Talk

Advanced search

opinions please on Catherine or Eliza for dd2

(18 Posts)
fragglema Fri 11-Jul-08 12:12:31

Surname is Taylor, middle name would be Genovefa (after my Polish gran), dd1 is called Lila, and we are at completely undecided and have been for the past 8 months- please tell me what you think of these names, I think they are both lovely and cant choose at all.....

TheFallenMadonna Fri 11-Jul-08 12:18:08

I prefer Eliza, but rather than Lila and Eliza, which would be a mouthful, I'd go for Catherine, which is also a smashing name smile

StellaDallas Fri 11-Jul-08 12:18:13

Eliza, definitely.

youngbutnotdumb Fri 11-Jul-08 12:20:19

Catherine Genovefa doesnt sound right to me but then again neither does Eliza Genovefa, Ellie Genovefa is nice (slightly similair to Eliza LOL.) Anyways is up to you dont listen to me or anyone else on here we all nit pick LOL.

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TigerFeet Fri 11-Jul-08 12:21:42

Agree with TheFallenMadonna - prefer Eliza as a name but Catherine works better with Lila and also, imo, with Genovefa

Catherine is a fine, upstanding name. Many, many wonderful people are called Catherine wink

schneebly Fri 11-Jul-08 12:22:10

Catherine is the best name grin Yes it is my name.

Eliza is okay I guess...wink

TigerFeet Fri 11-Jul-08 12:22:48

<waves at fellow Catherines> grin

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LaDiDaDi Fri 11-Jul-08 14:39:24

I actualy prefer Eliza as a name but I like Catherine too and it definitely goes better with Lila.

Lila and Eliza are too similar for siblings imo.

kitkat9 Fri 11-Jul-08 15:36:39

I have a Catherine, we shorten it to Katie, we love it. She can be a cute Katie as a child, then, if she wants when she's older she can be Kate, or Catherine (I think they sound 'older' somehow).

Eliza is pretty too though! Think Catherine is more classic though. And timeless.

Anna8888 Fri 11-Jul-08 15:37:36

Eliza is very sweet and pretty.

Catherine is pretty but more boring.

GreenElizabeth Fri 11-Jul-08 18:24:51

I prefer Eliza. Catherine is really dull (JMo)
But I do like Katya. could you do Katherine wih a K, and Katya for short?

I wouldn't be able to choose between Eliza and Katya. Well, I'd choose Eliza because I prefer its full name.

hth a bit

princessglitter Fri 11-Jul-08 18:26:28

I love Catherine. Tis dd2's middle name.

Janni Fri 11-Jul-08 18:28:04

They're both nice names.

I prefer Catherine.

FabioTheLiterateCat Fri 11-Jul-08 18:28:26

Eliza's nice but too like Lila.
Catherine's one of those names that's nice but not very common anymore.

AbbeyA Fri 11-Jul-08 18:29:12

Both lovely.

cherrylips Fri 11-Jul-08 19:01:50

Waves to other Catherine/Katharines !! grin
I prefer Catherine - its a beautiful name, a timeless classic, and can be shortened to lots of groovey nick names. Trina, Tina, Reenie, Cate, Katie, Kate, Kitty.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now