Please don't promote book giveaways here. If you'd like to discuss book giveaways on Mumsnet, firstname.lastname@example.org
My Beautiful England by Michelle Flatley - apply for free copy and post your feedback - CLOSED(45 Posts)
This week we have 50 copies of Michelle Flatley's debut novel, My Beautiful England to give away.
In a deprived town in Lancashire three women from very different backgrounds are thrown together at a local language school, united by their search for a new identity and desire to interact with others. My Beautiful England highlights the human stories behind the bigger picture of immigration in the UK and is a beautifully written and thought provoking debut. If you would like to read and review, apply for one of fifty free copies.
Really enjoyed this Mumsnet, thanks. Think it is really thought provoking and challenges preconceived ideas about immigration.
I was really excited to receive a copy of ths book, but my excitement seeped away as I read the story. Having volunteered in an ESOL group I was hoping for a real-life style story. Unfortunately the Eastenders-style story lines were too dramatic to be believable.
I really enjoyed reading this book. Thank you for sending it to me. I found the 3 main characters all very interesting and I was glad that Lenka's story in particular turned out so well. I did feel that the first 2/3's of the book was really good but that then the author decided that she needed to tidy things up and finish it all off which she did neatly and tidly. I personally would have preferred a few more loose ends with more left up to the reader. I thought the characterisation was the strong point of the book we understood the motivations behind the characters actions particularly in cases such as Suriya.
I really enjoyed reading this book. It is an easy read and a gently approached topic of integration for those who are unfamiliar with it. I would have liked to learn more about Lenka in comparison to Su and the other characters. I would also have liked to have had maybe an African or latin american character, as there were two asian characters, and the ones at the centre all were asian.
The author kept the sentences quite short and superficial for me, but I understand that this may occur for people with english as a new language, but even later in the book the language did not really develop.
I think that if english is not your first language, or you do not have that much time to spare and do not want something too taxing, then this book is perfect. It is also good if you have haranging little ones who need your attention all of the time, as the chapters are quite short, and you can pick it up and start again at any point.
Thank you Michelle Flately.
I felt so sorry for Sammy and had it a feeling things wouldn't end well for her. Her story really did feel horribly true to life, maybe not so much her romance but the other aspects. Su, I liked but agree with the sex scene, not because it was awful, just didn't seem to fit with the rest of it, I expected her to end up with David and sad it didn't work out like that for her but happy she had a child. Lenka, I just liked. Enjoyable book and read it like one of the others in two goes - think that's a good recommendation!
I read the book over the course of a week and a half: it was very easy reading and flowed well. I also preferred the parts set in Burnley and thought they were realistically written.
The characterisations were good, particularly Su's voice. However, I really hated the bit where she had sex with David - it really didn't fit with her character at all. And after that scene it seemed as if I was just waiting for the announcement of her pregnancy, it was so predictable.
Also, I noticed early in the novel that some of the punctuation, particularly commas, seemed to be in the wrong place. Things like that tend to jar with me.
On the whole, I enjoyed the sense of relationship between the three women. It was very well done and better than the 'plot' itself. Like some of the other reviewers have mentioned, I think the last chapters appeared somewhat rushed (also, Lenka ending up with David made me cringe a little!)
Overall, I would agree that it's a good first novel and look out for further work from Michelle Flatley.
I was lucky enough to receive a copy of this book and I immediatly passed it onto my mum who used to work in an ESOL centre. She read it in a day! She found it believable and touching. She thoroughly recommends it. I will be reading it next.
Thank you for sending me this book. I loved every page, and lost myself in the three main characters. My heart stopped when Suriya, tried to get the phone from Sammy. I cried when they went to Rob's house. I held my breath when there was loud knocking in the middle of the night at Lenka's house. And had a lump in my throat when Chelsea came back from her holiday. Michelle Flatley, what a wonderful book, I did not want it to end......mumsnet thank you for sending me a fantastic read
Started reading this morning and have just finished.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, I liked the way the sentences were written as if they were being spoken by someone who spoke little English.
It was very thought provoking and nice to see certain characters portrayed in a different light (Suriya not just A mean old lady)
I too felt the ending was a bit rushed and I didn't even consider that the su's baby was David's until I read a post upthread.
Overall a well written story that drew me in. I would like to read more from Michelle Flatley.
I too really enjoyed this book and am glad to have read it as it's not really the kind of book I would ordinarily have chosen.
I really admired Su and Lenka for their positivity and determination to improve their lives and make the most of their situations even though the reality of living in England was falling short of their expectations. Perhaps the bad hand life had dealt them so far meant they took a more realistic view that it was up to them to take control of their futures and not become passive bystanders in their own lives. I think this was particularly true of Su who was determined to make a place for herself in an environment so different to what she had previously known.
Sammy, though, was altogether more passive and looked to others (first Ehsan, then Rob, then Ehsan again) to lead her through life. At first I wondered if this was due to her younger age and relative lack of life experience but after a while it became clear that it was because this was what was expected of her within her culture and family. Her lack of freedom and the right to have a say in her own life (even down to her clothes) was very sad and I was glad to see her beginning to address some of these things with Ehsan. However, I have to say that I think it was an almost unbelievable leap for her to begin a relationsip with Rob, given her 'meekness' in other areas of her life. Whilst obviously this was a necessary plot to highlight to Sammy the shortfalls of her marriage and circumstances, I thought hers was the most unsatisfactory storyline. This is particularly true of Sammy's 'ending' which in some respects I think was a bit of a convenient closure. Although in the section at the end of the book about why she wrote it, Flatley stated that the 2003 murder of Shafilea Ahmed had influenced her, I think I would have preferred a less dramatic storyline for Sammy - one where we could have seen her life five years down the line.
Sorry if that last bit sounds too critical; it's really just my opinion which may be vastly different to others. As I said earlier, I really enjoyed this book. I thought it was very confidently written and, like a previous poster, I was surprised to read this is her first novel. It was extremely well-researched and I thought very authentic. It seemed to me that Flatley captured some of the native characteristics of the three different women very well and gave each their own distinctive voice. The book also showed how language and cultural differences could be overcome by the more universal traits of empathy, kindness and friendliness. I'll definitely keep an eye out for any future books by her.
Enjoyed this book, the characters seemed real & the subject had obviously been well thought out. I read it over several evenings but looked forward to it, i will look out for more from this author.
Fantastic!!! Really enjoyed the reading. The story is close to these days life, some parts, about Robs murder, felt like news on TV. Interesting how three different backgrounds, despite all differences in culture, religion have so much in common. England to the women meant - FREEDOM. Unbelievably strong friendship. I will pass this book for all my friends especially, foreign ones.
I really enjoyed this book. I'm a Lancastrian myself and although not from Burnley I have visited and had a very vivid mental picture of the setting. I also am married to a non EU immigrant and have had dealings with both the immigration system and the bi- cultural marriage aspect of the story (SU)(albeit from the british side.) There was a lot of truth to this book.
My only reservation about it was as a Muslim I'm constantly seeing negative stuff about muslims in the press and I did for a fleeting moment feel 'oh no, not another story of terrible muslim men' ..however I stuck with it and I know these things do go on in some families(as do the domestic violence issues faced by Lenka). In the end I found it to be much more nuanced than that and ultimately I was happy to have read it.
I finished this book last night - I loved it. Right from the start I was drawn right in. I've been to Patong and stayed in one of the beachside hotels, I was in Malaysia when the Tsunami hit and this book so many memories back of that time. I was eager to find out how Su, Lenka and Sammy would adapt to life in England. I was hooked, and wasn't expecting Sammy's storyline to end the way it did.
A great read, I'll be passing my copy on to friends to enjoy too.
I just got home about an hour ago from my holiday and thought I would post my review.
First the appearance of the book, I had a lot of paperbacks with me, and I loved the cover and thought the quality of the paper it was printed on appeared to be vastly superior to the others that I had with me.
When I started this book I was worried that it wasn't my type of book. I absolutely loved it, It was well written and easy to read , very hard to put down.
The second part of the book based in Burnley was my favourite part. The relationship between the three women seemed very believable. I don't think we necessarily realise how isolated some women can be and the deaths of Robb and Sammy were sad but seemed somehow inevitable.
I assumed the sex scene between David and Su was important as I thought Su's child was David's not Bobby's.
I really enjoyed this book and would be happy to read more of her work
I've finished it now, I enjoyed the second half more, the Burnley bits rather than the Thailand setting. But it was a bit depressing. I would have liked it if the men who killed Rob got arrested for it. It feels a bit as though too many abusive men got away with their violence - Kamil and the 3 who killed Rob. And the women just had to put up with it - even if they'd moved away, like Lenka, they still had the scars. And the men just got to feel a bit remorseful.
Initially, I wasn't sure if I'd like this book or not but I really did. I found it really interesting to see England through Su's eyes - I had a good look round and I suppose the UK can look grey and dreary compared to Thailand. I loved that the 3 women were able to overcome a language barrier to communicate and become so close. It didn't completely grip me although but it was a nice read.
I thoroughly enjoyed the book and was genuinely sad when I finished it. From the beginning I was totally hooked by the storyline and loved how the author intertwined the characters in so many ways. It was cleverly written, very thought provoking and a fantastic debut for the author . I actually miss reading about the lives of the 3 women and look forward to reading more from Michelle Flatley.
I'm halfway through. I really liked the idea behind it - having worked in language schools and lived in the NW I was interested. So far I'm not finding it totally gripping, I felt a bit depressed by the tsunami stuff. Now I'm in the bit where the Thai wife isn't very happy, and the other women are unhappy too - I suppose it will get less depressing eventually.
Just started my copy thank you - will post when finished.
I'm about half way in to this book, I am loving it, have purposely not read any of the threads above mine - will come back for a read once I've finished the book
I liked the book, but didn't really like the style of writing. No sentence was more than about 6 words maximum, so I found it a bit staccato, maybe that was intentional as that is how English comes across when spoken by Thai, Philipina people ( generalising of course).
Thank you for the book
Thoroughly enjoyed reading this book - it was a quick and easy read, while also being interesting, thought-provoking and moving. I look forward to more from Michelle Flatley.
Finally finished it. I had a little tear in my eye at the end
I also had a feeling about Sammy that it wouldn't end well for her. I was glad that Su and Lenka had better outcomes.
Really enjoyed reading this book though.
I found it very moving. I had a bad feeling about Sammy early on
I thought the characters were very real with good & bad in them. It would have been do easy for characters like Suriya fir example to be made out to be evil stepmother type cliches. The insight into her thoughts showed she did care, it's just her whole belief set is totally different.
Agree with the sex scene, very odd. And Su didn't act like a 40 odd year old
I felt the ending was a bit rushed.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.