Advanced search

19 month old otherwise lovely ds keeps hitting us!

(7 Posts)
Fisharefriendsnotfood Fri 12-Aug-11 15:19:38

only started a couple of weeks ago. Dd is 3 and he is pushing and hitting her a lot! I'm beginning to get concerned. He has also hitting me on occasion.

Right fro. The start I told him 'No', progressed to time out etc but hasn't had any impact. In fact today I said 'No' when he hit dd and he laughed and said 'out' and put himself in time out!

Clearly my strategy isn't working. Can anyone help?

Fisharefriendsnotfood Fri 12-Aug-11 15:36:03


Fisharefriendsnotfood Fri 12-Aug-11 20:26:28

Pm bump

MoonFaceMamaaaaargh Fri 12-Aug-11 22:28:53

hi fish smile

Ds is 18m and experimenting with hitting and biting atm. I think he's exploring the sensations. I just explain and sign that it hurts. Then ask him to be gentle, at which point he strokes me as this is his understanding of gentle. He's too young to control the impulse so i offer him acceptable alternatives eg a high five or xylaphone for hitting, Food to bite. A lot of what he does is hitting or biting inanimate objects anyway, so i mostly leave him to that...picking battles and all that.

I don't use time out or firm no's. He wouldn't undertand the former, and the latter would stop him from hearing the explinationy bit after, and to me that's the important bit. There's no malice in it in ds's case so i'm trying not to be reactionary or antagonistic in my response and so far it's working find for us.

AngelDog Fri 12-Aug-11 22:59:34

I say, 'Hitting hurts. Touch gently, please,' then get his hand and use it to stroke whatever he was trying to hit. Now if I say 'ow', he'll straight away pat & stroke me instead.

Offering an alternative has also worked for biting - I used to give him a spoon to bite on and say 'Biting hurts. You can bite the spoon though.' He's 19 m.o. now.

haplessnavigator Fri 12-Aug-11 23:17:58

Hi Fish.

It is distressing for us mums. But a 19 month old is not yet truly social and will not develop empathy for a couple of years. He will have a limited understanding of the impact but can comprehend an immediate consequence.

You are right, the best response is to say "No" firmly and remove yourself and sibling from them. (I appreciate that there will be some situations, like a bus, where this is impossible. In which case improvise - turn away etc). Do this consistently and firmly. Don't smile or respond in anyway that a little one could perceive as entertaining.

Children of all ages will sometimes start a negative behaviour to initiate an interaction that they perceive as play. You need to show them that they don't get any interaction when they bite/scratch/spit etc. Be consistent, bear with it and it will go away.

I am always repeating the rules of the house: Kind words, kind hands and kind feet. Angeldog's point about teaching kind hands (stroking) is a good one to use.

If he takes himself to time out it does suggest that he knows what is coming next which is good - he understands consequences. I'd ignore the smiles - don't read anything into them. I don't personally use time out until 3 yrs ++ as it has limited impact.

A note of caution - if you implement any of this, it will probably get a bit worse initially. The little monkeys usually up their game to see what will happen. If you persist it should stop.

The other thing of course is your DD's feelings. She needs to see and hear that something is being done. You may need to explain to her that you are responding to her being badly treating by doing X. It may not be that obvious to her as she is so young. She will also benefit from hearing the house rules, and it'll reassure her that this isn't to be tolerated.

Good luck.

Fisharefriendsnotfood Tue 16-Aug-11 14:34:46

Thanks everyone. Saying gentle and stroking really seems to be working. Thanks so much for taking the time to post smile

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: