Talk

Advanced search

Ivy or Edith?

(25 Posts)
rachels103 Mon 01-Jun-09 22:39:17

What do you think? Probably either...
Edith Violet
or
Ivy Olivia

and whilst we're at it, is Joseph still really really popular around you?
I don't know any at the moment, either at the school I teach at or amongst DS1's friends.

JudyBlume1019 Mon 01-Jun-09 22:40:50

Love both, my dd is Edith, and bfs dd is Ivy. Edith Violet is gorgeous

BoysAreLikeDogs Mon 01-Jun-09 22:42:19

Edith

Rindercella Mon 01-Jun-09 22:43:14

I love both. Funnily enough, my grandmother was Ivy & her sister was Edith. Must be why I love them grin

I know a lovely little girl called Ivy.

Haven't met any Joes/Josephs for a long time. Quite like it.

Bonneville Mon 01-Jun-09 22:44:16

Love Love love Edith, Violet and Ivy. (all old aunties of mine). Good proper sensible names. Not like all this made-up rubbish people are saddling their children with!

clemette Mon 01-Jun-09 22:45:49

Like both, but think Ivy Olivia is a bit of a mouthful...

bargainhuntingbetty Mon 01-Jun-09 22:46:10

My dd's middle name is Ivy and the poor child called herself X Library when she was wee.

LaDiDaDi Mon 01-Jun-09 22:47:30

Edith Olivia for me.

I think that Joseph is still pretty popular. I know 3 baby Joseph's.

angrypixie Mon 01-Jun-09 22:48:49

Not Poison Ivy
Edith/Edie lovely

Yes, lots of Josephs in my part of London

Lulubee Mon 01-Jun-09 22:57:16

Prefer Edith to Ivy, Ivy does still have the 'poison' connotation. Also it's a small dark creeping plant. Edith is gorgeous.

MadBadandDangerousToKnow Mon 01-Jun-09 23:07:26

Edith Violet is a gorgeous combination.

Ivy Olivia isn't, in my opinion. Ivy is quite ugly (in every sense) and there are a zillion Olivias around here (which would put me off).

Lots of Josephs around here too.

BanjoMyFanjo Mon 01-Jun-09 23:08:42

Edie, a wonderful name.

mumtoted Mon 01-Jun-09 23:10:23

Ivy and Edith sound like old ladies in curlers on Coronation Street. Olivia is nice, quite popular and Violet is pretty until it gets shortened to Vi.

Deemented Tue 02-Jun-09 07:00:46

Ivy will always have the connetation with Ivy Tilesly for me, i'm afraid.

And Edith... well.. i think someones been watching too much Balamory... grin

ninedragons Tue 02-Jun-09 07:32:41

I love Edith. DH vetoed it and there's still a part of me that resents it.

Ivy Olivia is too echo-ey with the i and v sounds.

womma Tue 02-Jun-09 15:25:22

Both lovely. My DD's middle name is Ivy after my mum.

womma Tue 02-Jun-09 15:27:02

Has anyone seen Grey Gardens? I toyed with Edie for DD but decided against it after seeing GG!

MaggieBee Tue 02-Jun-09 16:05:43

Just personal taste but I prefer Edith. I think it's a prettier sound.

sockmonster Tue 02-Jun-09 16:18:26

I wouldn't use them, but I think Edith is best, I really really like Edie as a nn.
Ivy is a bit scary!

I also like Violet though, as a first name.

Don't personally know any LOs named Joseph.

Horton Tue 02-Jun-09 16:42:12

Edith is gorgeous and I love Violet, too.

peppapig3 Tue 02-Jun-09 20:27:49

Well, I love Ivy although I don't think it works well with Olivia. How about Ivy Sophia? Edith is okay but not a personal favourite. Violet is lovely too!

FairLadyRantALot Tue 02-Jun-09 20:31:28

Ivy wins hands down grin...it's such a beautyful name

MoooCow Tue 02-Jun-09 21:19:52

edith violet for me, just gorgeous! mine are bethany may and isla rose, i think it's important how a name goes together.....

KAEKAE Wed 03-Jun-09 16:56:59

no not my cup of tea...Ivy is ok, but but I just think of it as evil for some reason.

rachels103 Wed 03-Jun-09 20:40:14

I prefer Edith too, and dh loves it. All the poison ivy references have really put me off Ivy now - I'd never thought of it like that before. I know a lovely little girl called Ivy and it was my grandmother's name as well.

The only thing with Edith is...if she's a cool, clever little thing then I think it's lovely, but what if she's not very confident - will having a slightly unusual and potentially old lady-ish name be miserable for her?

This is probably hypothetical as I'm pretty convinced it's a boy. I thought we'd settled on Joseph but DH is now unsure...3 weeks to go and back to the drawing board on that one then <sigh>

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now