

Mamachoc, I have the same problem, I have severe pelvic girdle pain (to the extent that I use a wheelchair) and I have been told that bf does prolong the problem due to hormones (though to a lesser extent than pregnancy) I have been told this by several hcp's ans in fact my orthoprdic consultant won't see/test/treat anyone one until at least 6 wks after they have finished breastfeeding

How true this is I don't know, but on a purely anacdotal level, I have had SPD four times (not counting now) and each time it began to get better only after I had finished bf

Report
MamaChocoholic · 13/04/2011 20:29

thanks tiktok. an honest don't know is actually strangely comforting. if it might be related, then it might clear up as the babies switch to more solids/less bf with time :)

Report
immortalbeloved · 13/04/2011 20:30

Oh my goodness please excuse my awful spelling and typing in that post, combination of typing while bf and heavy duty painkillers Blush

Report
MamaChocoholic · 13/04/2011 20:55

thanks immortal. sorry yours is so bad you're using a wheelchair, but glad to hear it can get better. did yours ever completely resolve between bouts?

Report
Petsville · 14/04/2011 10:45

Watching this thread with interest as I had SPD while pregnant. Thankfully mine wasn't terribly bad - I wasn't on crutches or in a wheelchair - but DS is now 8 months old and it hasn't completely resolved. I am really hoping it goes when I stop BFing.

Report
AngelDog · 14/04/2011 12:36

Mama, I have hypermobility and have also had De Quervain's Syndrome (inflammation of tendons going through the thumb). My hand therapist (physio) told me that it would be worse because of the hormones associated with bf (DS was 6 months at the time). That was certainly my experience with pregnancy.

I have found that it has improved a lot since then, though - DS is 15 m.o. and still bfs at least 4 x a day. Co-sleeping actually makes it worse than bf IMO, as I tend to sleep in the same position all night.

Report
tiktok · 14/04/2011 12:41

Hmmmm....this is far from being my specialist subject, but hormones play such a small part in established breastfeeding, but it is certainly possible physios and so on are not aware of this.

It would explain why hormonally-related things like SPD do eventually get better, the longer bf continues.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

AngelDog · 14/04/2011 12:49

That's interesting, tiktok - but as you say, a pretty low proportion of women bf for a longer period, so some physios might be applying the hormonal effects that you see in the early stages of bf to all women who bf for longer.

Actually, my wrist problems have been worse with bf - because I have rubbish posture and I tend to slump my shoulders while feeding which causes tension. But it's a posture issue, not a bf issue.

Report
japhrimel · 14/04/2011 13:24

I was told relaxin levels would be raised for a year postnatally whether or not you bf.

I have hypermobility syndrome & do find that feeding positions put a lot of strain on me, as does holding DD. I can't use a sling for walks without SPD & SI pain.

Report
iskra · 14/04/2011 13:29

Is the pain in your episiotomy scar during sex? I have heard that bfing can increase vaginal dryness - think it's the oestrogen.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.