Talk

Advanced search

help/opinion of girl names..........how about madeleine?

(27 Posts)
jkb Sat 17-Jan-09 19:34:46

Hi

Im 29 weeks pregnant & expecting a little girl.. my son is called Benjamin..
I love the name Madeleine..however, my hubby thinks everyone will think of poor little madeleine mccann.??? what do you think? will it be a horrid name/asociation for her?? Or do you think hes being silly?

I also quite like:
Isabel
Abigail
Chloe

I want her name to sound pretty... & not chavvy.. so when you hear it, you think of a nice little girl from a nice family..

any opinions?

Tortoise Sat 17-Jan-09 19:36:05

How about just Elaine instead? smile

stillenacht Sat 17-Jan-09 19:37:18

I love Madeleine - thats my second favourite girls name after Ella.

twoluvlykids Sat 17-Jan-09 19:38:29

my dd is Madeline, she's usually called Mad or Maddie

choosyfloosy Sat 17-Jan-09 19:38:42

Well, I like Madeleine and don't think the association will be made by the time she's older, but your dh obviously doesn't like it as much, and that matters.

You're very honest about what you are looking for in a name. If you're worried about associations, why not go for a very neutral/timeless name such as Catherine, Mary, Elizabeth, Jane or Sarah.

SniffyHock Sat 17-Jan-09 19:39:28

As long as you are happy with the shortening of Maddy as someone will use it.

twoluvlykids Sat 17-Jan-09 19:39:37

You can also spell it Madelaine or Madelyn
so no associations

jkb Sat 17-Jan-09 19:44:15

Thanku all.. hubby does like the name.. just worried about what people will think of when they hear it....
i also realy do like the shortened form... MADDIE.. think thats really pretty too? But just dont to let what I like give my daughter a name where people may think im a weirdo for chossing it after the MCCANN thing.

twoluvlykids Sat 17-Jan-09 19:45:57

if your surname doesn't begin with M, or sound like McCann, I wouldn't worry too much.

It's only a name.

Cies Sat 17-Jan-09 19:46:24

I don't think that those associations will carry on for very long.

Other names you might like:
Lucinda
Catherine
Charlotte
Fiona
Georgina
Isabella
Elizabeth
Victoria

Smithagain Sat 17-Jan-09 19:46:41

I know two children called Madelaine/Maddy and to be honest I hadn't made the connection. It's a nice name.

I liked Abigail for DD2, but she arrived just after Abigail Witchalls was stabbed. She lived very locally and I decided not to use it because it seemed a bit weird.

But three years later, I think I really could have done. Things do move on and it's not as if it's a really obscure name.

cuddlemum Sat 17-Jan-09 21:28:27

I think that people may well be reminded of Maddie McCann at the moment but that will fade with time.
Personally, I don't like the name Madeline anyway.
My favourite is Isabel which I think is v pretty and classic, although it is v popular at the moment if that bothers you.

meandjoe Sun 18-Jan-09 06:31:57

i love maddie, i'd use it if you like it tbh. there will always be some horrible association with some most names if you look hard enough. by the time she's at school it's not like any of her friends will remember the story or have any knowledge of it. i hate the name abigail but probably cos it's my name! lol, do like abby though.

RachieB Tue 20-Jan-09 23:14:45

I prefer Maddison

MrsMerryHenry Tue 20-Jan-09 23:20:54

Gorgeous. Doesn't matter what name you choose, there's always someone who has a bad association with it. So just go for it; it's a beautiful name.

daisy5 Wed 21-Jan-09 11:13:49

There is a girl called Madeleine in my daughters class, and it never occurred to me to associate her with the McCann girl. If it were a really unique name, then maybe, but it is familiar enough that I cannot see why.

daisy5 Wed 21-Jan-09 11:27:00

...and we even holiday down that part of the world and have closely followed the case, and still - I just don't make that connection.

lastboxoftampons Wed 21-Jan-09 11:31:44

I love it. I'd be more concerned over its popularity than the McCann reference though. Lots of little girls are named Maddie (either some form of Madeleine or Madison) these days.

I also love Isabel! smile

skyblu Wed 21-Jan-09 11:35:35

When I first read you post the connection honestly didn't occur to me either.

I just thought 'Benjamin & Madeleine - Ben & Maddie, that's really nice!'

Only thought of the McCann connection because you mentioned it.

From your list, I also realy like Abigail.

suwoo Wed 21-Jan-09 11:40:10

My 7 year old is Madeleine. There were a few comments at the time of the disappearance but nothing recently. The worst was when we were om holiday in Majorca that summer, everytime we called her- people's heads would spin round and stare.
Its a lovely name IMO.

Nancy66 Wed 21-Jan-09 12:00:39

I think it's a lovely name and, as sad as it is to say it, the Madeline McGann connection will fade over the coming years.

NellyTheElephant Wed 21-Jan-09 13:40:21

That is my DDs name, so obviously I think it is a lovely name! She was born a month or so before the Madeleine McCann disappearance, (which I have to say hit ME very hard at the time), however I do find it a bit bizarre to think that people will associate your daughter with that tragedy, I really don't think that it works like that - they will see your daughter as herself. It's not an issue I have ever encountered anyway.

PuppyMonkey Wed 21-Jan-09 13:47:04

I've got a 12-year-old called Madeleine (she is always called Maddie) - so just remember, I thought of it first. wink

It's not too common where I live at all. I have heard of just one a couple of years younger than my dd. I like it that way.

Never once has anyone expressed horror about the connection with Madeleine McCann.

It's way, way nicer than Madison, imho. But that's maybe because we had a dodgy nightclub called Madison's where I grew up. grin

Fimbo Wed 21-Jan-09 13:50:50

Lots of Madeleine's at ds's school.

Nice classic names are

Anna
Katherine

TheStatueOfLiffey Wed 21-Jan-09 13:55:41

I like Madeleine but it does make me think of McCann.

Isabel - quite like prefer rarer Annabel
Abigail - Abby ok, also like Libby short for Elizabeth
Chloe - ok, much prefer Zoe!

Zoe and Ben would be lovely.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now