Talk

Advanced search

Silas, Fletcher or Joseph? help!

(35 Posts)
stoofadoof Tue 29-Sep-09 09:32:57

short list down to these three... for the longest time any DS was going to be Silas, but just not sure if it would be seen as a bit poncey.... middle name Brady for family reasons, and a loooong surname!

what do you think? any other suggestions to throw in?

wuglet Tue 29-Sep-09 09:34:41

Like Joseph best out of those.

None of them are appalling, prefer Silas to Fletcher.

ScummyMummy Tue 29-Sep-09 09:36:19

I like Silas but prefer Joseph. Not keen on Fletcher.

choccyp1g Tue 29-Sep-09 09:37:21

Fletcher Brady is lovely. [adds Fletcher to collection of surnames which are actually jobs, but have a feeling that fletching was not a fun thing..]

Just checked.. it's nice, a fletcher was a maker of arrows.
Could suggest Archer, though that is going to be V.V. popular due to Robin Hood's brother.

stepfordwife Tue 29-Sep-09 09:38:25

joseph

bellissima Tue 29-Sep-09 09:43:06

Silas or Joseph.

Fletcher only if preceded by Norman Stanley

bellissima Tue 29-Sep-09 09:44:24

PS Silas a little bit Cold Comfort Farm mayhap (well yes I know it's actually Silas Marner, but tis a bit ooh arh Silas, Seth etc.)

mopsyflopsy Tue 29-Sep-09 09:51:18

I prefer Silas.

lilysam Tue 29-Sep-09 09:51:45

Joseph

Bucharest Tue 29-Sep-09 09:52:21

Joseph.

MaryBS Tue 29-Sep-09 09:53:10

Joseph. Not keen on Silas, even less so on Fletcher.

seeker Tue 29-Sep-09 09:57:02

Joseph. Or Patrick. best boys name ever, is Patrick!

diddl Tue 29-Sep-09 10:16:57

Silas.

liliputlady Tue 29-Sep-09 10:34:10

Joseph

nappyaddict Tue 29-Sep-09 10:50:06

I like Silas. Not keen on the other too.

cyteen Tue 29-Sep-09 10:53:32

Joseph. Silas sounds too much like 'silage' to my ears, and Fletcher does need Norman Stanley on the front.

GrendelsMum Tue 29-Sep-09 11:56:37

My preference is Silas, Joseph, Fletcher, but they're all nice names. I'm biased by just having listened to Silas Marner on the radio, though.

jemart Tue 29-Sep-09 12:01:00

Joseph is my fave of the three.

VanillaIce Tue 29-Sep-09 12:03:07

Don't call your baby Silas - he was the crazy monk in The Da Vinci Code. Fletcher is a good surname, but not a real first name. And he would get Fletch the Letch - my friend's surname is Fletcher and he gets that all the time so even worse if it was your first name, surely?

Joseph is a real name - classic and lovely.

LadyMetroland Tue 29-Sep-09 12:24:32

Joseph is best

Silas sounds like silage, Fletcher will be Fletch/Retch/Letch his whole life

LadyMetroland Tue 29-Sep-09 12:25:31

As for other suggestions - what type of name are you looking for? The three you've suggested seem very varied

hellokitty123 Tue 29-Sep-09 12:32:33

I like Silas a lot!

I don't really like Fletcher, don't know why. And I find Joe/Joseph a little dull/boring.

lilmissmummy Tue 29-Sep-09 12:35:50

Love Joseph, Fletcher is okay and Silas hmm mainly because it reminds me of Sylar (the baddy in heroes)

stoofadoof Wed 30-Sep-09 09:36:38

thanks everyone!

Fletcher isn't uncommon where we're from due to links with Fletcher Christian (Mutiny on the Bounty) bit of a local hero, though i was concerned about the Norman Stanley thing, and the letch thing, so that's confirmed that!

Silas i love, but don't like the shortening Si and can't imagine any other... and Joseph, well, we'll see!

There are lots of boys names we love, but it seems so much harder to choose for a boy than a girl! Plus, though we both have Scots heritage (grandparents) and love lots of Scots names, it feels a bit like a fraud to use them cos we're not in Scotland, and we're not Scots! (does that make sense?!?!)

anyway, thank you all for taking the time to help us out!!

nappyaddict Wed 30-Sep-09 11:37:29

I don't think people would shorten Silas to Si. It would never have occurred to me to use that shortening anyway.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now